News
Clashes in Bedouin village leave 6 wounded
Ilana Curiel
Published: 10.02.11, 13:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
8 Talkbacks for this article
1. So if we plant trees, the u.n. should be
jason white ,   afula,israel   (02.10.11)
involved.Too bad the u.n. buildings are not on some island in the middle of the ocean instead of Manhattan. Be easy to destroy this whole group of anti Zionist, anti American and anti democracy mental cases. The democracies of the world should leave the u.n. and form a group for democracies with not further ties to the u.n.
2. The dispute is easily settled
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.10.11)
Let the Bedouin present the deeds and titles to the land they claim is their own Southern Bedouin, seems they may have been in transit from Egypt, meandering into Israel, wandering to and fro with their flocks for grazing purposes No roots & no claim
3. #2; BEN JABO, Hits the nail on the head
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (02.10.11)
Before anybody jumps to conclusions do some research. There was another so called village like this one, written up in the paper. The author of the article was Amira Haas, as it turned out she misrepresented the whole story. How you may ask? She failed to mention, it wasn't a permanent village at all. It was a temporary camp site used by the Bedouin for seasonal grazing of their herds. But Amira Haas failed to mention this important fact in her article. Instead portraying it as a permanent village that had been there for centuries,at least that was the implication. It turned out to be completely inaccurate and she was caught and exposed for her lie. This may be the very same thing. Let's hear from somebody familiar with the area comment on this place. Clearly the court sided against the Bedouins, and Israel is well known for their judicial fairness. Unlike any of its neighbor's. As Ben Jabo states let's see the title's and deeds to the land. Apparently in court they couldn't provide it or they would have won their case.
4. Ynet, Where's the rest of the story?!
Salma ,   Palestine   (02.10.11)
how many times did your security forces demolish that poor village?! they say "illegal buildings". Residents of southern village of Al-Arakib say "illegal trees". An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth and the initiator is the aggressor.
5. A short memo to Mark
Gábor Fränkl   (02.10.11)
This "village" is the very exact SAME Hass blatantly lied about... Just thoguht of mentioning.
6. #5; Gabor Fankl, Thanks I didn't Know
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (02.10.11)
I couldn't remember the name of the village in that particular case. Thank for the update, I appreciate it. sadly, I've learned to take nothing at face value with regards to these kinds of articles. So many seek to vilify Israel, with their delegitimization campaign, that I question all such articles. Again Gabor, Thanks for letting people know this is just another phony story and cheap attempt to vilify Israel. The Pallywood never stops does it? You have set the record straight, good job!
7. No tickee no washee
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.10.11)
As they used to say in the old Chinese hand laundries If you didn't present the claim check (deed) you couldn't get your laundry The Bedouin's entitlement to live in that village is as ffictional as your claim to a mythical Palestine As of yet, and I guess not within my lifetime, you have yet to come up with the answers of the few easy questions I posed to you Name the last three rulers, your Capitol City, and where can I see some genuine Ancient Palestinian coins ? I loads more questions, I settle for the answers to a measly three of them
8. #4 Salma you are paid to post propaganda against israel
STEPHAN ,   YAFFO   (02.10.11)
Back to article