News  Magazine
Secrets of Nabi Saleh protests
Yair Altman
Published: 26.03.11, 15:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. I like Photo, nice shot
Sam   (03.26.11)
2. Organized Protests
Edward ,   Savannah, USA   (03.26.11)
Seems to me that the WRONG people are being deported. Instead of deporting aliens that have peaceful Hebrew speaking kids back to their host country, it would be better for Israel to DEPORT these troublemakers OUT of Israel, to Brazil or some other place that has a high population of Palestinians in place. And the parents of these kids need to be shipped out for allowing their kids to act like this. Send them to Oboma since he loves these people so much!!!
3. Tamimi will be taken out very soon...
Julian ,   Warsaw, Poland   (03.26.11)
4. Laughable
Smith ,   TA, Israel   (03.26.11)
Nobody here ever heard of Michael Collin's or "the troubles" in Ireland and Northern Ireland respectively. What the hell do you think is going to happen in a situation of military occupation? This will continue indefinitely and so long as boys are boys throwing rocks will always be fun. Just look at settler kids.....
5. no. 4, but you always believe everything Arabs claim
(03.26.11)
and were duped by them time after time
6. When are we (BiBi) going to stop calling them "settlers"???
NU ,   Israel   (03.26.11)
This LIE is what causes all these problems.
7. And if we take down the wall they will just live in peace?!!
Emet ,   Israel   (03.26.11)
The foreign investors (EU), just like the PA only care about destroying Israel. Destruction is the goal (via the PA mercenaries) not peace.
8. This is IDF propaganda
Leon ,   Ottawa, Canada   (03.26.11)
Whose tear gas is being shot? Who is the armed force. Violent demonstraters, well according to international law, they are allowed to resist the occupation of their lands using violence. When a settler from the US is shot dead in the WB, that is called resistance. When the French killed Nazis in France, the Nazis also called them terrorists. If Israel wants peace, leave the WB and take your violent American or European settlers with you.
9. How about charging him with his real crime
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.26.11)
Incitement to commit GENOCIDE. That is what he has been doing and that is a war-crime. The penalty for that crime here is death, not 14 months.
10. Why these kids are not in school ?
Yossef   (03.26.11)
They don't want to become doctors or lawyers ? They don't want to make business ? Or build a country ?
11. Appalling journalism
peacelover ,   Washington, USA   (03.26.11)
Actually, I wouldn't flatter this piece of garbage by calling it journalism, it's little more than crude propaganda that attempts to demonize non-violent protests against Israel's colonization of Palestinian land. Shame.
12. This reads like...
Moshe ,   Kiryat Arba   (03.26.11)
This article is a very nice write-up of a police press release. I truly doubt the reporter ever visited Nabi Saleh or spoke to anyone involved in any way.
13. Occupation
Yolex   (03.26.11)
They are not in school because they are being occupied.
14. To No. 10 - that's why the demonstrations are on Friday
keren ,   tzafon, israel   (03.26.11)
There's no school on Friday for Muslim children.
15. to#8
Jennie ,   US/ISrael   (03.27.11)
As opposed to the pali terror groups, yes Israel fights the terror with their national legit.armed forces....Sorry, we don't have terror organizations, like chamas, fattah, etc..And just so you know, it is the palis, who are the occupiers and invaders of the land of Israel....And if you can't tell this board by who's laws, when and where exactly was the WB proclaimed the property of palis, then don't come on here with your obviously delusional statements..Did Israel use tear gas ? Prove it...And BTW, we don't have settlers. Our WB is occupied by Israeli Citizens and Jews who where either born there or came by choice. Where do you hink the palis came from ? All 99% of them ages 30 and up came from other arab countries....
16. #8 To the occupier of Algonquian land
Cynthia ,   USA   (03.27.11)
When an Israeli is shot dead in the West Bank, it's called murder. Pay attention to Palestinian use of children as soldiers. That is called child abuse.
17. This is a slanderous report
Kevin ,   Arlington, USA   (03.27.11)
I have actually met Naji Tamimi, and he told me that he and the other members of the Popular Resistance Council in Nabi Salih are committed to non-violence. This "testimony" was obtained from a kid who, from what I was told, was bullied and coerced to give this "evidence." There is rock-throwing, yes, but only after the IDF starts shooting. They see it as self-defense. This article is full of lies.
18. ynet and the rong resources
asad ,   jordan   (08.13.11)
every Friday for nearly four years now?????? relay this is great village if it since four year until now protesting ! i want to briefly correct this information that the protest only for the past one and half year.
Back to article