Opinion
Confront the hypocrisy
Manfred Gerstenfeld
Published: 17.01.11, 12:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. they can just say mossad did it
ronen   (01.17.11)
and their followers in both east and west will accept that. even if they dont believe it. why do we feel the constant need to clear our name before the west? our friends dont demand us to do so. and our enemies are scum. so what are we doing this for?
2. Islam doesn't threaten Christianity's legitimacy
Howard K   (01.17.11)
Judaism does. No need to go into specifics but there have been in-depth studies done by Christians themselves attesting to the fact that Christianity is a manufactured religion that persecuted Judaism because it was competing with them. There was a lot of very successful Jewish proselitizing all over Europe at the time of Christ and for a couple of hundred years after that. Christianity used Jewish history and tradition to give itself cache' and validity (as did Islam too). Islam, on the other hand is no legitimacy threat but an ideological and military one, with their forced conversions in Africa, Asia and other places. Their advances in the west are too slow to alarm them. But Judaism is the Christians' nightmare because of its authenticity. They want to erase it from the world so that there won't be any more question that Christianity is the true religion. That explains the Holocaust, the west's war against Israel, and their blaming Israel for the plight of Christians in the PA and Gaza. In very simple words, they want to kill the father (Judaism) so as to take full power and control of the inheritance. The Vatican already holds a great deal of Jewish treasures and won't let go of them. .
3. THIS IS TRUE
BENJAMIN ,   SINGAPORE   (01.17.11)
Yes, I agree that xtians are being persecuted around the world too, infact to be precise in Muslim Nations due to Islamic Extremism. But not all Muslim are bad rotten apple , in Malaysia, the Malsyain Govt went hard on the Extremist that bomb the churches ( many churchs were set a blaze). BTW, on the issue of Xtians Churces being treated wit indifference- TRUE ALSO, this is by one reason- that these xtain churces vary in terms of doctrine and very denominational. Just like we jew wont agree easly with the azka, shepardi etc. I think we Israeli find it is easier to to TALK TO the catholics , I think the Catholics are the most organised instituition among the many denomination of xtians. Egypt has become a DODO of SYSTEM. What is Copt ? Is it the Coptic Churches ? Their Coptic Churces are ancient churches. I have been fro a wedding in Cappadocia , Oyo so loud their prayer, that we jews loose. Ok the point is it is hight time we Jews step in safe the Catholics. It is the Catholic Churches that is being hit hard by THE ISLAMIC EXTREMIST TERRORIST ! ben singapore
4. Anti Semitic Xtn Tourism In Israel
AntiSemiticTourism ,   china and israel   (01.17.11)
At this very moment all over Israel thousands of American and European Christian tourists are being sent to hear vicious anti Israel lectures calling for its demise by major Protetant denominations such as the United Methodist Church the Episcopal Lutheran and others to organizations like Sabeel The Bethlehem Bible College Augusta Victoria Lutheran Hospital on the Mount of Olives & St Georges Anglican Cathedral many of these lectures take place in Israeli Hotels such as the Olive Tree and others in Jerusalem these "tour groups" are aided and abetted by the Israeli Ministry of TOurism all in the name of "Democracy'Anarchy is what it is .Even in America such people would be put on a plane and sent packing. We are our own best enemies who ever would have thought the State of Israel would be the launching platform for anti Semitism ?
5. Howard K # 2
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (01.17.11)
There is nothing that threatens the legitimacy of Christianity. The Jews are in no way a threat to Christians. We are not out to erase other religions as you say, that would be the Muslims. I don't know any Christians that feel the way you say we do. True Christians respect the Jews and are on their side. True Christians know that it is the Jews that are Gods chosen people. I don't know where you get your information but you are wrong.
6. #2 Howard, good point & 2 billion Muslims/10 million Jews
JMK ,   NYC   (01.17.11)
7. they are both
Fadi ,   Lebanon .   (01.17.11)
transitional religions to Islam ..they both came to a specific people ..specific time ..and the clergies and rabbies were the entrusted mechanism to preserve the holy books . Islam is the message to Humanity ..till the Judgement day and God himself said In the Quran that he will preserve it till then . get you numbers straight H Islam is not speading SLOW in europe ..unless that would make you feel better ..then it is OK .
8. To all Christians reading this article - ISRAEL LOVES YOU !!
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (01.17.11)
WE WANT YOU TO KNOW THIS - ESPECIALLY THE EVANGELLICALS - THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR SUPPORT OVER THE LAST COUPLE YEARS - YOU WERE OUR ONLY REAL FRIENDS (AND YES IT WAS REAL) - WE LOVE YOU !!
9. A note to Philistine Christians..
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (01.17.11)
read your bible and ask - are these people occupiers?? we cant understand why you cant reconsile this basic truth and keep calling us occupiers - its not philistine history in that book
10. Andrew @ 8 and 9...Thanks, BUT YOU DONT CONVERT JEWS....
BENJAMIN ,   SINGAPORE   (01.17.11)
stop it......you better STOP It ! :-) ANDREW I PERSONALLY THANK YOU FOR YOUR KIND SUPPORT FOR US/ ISRAELI AND THE DIASPORA. WITH FRIENDSHIP BENJAMIN SINGAPORE
11. #2 Excellent you touched a raw nerve!
