News
Horror in Samaria: Terrorist murders family of 5
Yair Altman
Published: 12.03.11, 06:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
232 Talkbacks for this article
91. it is a crime
(03.12.11)
92. I am a Palestinian and i dont support such action
observer ,   Jerusalem/Palestine   (03.12.11)
The 3 children shouldn't pay for what their parents and government have committed, all settlers please leave the west bank and let us all live in peace, your place is not here.
93. Not all Palestinians are terrorists I am agaist this!
Fadi ,   Jerusalem, Palestine   (03.12.11)
I am Palestinian and I am against this this not only me but there are tons of Palestinians also against this thing that happen its really disgusting to do such a thing but we should also remember that the other side also did this in gaza "I AM TOTALLY AGAINST THIS AND I HOPE THEY WILL BE ABLE TO CATCH THIS CRIMINAL"
94. To #62, who thinks the Israeli right is responsible
Gobbo   (03.12.11)
You ask why would the Palestinians want to "sabotage their own cause". You act as though this instance would be the very first time they did precisely that. For how many decades have you been asleep? Remember what Abba Eban said many years ago: "The Arabs never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity." It was true back then. It's still true today. Hatred is the reason they shoot themselves in the foot. Abject hatred conquers one's ability to think rationally.
95. Sorry for the killing of the Innocent Civilian’s
Ahmed ,   Gaza   (03.12.11)
I am a Palestinian and so ashamed of the killing of the civilians. I feel so bad especially for the young kids. I am totally against the killing of any human being. My prayers are with their family and loved ones. May God bless their souls? I hope one day all of us can live in peace. I hope the killer is caught and be punished. Sorry again and I wish that didn’t happen.
96. 62 , suspicious . What and when this "previously" ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.12.11)
And what about all the suicide bombers ? Also Israeli right wingers ? You make no sense , and are disgusting to think so .
97. To: No. 77
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.12.11)
Too little; too late. We have tried to live in peace with you with over seven decades. You have made that impossible. You will have to go. Sorry. We just don't believe you, and we cannot have your decadence, violence and terrorism in our midst. Work something out in Jordan; you cannot stay here.
98. To: No. 93
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.12.11)
Good. Can we expect to see those "tons" of ersatz "Palestinians" participating in a demonstration demanding that the killer be brought to justice? Right. Didn't think so.
99. To: No. 88
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.12.11)
So he says. But we don't really know, do we?
100. To: No. 62
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.12.11)
Let's go with the track record. Arabs murdering entire families is not, sadly, an unknown phenomenon in Israel. It has happened before. Lots of times. By the way, the last seven decades of ersatz "Palestinian" terror make no sense. Reasonableness and common sense are not ersatz "Palestinian" strong suits, and there is a long, long trail of dead Jews to prove it. Your "suspicions" are misplaced.
101. coverage of the story
Rob ,   NY   (03.12.11)
check out al-jazeera's coverage. no mention of the ages. no mention of the nature of the stabbing. i guess to the Arabs and Muslims, these things just happen to Israelis and Jews. Maybe they fell on the knives. Send a note to al-jazeera for balanced reporting. i did.
102. Israeli leaders who listen to Obama are responsible
David P. ,   Capitola, CA   (03.12.11)
this is what happens when you outsource security to your enemies
103. coward
anton ,   istanbult urkey   (03.12.11)
disgusting act, killing kids and parents innocent civilians this kind of people dont deserve to breathe
104. simply disgusting
jj   (03.12.11)
and now the cycle begins again...
105. Sorrow, shock, and shame
Rahel Warshaw-Dadon ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.12.11)
I am a Jewish Israeli, living in West Jerusalem. Israeli (#79) writes that many Palestinians are horrified by this terrible deed. I first read about this horror on Facebook in a message posted by my young Palestinian friend, from Hebron, who posted this article, and wrote "Shame!". I agree, and so would he agree with Leslie (#15), Abed (#40 ). I am grateful for the comments of observer (#92), Fadi (#93), and Ahmed (#95). Thank your support. We strongly disagree with Rachel (#32).
106. #59 - you should be ashamed!
David ,   Karmiel   (03.12.11)
Tell me - are you just naturally a bigot or a neo-nazi in disguise. No Jew has ever gone into a Jewish home never mind a Palestinian home and STABBED to death and INFANT!! There is no excuse and the fact that you would suggest that there is says more about YOU and your warped ideology than Israel! In your book no doubt the Jews caused the Black Black and blew up the WTC. You should be ashamed!
107. Murder
Alexandra Villers ,   Antwerp   (03.12.11)
I pray for the souls of this poor family and embrace their families and friends. There are no words to describe this horrible act.
108. Robert , Brisbane 59 . You're disgusting
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.12.11)
Do you think that a murderer can be catched immediately ? It takes time . When have settlers "demonstrated" such acts against other Jews ?
109. zooz , gaza # 65 . Not children murderers ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (03.12.11)
Your memory is very bad . Remember only this case where an Israeli woman and her children were murdered in your region . And all the other suicide bombers . They all murdered everyone possible . Your people don't know what "ethical" behaviour means . Look only at what happens in your own families where women are murdered for "lookingf" at a man .
