News
Itamar massacre: Fogel family butchered while sleeping
Yair Altman
Published: 13.03.11, 00:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
243 Talkbacks for this article
91. You are an idiot
Guy ,   USA   (03.13.11)
You are not a peace lover you simply an idiot. Do you compare the killing of civilians in Gaza who sheltered Hamas terrorist or who were used by Hamas terrorists as human shields to the killing of babies ? As I said, Idiot.
92. to nr. 20.
universe-citizen ,   the universe   (03.13.11)
a crime is a crime, a murder is a murder, whether a palestinian, an ersatz "israeli", an american or whoever commits a murder and whether the innocent victim is a jew, a palestinian, a chinese, a nigerian, a stateless person (without a nationality/citizenship) etc. the murder is the same horrible crime. daniel from tel aviv you have the courage/guts to look objectively not only to non-"israelis", non-zionists, non-jews but also to your own people/country. iam also glad that there are still good-willing people in this world who are a good example to mankind for instance: nelson mandela. i hope that you are able to share your views/opinions with other good-willing people and that you will ultimately find the peace and hapiness that you surely deserves. shalom/shalaam. for peace and justice for all of us.
93. #65 So you are shaping the knives?
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (03.13.11)
I am sure this act of inhuman murder is a beginning of the new wave of the terrorism against Israel in order to bring more bloodshed between Arabs and Israel. It was planned by Iran, Syria, Hamas and Hezbollah. There is nothing new and secretive. But the evil will not prevail. All the arguments about the settlers stealing land are untrue. Settlers are building their house on the Israeli land. Israel is a democracy and if the Israeli court decides the land doesn't belong to the settlers they will be evicted. The same must go to the Arabs. If they build their houses illegally they have to be punished evicted as well. But if you see the enemy in 3 months old baby and you are ready to kill you are not a human.
94. #40 Marco
Chatich   (03.13.11)
Yes we all remember the children of qana. Their bodies were driven to the bombing site in refrigerated trucks by hezbollah for the purpose of manufacturing anti-Israel news, and to satisfy the rabid Jew-hatred of antisemites like youself. Just Google "green helmet guy". Complete fiction - just like the mohammed al-dura hoax, and the 'palestinians' themselves, for that matter.
95. terrible
Dov ,   USA   (03.13.11)
My deepest condolences.
96. Thank you Ahmed Salah
sara maimon ,   brooklyn, NY   (03.13.11)
Thank you for your kind words
97. Sounds like savagery of Fatah in early 1960s
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
Looks like the Arabs need another "1967"-like lesson!
98. #12 - oh, you mean the infant stabbed himself.
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
or, atleast that will be the "conspiracy theory" tossed around "palestinian" centers because you're too cowardly to take responsibility for the animals you create. If you're so against this action, I dare you to voice it publicly, either in PA news with your real name, or in protests against terrorists actions in your name. Either way - it would be a first from anyone on the "Palestinian" side. Considering how your side dehumanizes Jews and justifies these crimes against humanity, the killers will be honored as a youth center or city square.
99. #12 - Muslim against murdering of children
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
you were noticeably absent when a pregnant woman and her family were shot at point-blank range several months ago.
100. #16 - your children are used as human shields
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
They are not targeted and killed in their sleep, stabbed by people lusting for blood. Your children, sadly, are being used as cover by terrorists who launch rockets at other civilians. The address for your grievance is Hamas and Fatah, not Israel. After all, in 1999 there was plenty of peace and free movement for all...until Arafat and Fatah launched terror attacks just like this one. Let's use the Arab logic to decipher this crime. Who would benefit the most from this crime? The answer: "Palestinians". BTW - there were no settlers in 1967 and you still didn't accept the land in return for peace. Remember? Your leaders made that clear on international news. Israel was founded in 1948, but YOU didn't accept its borders and started a genocidal war you lost. Ergo, you have no right nor condition in which to demand borders of any kind. Finally, that land you claim is being stolen by settlers? Who does it belong to? Have a deed to present? We do - and much of that land was stolen from these Jews who were killed or ethnically cleansed in 1948, and replaced by Arabs forced into the West Bank by Jordan. Answer for that war crime, then we'll talk about your present-day grievance.
101. #19 - ahaha - no they're too busy kidnapping Gazans
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
trying to run away from Hamas rule. Because we all know that "Palestinians" have no idea how to operate a gun let alone a knife, and never has a "Palestinian" killed a civilian. They're too peaceful. Hahahahaha - which is why they get thrown out of almost every country they invade, from Jordan to Iraq.
102. #20 - shouldn't you address "Palestinian" parents?
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
After all, when terrorists attack in Israel, we grab our kids and protect them. When the IDF enters a West Bank village, schools are shut down and kids pushed to throw rocks at the soldiers, while terrorists shoot from behind them. This is the real crime against these children, one that's rarely addressed. And one thing you fail to mention (on purpose, I bet) is that if a "Palestinian" child is killed Israelis mourn. They are not happy and say so. Conversely, where is the condemnation of this act within PA media? None. Infact, they hand our candies to celebrate it. That's the hypocrisy, Daniel. You claiming both sides are equal when the respect for respective civilians is not.
