Business
Israeli nightmare: Muslims to halt gas supply
Tani Goldstein
Published: 30.01.11, 09:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
1. you are about to kiss your gaz goodbye
tea man ,   marjayoun   (01.30.11)
That will the first thing they will stop the Egyptian always saying that you are not paying fair price for the gaz
2. Contingency Plans???
leo ,   nyc   (01.30.11)
Even in the past of times, there were objections in Egypt to the supply of gas to Israel. So these new real problems should be no surprise. This is all the more reason why Israel needs to proceed immediately to develop its own supply and capitalize on the recent discoveries.
3. So we were standing on one leg only
Noa   (01.30.11)
What do we have politicians for? Egypt had the monopoly of our gas supply and no politician felt uneasy about that? Outrage.
4. No gas? No problem!
Israeli 2   (01.30.11)
Israel managed without gas many years before this so called "peace" The loss is theirs, not Israel's.
5. If Muslim Brothers gain power
Raphael ,   Netanya   (01.30.11)
This means breakdown of tourism, main income source of Egypt. Without gas sales, how will they manage simply to feed their 80 million people, buying cereals at soaring market prices (the US are presently supplying with state aid)? Egypt needs this gas money more than Israel needs gas itself, which could be supplied liquid by Qatar or others, as the world gas offer is higher than demand.
6. Stay Calm and Don't Worry,
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.30.11)
Palestinian gas & Lebanese gas will fill your need. just keep theft, Grab It now , it's your chance : (
7. Hello what about the Levithan?
The Dude   (01.30.11)
It is perfectly large source, it is not enough to support exporting gas, but for supplying our domestic uses, its perfect. Simply speed up this and focus on energy independence! On the short term we should speed up the Gas fields off of Haifa. In the medium and longer turn we should be developing other forms of energy to be completely energy independent, with the medium term focused on hybrid technology combining battery and combustion technologies to get the max from each technology until fossil fuels can realistically be phased out. We must now take this Pharaoh tragedy as an opportunity to also improve ourselves!
8. to #6
Chong ,   Malaysia   (01.30.11)
Salma, Cry till Kingdom comes. Israel is going to thrive. There is no nation called palestine. You occupy the Iseali land. Go to your own country, Jordan.
9. aish......and subsidizing salma
(01.30.11)
wheels n deals , are the palestinians about to otherthrow the western backed abbas and declare allegiance to a new independent authority?
10. first step
Marcelo ,   Berlin   (01.30.11)
cutting down all gas, water and electricity to gaza and the AP. That would improve the gas and energy capacity of Israel until leviatan is fully operational. As for the jordans called palis, well, they still can go back to jordan and egypt, where they are all from, doors are all open....
11. wow, i'm impressed
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (01.30.11)
the author wasn't lazy and incorrectly identified the subjects of the article as "arabs" (which wrongly implicates arab christians and wrongly assumes egyptians are, in fact, egyptians and not arabs). your credibility on the subject just rose as a result of having basic facts mastered (which is sadly absent from most israeli so-called journalists). kol hakavod for being intelligent and appearing educated, contra most every other journalist out there.
12. @8 nothing even People's History can learn you!
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.30.11)
Stay in your own country, Malaysia Don't ask don't tell, cause it aint your business .
13. #6 remember salma
(01.30.11)
that this egyptian gas supplies ramala, gaza and the entire arab villages in israel. if you want to see this gas delivery stopped, you must agree to stay very very cold and stop cooking in israel yourself. how about that? are you willing to stop eating and being warm?? this is what i mean by arab stupidity and particularly "palestinians" stupidity. you never fail to hurt yourselves. never. where are you going to get your gas from ,salma? where? if not from israel. hameed aboughaze, iranian
14. # 8 Chong in Malaysia
Ginette Golden ,   TORONTO, CANADA   (01.30.11)
Right on brother, I like your way of thinking! # 12 Salma "dear", the palis trying and wanting to destroy Israel is every Jew's business. Fully in agreement with Marcelo in Berlin (#10). Shortage of gas in Israel? No problemo! Let's cut off the supply to Gaza AND the West Bank.
