News
Medvedev reaffirms Soviet recognition of Palestine
Elior Levy
Published: 18.01.11, 16:36
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
111 Talkbacks for this article
31. #14 THE LION
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.18.11)
truth is not always easy to take but it bites worst to ignore it . tell me my LION , What's better for you ? a lie that draws a smile, or the truth that draws a tear. Wonder When will "Israel" smile to the truth ?! We're Here to Stay.
32. RUSSIA
(01.18.11)
Russia playing games according to the Arabs tunes,and secondly POLITICS is dirty game.
33. Sarah B
(01.18.11)
Russia were playing Russian roulette since 1988,and did not have time for the Arabs
34. 31 Salma
JUDAH THE LION   (01.18.11)
You can stay in our country there is no problem,but you must obey the LAW OF THE LAND
35. How important could it be?
Eli   (01.18.11)
It barely got mentioned on Galei Tzahal.
36. #12 Rochester the snow froze yr brain
KickTheConsulatsOut! ,   china and israel   (01.18.11)
THere is no such thing as "Russian properties " the properties are tax paying to the state of Israel.
37. ... so this is what Lieberman's friend has to say!...
Frank ,   Israel   (01.18.11)
... I guess like Lieberman, he says what he thinks........., so if we admire Lieberman for it, then surely we have to admire Medvedev too?
38. RECOGNIZE
POPPY   (01.18.11)
IT IS OBSURD HOW CAN YOU RECOGNISE PALASTIAN STATE IF THERE ISNT ONE. IS EVERYONE IN THE WORLD GOING CRAZY? THERE IS NO PALASTIAN STATE AND THERE WILL NEVER BE ONE UNTIL THE WORLD REALISES THAT ISRAEL CAPITAL IS JERUSALEM AND ISRAEL IS HERE TO STAY. THE WORLD WILL COME TO AN END IF ISRAEL DISAPPEARS
39. #19 Kate ,
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.18.11)
Just take care of "IDF" soldiers, for the occasion of this good news I suggest to send them a Russian red wine , Not all time Pizza ; )
40. Wissam 28
JUDAH THE LION   (01.18.11)
There will never be sanction against Israel,and should there be one,I can give GUARANTEE that the Palestinians will suffer more than us.The world will not go to WAR with ISRAEL because of you.NO WAY Wissam this land is not occupied,but been LIBERATED by the Real owner the JEWS. Check with you Koran.
41. Palestine
PAL   (01.18.11)
40 thousand Russia peacekeepers, 40 EU " " and 20 US " "
42. #21 So you've also decided I'm happy?
Salma (the real) ,   Palestine   (01.18.11)
Not enough for you to impersonate me?
43. To: No. 28
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.18.11)
Dream on. Economic and cultural sanctions just are not going to happen because Israel has too much to offer the world in terms of advanced technology, medicine, modern agricultural technology in drought-stricken regions, et cetera, et cetera. It is a very long list. You people, on the other hand, have contributed nothing to the world except violence and terrorism. No one -- and I do mean NO ONE -- is going to turn international precedent and international law on its ear to accommodate a fractious terrorist rabble that spends as much time killing one another as it does trying to kill Jews. NO ONE. They'll pay you just enough lip service to keep aggressive and belligerent Moslem minorities in their countries at bay, and then that's it. You will be at Israel's mercy and, frankly, we are not feeling particularly generous. I hope you look good naked. Might want to start working on those abs before September.
44. To: No. 30
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.18.11)
Laugh away. Last I checked, Israel controls Jerusalem and you lot don't have a state. Tee hee. Do you really, truly think that that is going to change? Israel will annex Judea and Samaria. Its Arab residents will be repatriated to Jordan. That's as generous as offer as you will get -- do you think we have forgotten that your leadership turned down the offer of 90% of the West Bank and East Jerusalem as a capital in 2000? You opted to start the second intifada instead. Didn't work out all that well for you, but no one has actually ever accused the ersatz "Palestinians" of being smart. You will not dislodge Israel. We know you have no intention of peaceful co-existence with your Jewish neighbors; you want only to supplant Israel. That just isn't going to happen.
45. To: No. 33
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.18.11)
I don't think anything's changed. They haven't acquitted themselves terribly well in Chechnya -- it's going rather badly for them there; very reminiscent of the foray into Afghanistan. We remember how that one turned out.
46. To: No. 39
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.18.11)
Israeli wine is far superior to anything produced in Russia. So we'll send some lovely wines to the IDF and a whole lot of crow to the ersatz "Palestinians."
47. Ready for freedom?
Brod ,   USA   (01.18.11)
What the scoundrels are saying is that they want freedom to commit more terrorist acts and shooting rockets at Israel. The world of AntiSemites and Islamist-Jihadists shares a common goal of exterminating Israel as they did in the Holocaust. Israel should NOT be fooled by their crap.
