News
Police: Palestinian shot in self-defense
Yair Altman
Published: 27.01.11, 22:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
31. Jews Jews Jews!
Sam ,   USA   (01.28.11)
The jewish settlers should leave the West Bank, and let the Palestinians live their lives and to enjoy their freedom and independent state.. There will be no peace in the region if Israel kept on occupying the West Bank.. Get the hell out of there..!
32. #30
Huntington Beach,USA   (01.28.11)
I think you're one of the least who understands that
33. The Truth ??
Michael ,   Haifa   (01.28.11)
Ther truth about violent incidents of this nature is never known...the extreme radical elements on both sides invariably lie and the police in the occupied territories is not renowned for its objectvity.
34. rock throwing is attempted murder
Golan ,   Modiin   (01.28.11)
So is setting a building on fire. So is strapping on a bomb belt. So is stabbing someone with a knife.
35. Let them confirm this first
Ilan ,   Ariel   (01.28.11)
I'm still skeptical. A grainy video image isn't proof.
36. Oh really Sam
Ron   (01.28.11)
What about 1949-1967 when Jordan occupied J&S? Was there any peace? No. At 1964 the PLO was established, only to destroy Israel- There was no fake Palestinian people,nobody mentioned any Palestinian country, there was no occupation. Commenting like an ignorant without knowing the facts is really pathetic. Please learn your history(you should really read about Zuheir Mohsen and Walid Shoebat).
37. truth can not penetrate hatred
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (01.28.11)
It is definitely a shame that people, including Jews, have such hatred for those Jews living in the settlement areas that their hatred blinds them from the truth. Ahh, that is the perversion that we must live with today...
38. #30 Jerrold the sniveling liar
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.28.11)
Hundreds of Israeli men, women and children along with foreign visitors and workers have been murdered, maimed, attacked and disabled by Jerrold's Palestinian terrorists. For Jerrold, "self-defense" means being careful not to fall off his ergonomic chair.
39. #31 Palestinians bite hand that feeds them
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.28.11)
The only viable labor market for Palestinian workers consists of work provided by Jewish employers in the West Bank. Palestinians can learn to co-exist with their Jewish neighbors or seek "freedom and independence" in the surrounding Arab states.
40. apparently a settler
Zev ,   Israel   (01.28.11)
Jewish or Arab?
41. to # 31
tejas ,   India   (01.28.11)
You don't know anyting about Israel. Do you?
42. Yet another drama from Paliwood.
tejas ,   India   (01.28.11)
43. Fakestinian lies versus security camera! Love the Truth,
Yaawqove ,   Israel   (01.28.11)
embarrass the lie. if the liar CAN be even be embarrassed. Shame on the left wing organizations. shame shame shame. Disgusting behavior and 100:1 odds they will not apologize. After all, we now know from the research into their funding, that they are being paid be everyone from the Islamic world Bank to most anti Israel governments of Norway and Ireland....
44. #31 Sami Sami Sami
Yaawqove ,   Israel   (01.28.11)
Please open a history book. There was terror way before the Jewish state REgained Judea & Samaria (the so called "west bank" of the Jordan River). Why would there be Islamic terror BEFORE there was any Return of Judea and Samaria? You claim its because Jews are living in Judea and Samaria and that should be another country for the Arabs, and if Jews leave all will be well. If thats the case there would have been no terrorism against Jews before 1967. Where were there thousands murdfered and wounded by Islamic terrorists BEFORE 1967, if all this is about is Judea and Samaria? Because this IS NOT about Judea and Samaria. This is about Arab nationalism and anti semitism, this is about Muslim edicts against Jews for 1000 plus years in the Jews' homeland. This is about "dhimmi" status. This is about Islamic and Arabic infatuation with dominance and conquest. You are the occupiers from the Arabian Peninsula. what does north africa, what does the land of Israel, what does the levant have to do with ARABIAN PEOPLE? Answer: Nothing. End the Arab occupation of the Jewish homeland. Period. Those Arabs who will be loyal become citizens and serve and get served. Those that are not interested, get resident status, and in place of not serving (national service army) they pay a tax that goes towards those who DO serve and are thus loyal.
45. sam USA 31 JEWS JEWS JEWS
JUDAH THE LION   (01.28.11)
Why dont you read your bible before you open your stinking mouth you idiot. This land belon g to the JEWS amn d no one else TOUGH TOUGH
46. eporue #16 -you Europeans are the true problem
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (01.28.11)
Eporue shows us the root of the problem is the creation of the fictional Arab "Palestinians", akin to the Boers of South Africa. Ask any historian where the Jews come from, where they established their homeland and lived - and the answer is of course Israel. No eporue, Jews do not come from Siberia or America or Russia. They come from their homeland, which was occupied by you Europeans 2000 years ago. Israel was occupied and we were turned into refugees, and you racist Europeans made sure we stayed stateless refugees for 2 millenia. It's obvious how we solved the problem of you Europeans denying us Jews civil and human rights for the past 2000 years until barely 50 years ago - the Jews went back to their homeland of Israel. You are the problem, eporue, with your adoption of the phony Arab propaganda that there was some country called "Palestine" that was somehow "occupied". There was never a country called "Palestine", and until WW2 when you Europeans said "Palestinians" you were talking about the Jews. And now, despite repeated attempts to share the land with the local Arabs, who took over the moniker "Palestinian" from the Jews, the Arabs refuse to negotiate using excuse after excuse to stay away from the negotiating table. And you Europeans encourage them, like you encouraged Palestinian terrorism in the 1970s by showing your spineless cowardice of releasing all arrested Palestinian terrorists from your jails so they could attack and kill again. But we are not concerned with you, since in another 100 years you Europeans will be a minority in a Muslim continent of Europe, living as 2nd class citizens under Sharia law.