RawNerveTouchedOuch! ,   china and israel   (01.17.11)
Fantastic article you have obviously touched a raw nerve/and those claiming numerical superiority obviously dont know they got those numbers via violence and abuse of governmental power both Islam and Christianity.Let them keep their numbers we'll keep our integrity and truth the world prefers to ignore
12. While #2 is right, the biggest reason is... (2nd try)
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.17.11)
that Islam is not idolatry. Man-god worship is idolatry. Judaism can get along with our cousins who simply have ill-informed beliefs that merely contradict historical documentation and Torah. But Christianity is avodah zarah (idolatry), which Torah explicitly commands is incompatible with His people. If Christians want to be welcome the way is simple, follow the historical Pharisee Ribi who taught Torah--instead of the post-135 C.E. Hellenist Roman (Christian) counterfeit man-god and idol you are following--and you'll have shed the idolatry and can be welcomed with the hope of learning Torah, the same hope we have for our Arab cousins and the hope for rest of the world. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer & Orthodox Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, ynet has refused to post it. Ck our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
13. Fadi, don't change the original for the fake ;-)
Yossef   (01.17.11)
14. This makes sense
J K ,   NYC, USA   (01.17.11)
Why should Israel get slammed? Because people expect better of the Jews? Why do the Arabs who treat them worse get a pass? Because no-one expects anything from the Arabs. Who is really in the worse situation? It isn't Israel...thats for sure.
15. #7 Fadi, I know telling you this is useless
Howard K   (01.17.11)
if Islam is the message to Humanity, I say to the rest of us let's run for the hills!!! This is not personal, as you understand, we're just talking ideas here, but the ideas and practice of Islam scare the heck out of me. It's not as simple as keeping the Christian proselitizers at bay and of suffering their verbal attacks here and there. Islam is out to kill Jews and Christians if we're ever in their power and fail to convert. The small non Muslim minorities in Muslim countries are all subjugated and living in fear and often under violent attack. Lebanon used to be a Christian country once but no more. So the message is convert or else. Some message!
16. 5 Torah Declares Christianity False (Dt. 13.1-6)
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.17.11)
That is why the original (post-135 CE) Roman Church and Christians vilified Jews, burned the Torah scrolls & Jewish genealogical registers and killed any Jew who dared teach or study Torah. Please learn your own Christian history. For starters, read the late Oxford historian, James Parkes (The Conflict of the Church and the Synagogue). You're not alone, you're like most Christians: unaware of your Christian history and doctrines and unaware that that Torah and Torah Jews contradict the legitimacy of Christianity. But your lack of awareness doesn't change the fact. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer & Orthodox Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, ynet has refused to post it. Ck our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
17. 9 "Palestinians" are Arabs, Philistines were Greeks
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.17.11)
I appreciate your sentiments but, historically, Philistines were of Greek origin, ethnicity and extraction. The local Arab squatters and occupiers are not Greek and have no historical Philistine claim. There is not even any remote connection between the two. The Arabs simply squatted on this land after the Romans expelled Yehudim (Judeans / Jews) from Yehudah (JUDEA) and renamed it Palestine--in 135 CE; the same date, BTW, that the (gentile) Roman Christians ousted the Netzarim Jews and their 15th Paqid from Yerushalayim and displaced him with their own, first gentile bishop, Marcus (according to the earliest extant Christian Church historian, Eusebius). Before 135 CE, the Holy Land was known as Jews know it today: Yehudah (Judea) and the Shomron (Samaria). The local Arab occupiers and squatters in our Holy Land today don't even have a proper claim to "Palestinian," which, from 1948 until recent years, referred to the Jews here in the Holy Land. Until recent years, Arabs refused to be called "Palestinians," insisting that they all belonged to one pan-Arab people. Study up for yourself on this recent history. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer & Orthodox Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, ynet has refused to post it. Ck our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
18. Palestinian Christians -> Israeli Citizenship
George   (01.17.11)
If Israel gives Palestinian Christians the right of return and an Israeli Citizenship in order to Create a Jewish-Christian State in the middle east. Then and only then you will see how the Palestinian struggle will end, for those that move and order the arab molecules are the Palestinian Christians in the Diaspora (Muslims can't think on their own) .
19. Ignorance
olavi ,   espoo, finland   (01.17.11)
The Coptics may be quite the inheritance of ancient Egypt. They may be able to build permanent communities with skills. That is one reason they are hated. On the contrary the arabs are permanently unable to build any kind of fuctional society. They are deemed to be eternal losers.