103. #21 - demonization of settlers as subhuman by Lefties?
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
Maybe that's why? Because after all, if the Leftists don't like you, you're fair game for any kind of attack, physical or on your character.
104. #22 - you mean like in Gaza after Cast lead?
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
Yes, the body count that went from 1400 down to 300 after Hamas admitted to lying about it. Better yet, let's look at real statistics and percentages. Out of the dead - and keep in mind that Israel protects their civilians better and with more earnest than do Arabs because we actually send civilians AWAY from war zones not use them as human shields.... what percentage of civilians were killed by Arab terrorists and what percentage by the IDF? By Arab terrorists - 89%! By IDF - 24% (low for comparable urban guerrilla-style warfare situations) Why? Because Arabs target civilians - that's called terrorism! But don't let facts hurt your train wreck of thought.
105. #22 - by the way, a 19yr with gun not equal civilian
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
nice try though. Please present your stats pointing to 1000 civilians claimed killed by IDF in 2 years. Please do not include those who died of natural causes, of hospital procedures and terminal diseases, or those killed by "work accidents" or rockets that fall short (there were plenty). GO!
106. #26 - name the incidents, bring proof
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
I don't recall one time when the IDF went into a "Palestinian" home, with the purpose to execute an entire family, awake or asleep. Infact, I don't recall anytime when the IDF went in with the intention to kill anyone who wasn't a wanted criminal/terrorists who was given the chance to surrender first. But you were in the IDF, so you tell me.
107. Well, that's one way of getting Intl attention after Japan
William ,   Israel   (03.13.11)
tsunami. "Palestinians" just can't stand it when the world concerns themselves with the plight of the other 7 billion citizens on this planet - 4 billion being non-Arab/Muslim and below the poverty level. This is certainly one way to get the world's sympathy again...kind of how they complained when the world was focused on Haiti after their earthquake.
108. When will you ever learn?
Robert ,   Brisbane Australia   (03.13.11)
After the terrors perpetrated on Palestinians by the IDF this attack pales into insignificance in comparison.
109. May G-d Avenge Their Blood
(03.13.11)
110. blair, US and barak to blame
mottel   (03.13.11)
The US and tony blair constantly pressure israel to remove security check points. Where sharon said n o, ehud barak who cannot say no yet admires shamir cause he told james baker No, quickly dismantled checkpoints. And so,a rabs found a weak point and did what they do best, kill innocent babies slitting their throats and gleeing about it like wild hyenas. Its not just israelis. Gazans celebrate the killing of 3000 americans on 9/11. education won't help change things. it is a culture of death against a culture of life and the 2 pass each other through the night. You know what putin would do if 5 russian babies were killed in their beds-he would incinerate the village from which the terrorists came, all of them no matter what. And tsipi livni made a bland comment that she feels bad for what happened and endorses idf action, a rather unenthusiastic reaction. abbas will pay for this outrage which he endorsed under the table.
111. a settlement is a reason to slaughter someone?
Abby ,   New York   (03.13.11)
To slash the throat of a 3 month old baby, a 2 year old in the heart- sleeping people????? You give credulence to these henious actions??? You condone murder - then the blood of this innocent family is on your head and others like you. Jews fight to protect their families from suicide bombers and monsters like like these murderers. We don't dance in the streets , like animals.
112. peace loving jew
abby ,   usa   (03.13.11)
Your not a peace loving jew Your a fence rider - whose afraid to stand up for his own people SHAME ON YOU! Self hating Jew. Coward!
113. Idiot
Mohamad Shahin ,   NJ, United States   (03.13.11)
This is how your a complete idiot and have no idea what your talking about. Islam does not allow this sort of brutality. There is absolutely no question to me that Israel is the most brutal state on the face of this earth when it comes to dealing with those that they still occupy--BUT these were innocent kids, Islam has never and will never support these sorts of crimes. Also idiot, Prophet Muhammad never called anyone apes and pigs...
114. fogel murder
keith ,   hagerstown usa   (03.13.11)
carpet bomb areas frequented by hamas.
115. to no. 78, there is no such people, address Arabs instead
(03.13.11)
and demand that they remove their illegal settlements from Jewish lands Arab occupation of the Middle East must end and region given back to its rightful native Owners, Kurds, Phoenicians, Copts, Druzee, Persians, Maronites, Black Darfurians, Assyriacs, Chaldeans and Jews
116. AMEN ve AMEN: # 1 & # 2
Israeli 2   (03.13.11)
AMEN ve AMEN!!
117.  2. Can someone tell me ....
split ,   US   (03.13.11)
You're making them pay for resisting their land theft and occupation more than dearly for last 60 years with no results, try something else, you narrow-minded idiot ,...
118. ANIMALS ANIMALS.YOUR PEACE PARTNERSM
URI   (03.13.11)
119. BOMB AN ARAB VILLAGE!
LR   (03.13.11)
120. My solution:
Jewish Warrior   (03.13.11)
Find the sick fuck who did this, do the same to HIS wife, children, and parents (who probably encouraged him), and force him to watch by cutting off his eyelids. THEN, shoot him with a bullet dipped in pig blood, wrap his carcass in pigskin, and bury him with pig guts.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article