48. Salma no 39
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (01.18.11)
Salma your suggestion to send a Russian red wine,well,Russia dont make good wine, but =======. There is fantastic KOSHER WINES which comes from a place called GOLAN HEIGHT.Once you try this wine,you will never drink any other wine The best of the best
49. Russian aid
JUDAH THE LION   (01.18.11)
The Russian leader would grant PA with $10 million. Insult to the PA only $10 million from very WEALTHY COUNTRY.SHAME
50. Sarah B , U.S.A. / Israel
Observer 1 ,   Biu, Nigeria   (01.18.11)
Dear Sarah, let the Hakims, the Wissams, the Salmas, the Nours, the Dougs, and their ilk go get a new life because the one they are living right now if full of hatred, antisemitism, total blindness, and utter illusions. That's a losers' life, believe me. Nonetheless let them make no mistake about it: they must just know that no matter what people like them say or do, ISRAEL has been here before anyone of them and will be here when they are long gone and forgotten. There's nothing they can do about it. Let not Russia only but 202 countries recognize Fakestine, let the whole universe recognize them, and the truth still remains forever: ISRAEL IS HERE AND JERUSALEM IS THE COVENANT CITY OF THE LORD that must forever remain ONE and INDIVISIBLE .
51. how can capital of state be outside its international border
observer   (01.18.11)
Jerusalem is outside the 1947 patition plane border for the Jewish state. East Jerusalem is outside the armstice line of 1949. So, the status of West Jerusalem should be defined as internationally disputed territory. No country has so far recognized Israeli sovereignty in either West or East Jerusalem. With regard to West Jerusalem, the European states have de facto accepted the applicability of Israeli law. The case of Yossele Schumacher; this young ultra-Orthodox boy was abducted in the 1960s by his father from Jerusalem to the United Kingdom. The British court applied the law in force in West Jerusalem, i.e., Israeli law. Interestingly, foreign states have not claimed that the law of occupation should apply to West Jerusalem." Another example is the Regency Hotel, formerly the Hyatt Hotel on Mount Scopus in Jerusalem. It is partly built in an area where there was an Israeli enclave from 1949 to 1967 and partly outside it. When official European representatives come to the hotel they go only into those parts located on land that belonged to this enclave.
52. China and Philippines likely next then Spain and EU in Sept.
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (01.18.11)
This trend was started by Vatican statements with Brazil leading the way. The US leadership, world influence and trade agreements are the main target, while Israel got caught in the Middle after peace talks died, the stopping of the second freeze may become very costly to Israel. Pro-Israel faction in Congress is strong but has limits and may well receive a backlash from Catholics in the coming months.
53. 41 Palestine
JUDAH THE LION   (01.18.11)
This Pal no 41 wrote QUOTE:40 thousand Russia peacekeepers,40 EU,and 20 US. Israel will not allow ONE SINGLE FOREIGN PEACEKEEPERS in Israel or Jerusalem.How they would come, by force,NO CHANCE in one million years.The world will not go to war for the sake of you Palestinians? Remember PAL,you are talking about the STATE OF ISRAEL. ISRAEL not BOSNIA,IRAQ,AFGHANISTAN. They will not DARE to open a war against Israel.
54. to nr. 24.
payer ,   planet earth.   (01.18.11)
you should be repatriated against your own will (forcefully). you can have your own land in antarctica or on the moon. bon voyage.
55. to nr. 27.
payer ,   planet earth   (01.18.11)
you are the ersatz sarah b.! go to geert wilders. have a nice day too.
56. To: No. 51
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.18.11)
A remarkably stupid question. Israel formally annexed East Jerusalem and environs in June 1967. Once annexed, those areas became part of the State of Israel. We don't care who does or does not recognize it. It is both de facto and de jure. By the way -- the case you refer to actually commenced in 1960, with the ultimate ruling being handed down in 1962. Israel did not control East Jerusalem in 1960 or 1962. The case is irrelevant to the current situation, i.e., a unified Jerusalem wholly controlled by Israel. Still co-opting other people's work without attribution, eh? Next time, try and pick an argument that is relevant.
57. To: No. 52
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.18.11)
Congress can take away the "most favored nation" trading status of any country, any time it wants. That would cripple China. You would do well to keep that in mind. I am certain that the Chinese are very well aware. The whole scenario is a tempest in a teapot. The ersatz "Palestinians" will be like all those uncrowned heads of Europe following both World Wars -- recognized governments perpetually in exile with no place to call home and no one ready to invade anyone else for the sake of those uncrowned heads.
58. For Talkbackers who wish to read the
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (01.18.11)
most powerful and articulate article I have yet to read on the mideast (Israel/Palestine) please go to pajamasmedia.com to a current article entitled "Is Peace Possible in the Mideast" by David Solway. The article confirms an opinion and perspective I've been grappling with the whole past year. Mr. Solway decisively analyzes why peace is not possible and why we (Israelis) should set our aims lower instead of continually getting caught up, the way the left has done, in that which is beyond the possible.
59. BEEN AWAY
Michael ,   California, USA   (01.18.11)
Well, it seems Sara B has hijacked this site while I celebrated Martin Luther King's holiday. Another victory for Israeli bigots, racists, religious stale books nonsense promoters. Meanwhile, the Hebrew part of Ynet is writing on how high school students in Israel are coming out against their citizenship teachers and for racism. C'mon Ynet, censor this.
60. Same as our Soviet comrades, I too have been waiting with
Bat Zion ,   Central Israel   (01.18.11)
baited breath for the Palestinians to build their own state and lead an independent, productive life. To build houses for those who are still living in refugee camps, to build hospitals, produce their own electricity, establish industry, advanced agriculture and food production.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article