110. To #62 and other imbeciles.Al Aksa Martirs Claimed respon..
Aaron ,   Jerusalem   (03.12.11)
..sability The Military Wing of Al Fatah the Alaksa Martyrs Brigade Claim responsability. Any Doubts? For all the moroons who might think it was Right Wing doing. To all antisetlers. Settlers is not the issue. Would Palestininas haved started direct talks the settlement issue would have been solved. We solvedit to make peace with Egypt and remove settlers from Sinai. We removed settlers from Gaza (unfortunately terrorism intensify after this) So to claim that settlements could be an excu8se to provoke this crime, that is exactly what it is an excuse. Abbas and Fayad are also responsible for all the narrative of hate they are pooring in their education and propaganda systems. They are the ones, just as was Arafat of the Hatred that has not permit us to sit and talk. SETTLEMENTS ARE NOT THE ISSUE
111. For Sure The Killer Is Not a Hero.
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.12.11)
But you cannot blame anyone but yourselves, when "Israeli" governments send settlers to live in a land not their own, and bring them up with wrong values toward neighbors, then the result with great regret can be expected. MAY GOD BLESS AND GUARD ALL THE CHILDREN IN PALESTINE AND "ISRAEL".
112. RIP
cfs ,   fr and dz   (03.12.11)
RIP, my condoleance to family and friends. No killing people of the world.
113. MORE ATTACKS
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (03.12.11)
We are scared to death here, in Karnei. There are rumours the attacks will intensifie. We are really worried. We don't have means to deal with terrorists. They act quickly and unexpectly. I never considered that, but maybe it is time to start to think about leaving my beloved Samaria.
114. horrible
Ashamed palestinian ,   Jerusalem   (03.12.11)
i'm totally under shock of this horrible action, why to murder innocent kids. a criminal will only do this. settlers r the worst and they r turning peoples life into hell with their occupation and existence in the west bank on occupied land. but killing kids is not the way to struggle against them. i'm ashamed of this attack, it's not in my name. condolonces to the family.
115. WE ALL ARE " SETTLERS " TODAY !!!
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (03.12.11)
116. to nr. 15: this wasn't an act
Wilhelm Tel ,   Swiss Alps   (03.12.11)
..of a "carzy man". It was an act of terror and behind it there are very "cool" and calculating "men" who conduct a jihadist agenda.
117. NR. 77.
Orao. ,   Srbia.   (03.12.11)
Message to all there is a simple massage need to be heard, that there is no other way of living next to each other without having PEACE between Palestinian and Israelis. COMMENT - ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE, THERE WILL BE NO PEACE BETWEEN PALESTINIANS AND ISRAELIS, UNTILL YOU HAVE CONVERTED . TO THE GOD OF ISRAEL. need to understand the peace massage, since almost 2 years and sattlers from these area's are pushing the area to more Violence by buring local palestinian fields, cuting thier trees, attacking local palestinian Properties, buring thier Mosques,.... , sattlers recent acts of violance need to be STOPED in all west bank or what you call it Juda and Sameria, sattlers violant fuel's the area with more heatred. COMMENT - 2 YEARS - ? YOUR SELFDECEPTION WILL NOT SOLVE ANYTHING, THIS IS NOT AN CONFLICT 2 YEARS OLD, THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON SNCE 1947 AND EVEN BEYOND THAT. Finaly let us live in peace we have nothing much to ask for except to live in peace, work, eat, pray, grow our land , try to accept us as palestinians living near by you and having our life simply as you do , we love our families just the way you too we love our land just the way you do. Hope my massage recived THIS SELFDECEPTION OF YOURS WILL NOT HELP EITHER. IF YOU REALY BELIEVE WHAT YOU SAY, YOU MUST BE VERY VERY NAIVE. Orao.Srbia.
118. terrorist attack ? it could have been EVERYONE !
eporue ,   europe   (03.12.11)
lieberman is not only a radical nutter extremist, he is also stupid as a brick: HOW CAN ANYONE CONDEMN the "terrorist attack", when its not even known who did it ? i see, you in israel can. sorry, "we" not. find the perpetrators - by watertight proof that they are the true ones... by now, the whole story (parents, some siblings murdered, daughter/son/husband/wife finds them) sounds the same as many many others, happened before around the globe. in VERY MOST of them, it was a relative - who did it or who ordered someone (boyfriend etc) to do it...
119. #62 - i agree. strange and very suspicious.
eporue ,   europe   (03.12.11)
and shocking, that everything other than a terrorist attack is ruled out. do you think, israel is free from psychopaths ? NO.
120. wow, yair altman... it was all censored ?
eporue ,   europe   (03.12.11)
it is SICK, how - without any shred of doubt - the murder is blamed onto terrorists... it can - with at least(!) the same likelihood - have been someone from INSIDE the settlement... tell me, why not ! and tell me, why you censor this "suggestion"... or was it, that lieberman is "stupid as a brick" - for asking the world for "condemnation", if not even a suspect was caught... ?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article