News
Arab-Israeli critically wounded from IDF fire
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 21.01.11, 08:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. I hope this man recovers
Alexander ,   NJ USA/Israel   (01.21.11)
I wonder why he didn't stop, but hopefully he can recover from this seemingly terrible mistake. God bless him with a speedy recovery.
2. When it says to "Military Checkpoint, STOP" that doesnt mean
Yaawqove ,   Israel   (01.21.11)
you dash quickly at the checkpoint.
3. I better watch myself from now on .....
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.21.11)
as I casually stroll on the "Tel Aviv" seaside promenade.
4. Salma
JUDAH THE LION   (01.21.11)
Respect the law of the land,and no one will harm you,but do somthing naughty against the Jewish state,then you are in trouble.
5. Salma-at least you can walk down TLV promenade
BRL ,   Israel   (01.21.11)
I cant walk down any beach in Gaza.....
6. Well Done IDF
Dudi ,   Israel   (01.21.11)
They only problem here is the space occupied by this "person"on the hospital. If he didnt see the checkpoint, better for society that this person is not driving again, and If he saw it and as a "MACHO" primitive Arab tried to go with his tunned ugly car to kill the soldiers, well done IDF soldiers who risk their life from these "human"garbage that pollute the world.
7. Salma
Noam ,   Israel   (01.21.11)
Salma, love the way you deliberately stir all the time it’s like you invite confrontation and run away. This leads me to believe you are educated and have an IQ. However wish you knew how to use this gift constructively, and instead of enjoying the way you spark anger in people on talkbacks, find another medium that solves something or brings us closer to peace. We are all tired of the Middle East crises and all want peace and quiet- think about it…
8. to #3 salami, your are right. You better
jason white ,   afula,israel   (01.21.11)
watch yourself, no one else will.They could turn to stone.
9. @ Salma, Jordan
Ariel   (01.21.11)
Just imagine an Israeli Jew driving inside Nablus...your nice fellow Palestinians would kill him even if he drives slowly...So please stop with your stupid meaningless talkbacks Salma from Jordan. And anyway why you post on ynet and drive to tel aviv, if you are so worried...The Truth is that you should thank Allah every day that you are allowed to live next to a developed country like israel...and instead of writing nonsense...stay in your refugee camp like you did for the last 60 years...it's all you are able to do and you know it!
10. R there speed limits in this area?
rebecca ,   Modiin   (01.21.11)
Even if he did not see the road block, how fast should he have been going? Those roads are not highways, so maybe 70kmh.
11. #3 Salma
Raphael ,   Netanya   (01.21.11)
The worst encounter you could be exposed to on the Tel Aviv seaside promenade: a lynching party of drunken Arabs from Jaljulia, like Arie Karp's murderers.
12. Speed kills
Serge ,   Montreal, Canada   (01.21.11)
This is Exhibit A in why you must always, always be alert when driving. Driving a car is piloting a 1500 kilo hunk of metal at superhuman speeds. Never take it lightly.
13. #12 especially when the slow down sign is only in Hebrew
observer   (01.21.11)
14. #10 60y old Arab can drive, but can't read signs in Hebrew
observer   (01.21.11)
15. " improvised roadblock "
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (01.21.11)
I doubt he was trying to "break through the roadblock" or cause anybody harm. I hope they truly invistigate as this could very well be another unjustified shooting by trigger happy soldiers.
16. observer should call himself clueless opinion
Jrodstein ,   Basalt, Colorado   (01.21.11)
road signs in Israel are all in arabic, English as well as Hebrew.
17. Shooting justified
S ,   USA   (01.21.11)
LOOK PEOPLE, when the soldiers opened fire they did not know that the driver was even an Australian, Singaporean or Arab!!! All they understood was their lives were in danger---given all the terrorism Israel has experienced. I would shoot first and ask questions later if I felt my life was in danger, no matter who was driving the car!!!
18. License Plate Color Tells IDF whether they can shoot or not
Buford T. Justice   (01.21.11)
If the license plates were yellow they would not have shot because they would be in deep do do if they shot a Israeli Jew, but since the licence plates were white, the IDF has a green light to blast away with little concern of any consequences. The official IDF investigation will say that they feared for their lives as they did when they killed the old Palestinian man asleep in his bed..
19. #17 all car shootings were at roadblocks? don't defend Pals!
observer   (01.21.11)
20. Dont think he would dare to pass by a military road block !!
Justin Case ,   Brasil   (01.21.11)
21. #3 Salma, we've already had female
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.21.11)
homicide bombers Stoll, don't run Are you telling us that you're as big as a speeding car ?
22. #18 Buford
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.21.11)
Who said the license plates were white, other than yourself ? He was an Israeli Arab, as such he was entitled to have the customary yellow plates with black lettering When Arabs are from the territories, they have white plates with small paste on's that tell which area he's from
23. #9 NON-OBSERVER
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.21.11)
The sign is RED HAND upraised telling the driver to halt Hebrew isn't required, even the ignorant likes of you would know what the sign means
24. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.21.11)
Nah, baby girl. You're not allowed into Israel, and you know it. Why deceive all the posters here? We know exactly who you are and where you live. Tel Aviv? Right. Dream on. Enjoy your casual strolls down the main drag in Ramallah. Oh, what fun! I do mean it when I say "enjoy." Those strolls are coming to an end, too. I'm sure there are wonderful strolls in which to engage in beautiful, downtown Amman. Get your hijab dry-cleaned, though, sweetie, okay? You wouldn't want to be arrested and flogged.
25. To: No. 18
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.21.11)
So when the United States shoots to kill at coyotes crossing the Mexican border with hundreds of illegal aliens, what color license plate are they shooting at? Yeah. That's what I thought. Get a grip, get an education, get a life. Uber-emphasis on "education."
26. To: No. 15
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.21.11)
Well, if he's that lousy a driver, he doesn't deserve a driver's license, anyway. Who in their right mind doesn't see a roadblock or soldiers signaling a halt? Was this Arab driver drunk?
27. How can you not notice a roadblock?
rachel ,   usa   (01.21.11)
If he was speeding something was wrong.
28. #7 don't waste you breath . She's not so smart
rachel ,   usa   (01.21.11)
29. #28 Salma is she or he?
(01.21.11)
30. #29 who cares
rachel ,   usa   (01.22.11)
Next talkbacks
Back to article