Settlers: 15 injured in Havat Gilad
Yair Altman
Published: 28.02.11, 15:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
1. so cruel among themselves, do you expect they'll have peace
observer   (02.28.11)
with Arabs.
2. there's a reason rubber bullets & smoke grenades were used
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (02.28.11)
sure the settlers talk about what the security forces did, but are we to believe that the settlers were quietly praying on the side and violence was used against them for no reason? were they arrested for drinking tea?
3. To # 1 Observer
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
For once I must agree with you! Just that real cruelty comes from somebody who calls himself "for peace and understanding" He acts as Defense Minister and his name is Ehud Barak.
Laurence ,   Givatayim, Israel   (02.28.11)
We have in Israel about 45.000 illegal arab houses. They have stolen acres of land in the Gallile and Negev and Mr Barak is focusing histerically on a tent and a few miserable structures of our jewish brothers. I can't wait we'll get rid of Barak !!
Ricardo Macher ,   Karne Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
Now we know what Bibi offered in return for the US veto in the settlement resolution. It is the policy of "no talk, no build". Pressure now to avoid construction will be unbearable. Destruction, freeze, relocation. Just wait. Nobody will talk about it, but we will not be seeing authorization for building in a long time now.
6. FMI ,Rabbi Yitzhak Shapira incited to kill NON-Jews
Salma ,   Palestine   (02.28.11)
After his release he seems to have changed his mind !
7. Well done our security forces
Avi ,   Israel   (02.28.11)
AS job well done on containg the illegal settlers, who seem to think they are above the law. As for MK Ben-Ari what a joke he is now claiming to be a victim , this fanatical so called MK who fans the flames of hatred and incites violence as a way of life.
8. Complaint
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
There is a stupid person using my name, in this case # 5, is it not possible ti filtrate frauds when you always have the details of the talk backers? Please!!!! It's not nice what he is doing!
9. Netanyahu is a loser like Olmert
Al   (02.28.11)
Bombs fly in from Gaza and he's got his finger up his ass....but when it comes to beating up Jewish kids...he's all balls. Loser..Loser ...Loser. Two time loser!
10. Barak and Gantz must resign now !
11. # 3 FAKE
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
There will be blood, there will be violence. They brought me to the West Bank, and I will not leave Samaria for nothing in the world. Over my dead body. Maybe this is the beginning of the revolt that is sweeping the Middle East. Aux armes, citoyens!!
12. 5 Ricardo
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (02.28.11)
I am ABSOLUTELY against freeze. But don t you think the veto was very important?Can we condamn Bibi?Is there another option?
13. Maybe it's the time for settlers declare a state
Seppo ,   Finland   (02.28.11)
in Shomron and Judea. They have much more rights for it than any Arab. League of Nations did not determine how many Jewish states could be located west of Jordan, only that the whole area IS Jewish homeland allowing local Arabs to have their civil and religious rights. Barak seems to regard settlers as enemies. He is responsable for any shooting in the area and he chooses to shoot Jews to create a civil war and makes Arabs to be kings. Who pays him? If he lets Arabs build freely in Jewish homeland and prevents Jews from doing it he is breaking international law. Area is not under civil law of Israel, only under UN Charter's confirmation to build anywhere Jews want without Barak's permits. Because Bibi prevents "building permits" he is also breaking international law and only appeasing Arabs and Obama. But neither is happy before Jews have disappeared from Israel.
14. concealing weapons on their persons?
observer ,   Egypt   (02.28.11)
they can't conceal machine guns or RBGs, because weapons are ALLOWED for legitimate settlers.
15. Yep, this is why we have an army.
Aviela ,   KochavYaakov, Israel   (02.28.11)
Our army is, above and all, to protect foreign interests? I thought it was to protect the Jewish people in the Jewish state. Pathetic!
16. This Yishuv in Shomrun and ones like
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (02.28.11)
it form the heart and backbone of the Zionist enterprise, all but forgotten by our miserable urbanized left. Pioneers all, they protect the rest of Israel while recognizing that we have an historical right tothis land given to us by the blood and hard work of our ancestors and by Hashem himself. To recognize what our pitiless police are doing to us, go to the Havad Gilad website for photos and captions. That Jews could violate the rights of of our brothers with such impunity is shocking; that they could do it with such aggression, violating all just alternatives, is indescribable. We really need to rid ourselves of Ehud Barak and allow Avigdor Lieberman (a member of a Yishuv himself, Nokdeem, in Yehuda) to lead our country.