20. to 19
nadia   (01.17.11)
the truth is c0ptics or moslemes in egypt are so proud to be egyptions even if they leve the country to any where if they are rich or poor //all of them say -egypt is the mother of the world //once in haj i asked an old woman -from whee you are ? she said /from egypt /i said -yes from where of that country /she said /from egypt evry one in this world knows egypt // they are so proud of egypt more than the religion // it is egypt not funland
21. to 8
sahla ,   jerusalem   (01.17.11)
iam not cristian but people here and there love me ..why you do not ??iam sahla a good girl
22. Many Christians going back to Jewish roots
Claudia USA ,   Tampa, FL   (01.17.11)
for we see the church & many protestant denominations have strayed too far from the intentions of Yeshua and original Disciples. Yeshua said he was not there to change Judaism yet those that followed did far too much to attract followers, and later the Roman Catholics for power sold out Jewish belief system which too many found difficult to adhere to. Today we are left with a Christianity of the liberals and the Vatican that I want nothing to do with. We are banding with Evangelicals that emphasize old testament scripture and the teachings of Yeshua. I hope that gives us more empathy for our Jewish brothers to where all we disagree with is the divinity of Yeshua. That is a big enough hundle! We are not at odds with Judaism, it is our fundamental belief system. Yeshua was a Jew, lived his life as a Jew, and that is what so many of us lose sight of.
23. Paqid # 16
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (01.17.11)
I am not a Catholic. I don't consider the people that persecuted Jews either in the name of a church or in the name of Christianity to be Christians. I am quite aware of the evils done in the name of Christianity. The people that do them are not Christians. I am not worried about you questioning the legitimacy of Christianity. I answer to God and his son Jesus, not to you or anyone else. Someday all will know the truth.
24. George #18 why?
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (01.17.11)
Why should we help them? Please explain it to me. The 'Palestinian' Christians have sided with the Muslims against us at every single opportunity. They have done their level best to aid and support genocide. Now you think we should aid them? I think not - they made their choices and now have to live or die with them. We owe them nothing and have gotten the same in return. Let's keep it that way. There are 2 billion Christians in the world and over 50 Christian countries. Another 56 Muslim countries and only one Jewish one. We cannot and will not be the solution to your problems.
25. 22 Claudia: Bravo
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.17.11)
You'll find a wealth of material to help you learn the most in the shortest time in our website (URL below). For instance, "Old Testament" implies obsolescence caused by supersession by the Christian "New Testament." It's offensive. The proper term is Tanakh. You can find details in our website. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer & Orthodox Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, ynet has refused to post it. Ck our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
26. 23 Historical Church, not your opinion, defines Christianity
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.17.11)
I commend you for your stand. But you should recognize that the Roman Catholic Church has defined Christianity from the beginning (135 CE). Your disagreement with their doctrines doesn't mean that you have authority to redefine Christianity and, therefore, they are not Christians. The fact is that they are the true Christians. Rather, you need to recognize that your disagreement with, and being different from, those original Christian doctrines means that you're the one not a Christian--and that's good! Get rid of the Christian festival to the sun-god, the festival to Ashtoret, Roman idol-worship, etc. Learn how to follow the historical Ribi Yehoshua--who taught Torah--in our website, especially in our History Museum. All the best to you... and also to #22. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer & Orthodox Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, ynet has refused to post it. Ck our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
27. #24 because we should
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (01.18.11)
Many Christians are native to Israel and many of them (unlike the Muslims) have been living in Israel since the time of the Roman occupation. Now, Christians in all of the Middle East are in grave danger of physical and cultural extermination at the hands of Islam, look at the Christian population of Gaza and Bethlehem ever since Israel surrendered these lands to Muslim rule. It is a moral imperative to save these people. I would go further than George, and suggest that there be a population exchange: Muslims living in Israel (including Judea and Samaria) who refuse to accept Israeli rule move back to their homelands Lebanon, Syria and Iraq and Israel accept Christian refugees instead.
28. they are so afraid of Arabs/muslims but not of Jews......
rachel   (01.18.11)
in other word they are cowards
29. #26
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (01.18.11)
2nd attempt / shorter version. The true Christians are those who follow Jesus, not those who follow the Church of Rome. There are certainly Christians among the Catholics but being a Christian is based on a persons relationship with Jesus, not with any church. I like you, but I find it as strange that a Jew thinks himself an authority on what makes a Christian. It's like having a gentile acting as an authority on what makes a Jew. I truely wish you well.
30. Local Christian Leaders Spread Hate
HateFilledBishops ,   china and israel   (01.18.11)
The Patriachs and Bishops of the local Arab Greek and Armenian Churches are the leaders in spreading the hate of Jews and Israel they host thousands of tourists here with their "horror" stories then attend official functions at the Knesset such hypocrisy and evil. The titles are misleading the Bishops' of the Anglican and Lutherans are lucky if they fill their empty churches with a dozen people on a Sunday yet their titles allow them to spread their blind hate near and far.THey need to be called out ! Many of their own flocks are embarrassed by them.
Next talkbacks
Back to article