News
Haifa: Chevra Kadisha director shot to death
Ahiya Raved
Published: 16.01.11, 23:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Shot to death and critically wounded
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.16.11)
Well, which is it?
2. Sloppy Police work...
Al   (01.17.11)
Attributed this to 'criminal activity' without any evidence whatsoever. Send these bozo police back to school. They havent got a clue. This could easily have been a terrorist attack as well.
3. #1 Have some respect Sarah BS!!
Ken ,   Burma   (01.17.11)
4. Hesse's murder
LT COL HOWARD ,   WASHINGTON DC USA   (01.17.11)
All of Israel should be shocked and saddened by Hesse's murder. All factions should demand a thorough investigation to root out this evil and to make sure that it does not happen again. The shock and outrage that followed the murder of Prime Minister Rabin was warranted. This murder also demands widespread public outrageā€¦ a thorough investigationā€¦ extensive measures to prevent this from happening again in the future, etc.
5. Could be a dissatisfied customer?
jason white ,   afula,israel   (01.17.11)
6. "He cleaned house up" what exactly did he do?
Josh   (01.17.11)
"The problem is that all is lawless in this country" Amen, including the religious leaders. Certainly he could have used a little more protection from G-d and a lot less protecxia in this country. Was it a dati person that did this based on some Rabbinical tracate or a outright secular thug? I hope they find out whoever did this antiTorah thing.
7. The sequence of events usually is
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.17.11)
1) Shooting 2) wounding 3) Death, when wounds are fatal It doesn't need Sherlock Holmes to figure that out Now, let him rest in peace
8. Hevre kadishe
Max   (01.17.11)
The hevre kadisha are cesspools of corruption that (along with religious political parties) give Judaism a bad name.
9. CPR for nearly 40 minutes, IN the FIELD?
observer   (01.17.11)
is that political technique or religious one? What exactly is the Job of a hospital in Haifa? the rescuing should be as condemned as should be the murder.
10. #2
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (01.17.11)
Why? Terrorists taking the trouble to single this guy out? Really. You don't want to admit that Jews kill Jews?
11. # 8 Max
Sagi   (01.17.11)
Religion and religious fervour engender corruption. Corruption is a natural sequitur of religious practices and proceedings. This is not my opinion but rather fact substaniated by a few thousand years of proven track record.
12. "Background remains unclear"
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.17.11)
Are you kidding?! "Israel" should learn form Benny Hesse how to clean its Background
13. To Ken No. 3,
dotty ,   gilgil, kenya   (01.17.11)
Didn't ypu know Sarah B 's ears are on the ground to listen to everithing that goes in and out of israel? to comment just for the sake of.........?
14. #12 can the Shin Bet assassinate Jews?
observer   (01.17.11)
15. Agree with Max #8
R ,   Israel   (01.17.11)
I'm totally getting buried on some kibbutz, even if it costs more.
16. I forgot to mention
R ,   Israel   (01.17.11)
Condolenses to Mr. Hesse's family. It shounds like he was a good guy, a very good and capable guy, and didn't deserve this.
17. looks like mob work
Don   (01.17.11)
he probably refused to help dispose of a body...........
18. 8 stereotypes!
ORA ,   Jerusalem   (01.17.11)
Unfortunately,there is corruption in all groups that have power.
19. #9 NON-OBSERVER SOUNDS OFF
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.17.11)
Yes, in the field, if they took the time to get him to the hospital without providing CPR first, he would have been dead on arrival He was shot & bleeding, leaking vital body fluids When a person, for example, has a heart attack, they first try to revive him on the scene, then transport him to a hospital repeat the following medical phrase slowly ohwatagoosiam
20. #14 NON-OBSERVER'S QUESTION
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.17.11)
When you're pretending to make observations, you should be making statements not asking dumb questions In fact, after viewing your missives for the past couple of months, I've come to the conclusion that is YOU who needs observation First have the medics check in your overhead (Caine Mutiny Court Martial) to see if the find the loose nuts I suspect are rolling around
21. #17 Somebody had a grudge
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.17.11)
If the problem is body disposal, there's plenty of ocean outside of Haifa or lots of sand dunes, with easy digging, quite close by
22. #19,20 changing doctrine of emergency treatment
observer   (01.17.11)
The injury that killed Princess Diana although critical was not fatal and in fact former President Ronald Reagan, 70 YO, survived a similar injury when he was shot in 1981. why not a 36 year old woman in good health? it is very highly likely that if Princess Diana had been rushed to a hospital immediately instead of being snail-paced for two hours in an ambulance she will still be alive today! Several eminent doctors from around the globe (including French physicians) agreed that a timely evacuation to the hospital would have probably saved the Princess! the real reason why the ambulance journey took so long; the plotters (Shin Bet in case of Hesse)were waiting for Princess Diana to bleed out before presenting her to other personnel not privy or involved in the plot (waiting hospital staff). it's free eduction.
23. #22 NON-OBSERVER
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.18.11)
Circumstances weren't at all similar Benny Hesse, director of Ashkenazi Chevra Kadisha was shot several times, in all probability by a 9MM, Reagan was shot once with a .22 Princess Di was an accident Your basic problem is that you claim to observe, yet you're incapable of absobring Of course, if you had been on the scene, the ambulance attendants could have partaken of your non-existent wisdom
24. #22 Shcizo -
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.18.11)
You don't have the vaguest idea of the required protocols for EMS treatment are Diana was an accident Reagan was shot once with a .22 The Chevra Kadisha victim was shot several times, most probably with a 9MM, even thought the story didn't say it, because the 9MM is the most common sidearm in Israel Read the following slowly, so it will sink in, notice the first step is stabilization (you could use some, you seem to be rather unstable) emergency medical service (EMS), a network of services coordinated to provide aid and medical assistance from primary response to definitive care, involving personnel trained in the rescue, STABILIZATION, transportation, and advanced treatment of traumatic or medical emergencies. Linked by a communication system that operates on both a local and a regional level, EMS is a tiered system of care, which is usually initiated by citizen action in the form of a telephone call to an emergency number. Subsequent stages include the emergency medical dispatch, first medical responder, ambulance personnel, medium and heavy rescue equipment, and paramedic units, if necessary. In the hospital, service is provided by emergency department nurses, emergency department physicians, specialists, and critical care nurses and physicians. See also emergency medical technician, emergency medical technician-advanced life support, emergency medical technician-intermediate, emergency medical technician-intravenous, emergency medical technician-paramedic For you to give education of any sort, first you have to find out what you're talking about, you simply don't know STABILIZATION IS FIRST, TRANSPORTATION COMES AFTER IT Now, be a nice fellow, chase yourself around the block
25. #1 orthodox too wounding, too killing
observer   (01.18.11)
26. #24 it is all about the Shin Bet!
observer   (01.18.11)
27. #26 NON-OBSERVER
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.18.11)
Yes, it's the Shin Bet, don't forget to look under your bed at night they may be lurking to eat you You have a fixation with Ambulances and medical procedures, curried from your vast store of knowing exactly nothing Pls. go seek Observation, before you harm yourself or some innocent people
Back to article