17. I reside in the Yishuv of Tekoa (Yehuda)
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (02.28.11)
but possess little knowledge of Shomrun. I see that there are several tours which one might take. Has anyone taken one or heard from a friend about them? Especially, given the pitiful way the Jewish villagers are treated by our own police force, my interest has risen substantially.
18. "so cruel..."
Ilana   (02.28.11)
If that is so cruel, what can you say about your brothers and peace with Israel???? Take a look at facts, observe the facts, the numbers of cruelty among muslims, to muslims and to others and then you see how we feel about your ability to make peace. You are a joke and a pathetic one.
19. For N07 who was born in Israel by mistake
Trumpeldor ,   danielroth58@yahoo.f   (02.28.11)
"7. Well done our security forces" You rejoice because "Israeli" security forces destroy dwellings of your brothers ??? You do have a weird sense of Yehadut, near rehov Shenkin ............
20. Would a Jewish State execute such a pogrom against its Jews?
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim,   (02.28.11)
B"H - The answer clearly is: No!
21. Netanyahu's choice
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (02.28.11)
Netanyahu can become one of Israel's greatest leaders like Yehuda Maccabi or Ben Gurion. Instead, by sending the YSM stormtroopers to attack innocent Jews, it seems Netanyahu is intent on starting a civil war. Apparently he wants to be remembered like another Judas Escariot.
22. Reply to #19 Trumpledor
AVI ,   Israel   (02.28.11)
Hate to break it to you buddy but i dont call a bunch of fanatical religious settlers my brother. They hate us (secular) with a passion. The day will come when civil war will break out and i know what side i am on.
23. Totally unnecessary...
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (02.28.11)
Israel should simply confiscate the settlers' weapons and withdraw the Army from the Territories. Let the settlers figure it out with the Palestinians, since they both love The Land(TM) much more than anything or anyone else. Because of so much pussyfooting by successive governments (with the exception of Dr. Sharon's), the settlers now feel they have a carte blanche to do pretty much whatever they want. The municipality can't even move a flower bed without these settler morons starting a riot and calling everybody in sight a natzi.
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (02.28.11)
This is what the "NUE LAND" really stands for, its destruction of its own Jews and our true heritage. King Ehud rules wit a very familiar ruthless oppressive Hedonistic fist. While the IDF is impotent to protect its citizens from incoming fire, no expense and effort is spared to destroy tax paying citizens property. While our Islam cousins rise up against its corrupt rulers, we as usual bow down to our own dictators, who will stop at nothing to harm us. Behind closed doors deals have been made and money exchanged, in order to force the new world order on us. Any link to the devine has to be eliminated, because it is opposed to the rule of secular Liberalism . As our history has shown many times over, our internal Kapo's who bow down to foreign idols, will stop at nothing to destroy us.
25. How dare they complain
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (02.28.11)
when they were fighting against the forces of law and order. Of course the soldiers and police had the right to use whatever force was necessary to carry out the evacuation ordered by the government.
26. Hopefully in the next elections, we will
jason white ,   afula, israel   (02.28.11)
elect a pro Zionist, pro Jewish rights government. They better make sure that the first law they pass will be to punish with prison time, loss of rank and pension each and every police person, border patrol person and other security forces that destroyed Jewish structures, removed,harassed or arrested Jews in the liberated territories as well as gaza. Next they should destroy all illegal arab buildings and retake land that was stolen by arabs. Finally we should make sure that bibi, barak, livni, peretz and peres are locked up and never allowed to communicate with outside world.They picked sides and it was with the enemies of Israel and the Jews.
27. #12 ORA
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (02.28.11)
Ora, I think it is time to leave the settlements, as we left Sinai, South Lebanon and Gaza. In the end, everybody knows we'll keep the biggest ones, like my town, Karnei, and dismantle the smaller ones. To fight against this is a waste of time and image. The resolution was ok. The US showed they are our friends. # 8 is a fake Ricardo Macher.
28. Only civil war will save ISRAEL........
MKY ,   Israel   (02.28.11)
from the leftists
29. @22,look at the srugot numbers within Tsahal
trumpeldor   (02.28.11)
THEY are the future of Israel ! Hilonim,clearly are not.
30. Why r they masked?
svietka from shomron   (02.28.11)
why cant we see their faces? why r they wearing black uniforms and not grey or zahal? why r they armed with riot equeipment to be used in long range shooting? why r ppl being shot in the back? why dont we know who gave the order and who was in command? ON MARMARA FLOTILA THEY GO IN with paint guns--against fellow jews they go in with shoot-to-injure brave IDF is really loosing it!
Next talkbacks
Back to article