47. #22 - "...I'll ask you a question. How much say did the..."
eporue ,   europe   (01.28.11)
...vanquished Germans have following World War II? Absolutely none. Why should the ersatz "Palestinians" -- on the losing end of six wars -- deserve more consideration than that which was accorded Germany? " answer: israels "occupation" is lasting for too long. if the palestinians would have some hope, that it ends anytime soon (maybe even in a couple of years), the situation wouldnt be that bad as it is. but facts are: there is an occupation lasting more than 40 years already, and - its clear, that israel doesnt want to give it up... question for sarah b: what would you do in their case ? what would you, sarah b, do if you were a palestinian in the west bank, lets say hebron ?
48. #31 Sam,Sam,Sam,Salam Salabim
Sam,Sam,Sam,Salabim ,   Germany   (01.28.11)
Where is the West Bank situated? Whenever it may be but, that for sure not in Israel!
49. 48 MR GERMANY
JUDAH THE LION   (01.28.11)
You said West Bank is not in Israel? Then,can you tell us where isd the West Bank is situated
50. eporue europe 16 &47
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (01.28.11)
Brian Cohen no 46 awaiting for your reply.It will be intresting to hear from you
51. #46 - brian: i am the problem ?
eporue ,   europe   (01.28.11)
i understand (too), the homeland of jews were judea and samaria, some thousands of years ago, as there is "proof" of it in the tenach. in 1948 your government accepted borders, and called its state "israel". ben gurion said, they wanted to leave the name "palestine" for the arabs, in case they wanted to found an own state. they - as israel - had and have the right of an own state. im not sure, what the "question" to me in your post is, but imo: when we dont like people - and this happens often (to me) - then we cant oppress or kill them as a consquence. crimes have to be punished, but we cannot single out and punish people for disliking them (or them disliking us).
52. #49 What I know, but not in Israel.
Joav ,   Germany   (01.28.11)
Such Land named "West Bank" has never ever exist in this region. Every person who know a little history known that this Land calls Judea&Samaria and we will never except the names wich the world occupation powers like Great Britain gave us. We are connected with this land for most 3,800 year and no one can rewrote our history.
53. Joav Gdrmany no 52
JUDAH THE LION   (01.28.11)
Well said BRAVO. Agreed & Shabbat Shalom
54. Yes, Eporue, you are indeed the problem
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (01.28.11)
First you say we stole their land, then you say there is indeed proof that this same land is our homeland. I wasn't asking a question, I was stating the obvious, that Europeans are sticking their nose in and blaming things on the Jews (accusing us of "stealing" our own homeland?). Yes, these Arabs should have their own country, be it their own or as part of Jordan (as they were before 1967 as Europe conveniently forgets). You seem to be accusing me of being in my homeland, yet stealing land from "Palestinians" when you admit that the Jews were the "Palestinians". We are not killing the Palestinians as a consequence, nor are we oppressing them - Most of them are living under the PA, not Israel. If a Palestinian throws a rock at my head, you seem to think that it's acceptable and that I'm not allowed to defend myself, unless I throw a rock back ("proportionate response"). However, this Palestinian is indeed trying to kill me. If he cracks my skull and I die, he will celebrate and be feted as a hero. And Europe thinks this is legitimate and that we are not allowed to negotiate for our homeland. History did not begin in 1967, nor did it begin in 1948. Many of us Jews are here on land in Judea and Samaria that was legally ours (purchased legally and titles held) before 1948. You are now telling us this is "stolen". And, of course, you don't see that you are wrong. You are the problem.
55. 51 eporue europe
JUDAH THE LION   (01.28.11)
The Jews have accepted partition because we did not have any other alternative,but the Arabs rejected and made war against the Jews,and they have lost tha war against all odds.Jews were attacked by the GREEKS
56. Brian Cohen Judean peoples front 54
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (01.28.11)
The Europeans are hopeless,currupt, selfish,arrogant,and one sided only for their own interest,and they will sell the Jews for a BUNCH OF SPRING ONION. The European may think when an Arab throw stones on the Jews,stones is not a weapon,but rather sweets. For once we should tell the EUROPE if they want to be judge,then to be FAIR on both parties,otherwise they can get lost and MIND THEIR OWN BUSINESS.Enough from EUROPE.
57. to have me silenced, i must be dead...
eporue ,   EUROPE, SORRY !   (01.28.11)
58. 57
JUDAH THE LION   (01.28.11)
No body wants you to be dead.G D FORBID. Just do not give false support if you want to be fair judge
59. #10 NON-OBSERVER
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.28.11)
Just like everything thing else you comment on, you've never seen it Next time, try reading the article a bit more slowly, the fact that a camera was present when the attack took place, should be simple enough for the likes of you to comprehend You really shouldn't comment on Blood Libel, since your posts consist of sheer idiocy
60. Jerrold Cohen - "The voice of inexperience"
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.28.11)
Always commenting on things which you havent experienced If it would up to you, you would have helped the Nazi's run the Concentration Camps You had mentioned that some of your ancestors managed to escape the pogroms or Europe, to which I can only say, too bad, if the likes of you is what resulted,
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article