15. take back the sinai peninsula quick
jDK ,   nyc usa   (01.30.11)
In case a Muslim non secular government take over power, and they don't keep agreements with Israel about gas etc, so Israel does not need to keep camp david accords about the sinai. Not only the don't have to , but in order to keep the enemy at bay they will must re conquer the sinai very quickly. Do not forget that besides 700. Soldiers it should be demilitarized. If the loonies get the government we better be ready to get it back before they deploy their army at the southern israeli border.
16. I have this idea, it might be a little nutty...
Etoile ,   Montreal, CAN   (01.30.11)
How about, stop the bureaucratic nonsense that is going on with the Israeli government concerning the Leviathan and other gas fields? That way, development will occur much faster for that and other fields without the stupid burdens of excess taxation and regulation. The whole Egyptian situation would become a non-issue!
17. # 13
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.30.11)
She produces enough of her very own gas to keep herself warm & cook her food !!
18. # 14
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.30.11)
Oh Oh, the West Bank without gas? you want the yishuvim to be without gas ?
19. Oops! Thanks for keeping me in line Birdi
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.31.11)
I forgot my People also live in the West Bank. Because I only spent 2 years of my entire life in Israel (long enough to learn the language) I am not too familiar with all the other stuff. what is a "yeshuvim" anyways? I suspect it's a settler but of course I am not sure. Ok then, lets' just cut off the gaz supply to Gaza.
20. # 12 Salma
Arthur ,   Huston, TX   (01.30.11)
The Palis use donkey droppings to cook, they do not need gas.
21. Coal..its a cleaner fuel than you may think
Al   (01.31.11)
Israel has the technology and the brains to devise methods that can make this fuel ultra clean. China, Canada USA and other places has tons of it. It can be had for a song. No need to enable an Egypt who will turn against Israel in the very near future. One final thing..Israel has no obligation to supply anything to Gaza. You are feeding a sworn enemy.
22. Hammer and Anvil
Eldar ,   Haifa   (01.31.11)
Great - we're stuck between Islamic tyrants and our own business-tyrants, Tshuva/Ofers/Maiman. Best option - publicly owned solar, wind, conservation, and - if needed - publicly owned nuclear. Tshuva is going to try to make a killing on our misfortune.
23. One journalist's nightmare is our fish wrapping material
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (01.31.11)
Lucky for the author, you can't use a computer screen to wrap fish (well, you can, but it's messier than newspaper). He forgets to mention that Israel's major power plants (like Hadera) are powered by that good old greenhouse gasser and pollution rich black gold......coal. There is no nightmare. The world's supply of coal is quite ample for the next century.
24. Birdi and Ginette...you've got the wrong gas...
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (01.31.11)
There are two types of gas here: cooking gas for your kitchen, and gas to power a power plant to make electricity. So far as I know, the Egyptian gas is for the power plants, and only makes it to Gaza and the high hills of Judea (and Samria) as electrons, where it lights up our yishuvim (communities) and powers our computers...among other things. I'm not sure of the source of the gas in my stove, but there are lots of alternative sources for it.
25. Brian # 24
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.31.11)
Thank you for your explanation. One thing for sure, whatever they will try (i.e. cutting off the gas supply), Israel has enough brain power to find an alternate, viable solution and that very fact is killing the Arabs with envy.
26. hameed, Birdi , Ginette Golden and Arthur , Ha!!!
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.31.11)
Very true, Ignorance has no limits ! a vast deposit of natural gas within Gaza's maritime activity zone Was discovered before you smell it along our beautiful coastline ! End the occupation and siege, so that we can export our gas to the needy in our region.
27. @26
(01.31.11)
so, salma??? what are you still doing here writing. go girl. go!!! start digging. maybe all this future work will keep you from being terrorists and dying for allah. at least you palestinians will keep busy rather than standing with your hand out to recieve cash from america and europe. at least hard work is better than being a welfare society for over 60 years.
28. #15 - and just whose children are you sending to war?
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (01.31.11)
I bet not your own!
29. 28 Dorothy
jorge stern ,   mexico   (01.31.11)
although it would be sad to see any Israeli killed-------ISrael may have to re-take part of Sinai. We know from history that soon, the radicals will take over-just as they have done in Lebanon very recently We areall praying for the safety of Israel !
30. # 24
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.31.11)
Brian, thanks. I meant, I dont want our yishuvim without gas, whether its gas for cocking or gas for lighting up the hills of Judea & Samaria.
Next talkbacks
Back to article