News
Soldier suspected of humiliating Palestinian kids
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 28.03.11, 15:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. #1. Yesha is as much Israel as Tel Aviv.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.28.11)
#1. Jewish "fanatics" in Yesha??? Where do you get rubbish like this? Yesha is the 3,500 year old heartland of Israel. It is as much part of Israel as Tel Aviv. Residents of Yesha are Jews in all walks of life, all age groups, both genders etc. You are the fanatic.
32. to#21
Jennie ,   US/Israel   (03.28.11)
Henous acts, exMarne? Sure...Coming from you, it is perceived as a compliment...The boys in IDf are not bored...Seems, you can contain your joy for having another blown out of proportion deliberate rumor patched up by the expert pali "fighters", who sold it to bloggers who can't wait to get some "dirt" on IDF...Where were you 2 weeks ago to opine on the most brutal masacre of a whole Jewish Family...IDF could easily crash and turn gaza into a football field..but they are more mercyful to a life of another human being, then to defend their own Nation...And little people like you can't wait to get off by blaming Israel for anything...
33. #21 These incidents occur far less often
Claudia ,   Tampa USA   (03.28.11)
than do the rockets shot from Gaza by the poor abused Hamas agents that hide behind women and children, and terrorists acts like bombing buses and murdering infants in their beds. Perhaps you'd be better off thinking up methods the Palestinians could use to protect their children, like teaching them ways to consider peaceful interaction between Muslims and Jews & Christians, rather than the hate they are taught & confronted with from the cradle, and the rocks placed in their hands to prove their manhood. This does not excuse any IDF soldier from abusing children or anyone else, but from experience I know that 18 year olds are not the most mature individuals and yet they are called upon to defend their country under some of the most extreme circumstances. Education is in order here on behalf of both Israelis and Palestinians. In fact I read that the IDF has stepped up it's classes on how to deal with both Palestinians, Israeli and WB'ers. You should know that...as an ex Marine... but you don't seem to. You only want to smear and name call. Great soldier you must have been.
34. # 19: If only you were right
Raed ,   Palestine   (03.28.11)
if acts of kindness were more than acts of cruelty we wouldnt have seen 2 intifada's going on # 3 you need to accept the fact that acts of kindness in military occupation are extremely rare. ruling a civilian population with military means puts your solders humanity and morals at risk, that's a FACT of all military occupations, where the stronger party gets to play GOD and civilians become slaves.
35. #20
Jennie ,   US/Israel   (03.28.11)
I dissagree, wintergreen...You are an Israeli, who is most possibly a far left liberal. If your fist instinct is to attack your own, you haven't learned nothing yet. But life will teach you something: You should always be on the side of your own people.. They(IDF) are the ones who defend your life..Your loyalty to those who enable you write this garbage, should be valued a little higher, then to the enemy, who has no limits in ways to influence the weak souls like yours....
36. so called humiliation
Aaron Greenberg ,   Brooklyn, NY USA   (03.28.11)
I can't understand how this is the number one story after all the truly heinous incidents that have occurred such as Jerusalem bombing and Fogel barbaric murders. A. Greenberg, USA
37. most moral army in the world
anton ,   istanbul turkey   (03.28.11)
38. IDF and Israeli police
J.Sheps ,   NY, NY   (03.28.11)
The point of this article is obviously a leftists self hating jewish expression, but nevertheless another point needs to be made. Do Israelis even remotely understand what their behavior is like and that it is not "cool" to ape the other nations practices. If they truly can't build a society on Jewish values which by the way under no circumstances allow for mistreatment of people living under your guard let alone your own fellow jews (your police are no better than animals towards its jewish citizens) and the IDF were not heroes when they pulled out 8000 of their own in Gush Katif, then do everyone in the world a mitzvah and leave Israel! We invite all of you to join a growing number of Israelis living here in NYC. Here you can act out your "goyishe" fantasies!
39. #21 No such thing as an "ex-Marine"
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (03.28.11)
Once a Marine, always a Marine. One can be retired from active duty, but still & always a Marine. Ergo: you are not and were never in the USMC.
40. #34 Where is Palestine?
Jewdah ,   Beverly HIlls, Ca   (03.28.11)
How can Arab muslim violence directed against Jews in Israel stop when Arabs are so dishonest with themselves as not to be able to say they live in the couintry called Israel.? When Arabs can also muster enough honesty to tell the world my own Arab brothers are oppressing me, thats when there will be peace!
41. to#34
Jennie ,   US/Israel   (03.28.11)
Who are you trying to fool here,raed ? Act of kindness ? Is Israel occupyig Gaza now ? Last time checked, Israel has withdrew from gaza 7years ago...You are being occupied by your own chamas, fattah,etc...If anyone ever showed you kindness, it is the IDF, who warns your people before they have no choice, but take out your terror wholes... Israel provides most of your basic needs, while you shoot kassams at them...The truth is, that you are still alive, because of Israel's efforts...If this is not enough, go and complain to abbas and chaniye...You should talk about acts of cruelty ?
42. # 40: i'm pragmatist
Raed ,   Palestine   (03.28.11)
>>when Arabs are so dishonest with themselves as not to be able to say they live in the country called Israel.? No one told me i lived in Israel? is Bethlehem, Ramallah, Hebron, Jenin, Jericho ISRAEL? Can i apply for Israeli passport and tell them Jewdah from Beverly hills sent me? I live here, and your saying here is ISRAEL, i would like to Vote in the next election, where can i register?
43. Anton, #37
Golani ,   Vineland, USA   (03.29.11)
You took the words right out of my mouth. Yes, Israel has one the most moral armies in the world, if not the most. Thank you!
44. Corrupting good Israeli boys for settlers
Basil ,   Morgantown, WV   (03.29.11)
You are corrupting people from Herzliya, Tel Aviv, Haifa and other places for the sake of an abysmal attempt to keep suppressing the Arabs and placate the settlers who cost a lot of money. It's a waste. To control other people encourages making Jewish boys like that. It's the system's fault, too.
45. to Salma 53
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (03.29.11)
No one is occupying "you"-you live in Israel.You teach your indoctrinated "children " to be suicide bombers because you are cowards.Why aren't your leaders and your self included suicide bombers-it's because you don't want to die but let your "children" die for you.Go to JORDAN or GAZA where you belong.
46.  MARINE JEFF
UNCLE JOE ,   U S A   (03.29.11)
WHERE'S YOUR BUDDY MUTT .I BET YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A BEEBEE GUN AND AN M16. LET ME GUESS ,YOU'RE JUST A BAR DRUNK AND DRUG ADDICT AND YOU HAVE ALWAYS BEEN A DISHWASHER AT ''FRIENDLY'S'' .A DUMB F... . GO TO HELL OR COME HERE AND SEE ME ,YES ME .I'LL FIX YOUR ARSE, IF YOUR HOMEBOY MUTT IS NOT .
47. #21; Jeff, You already redefined the word
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (03.29.11)
When we look up the word "putrid" we see your picture, right? How typical for the anti-Israel writer's, take an atypical situation then blow it out of proportion. We don't judge the USA military by those in Leavenworth, do we? So until you want Marines judged by those in the Marine Corps Brig at Quantico, Virginia, Do us all a favor keep the sarcastic remarks to yourself. The last time I looked, I've never heard of Hamas, PLO, Fatah or any other Arab group even the ones that claim government status, elected by their people and that are the current government, arrest any of their terrorists, have you Jeff? What justice system do the Pals have in place to punish those that mistreat and murder Jewish people and when have you read of any arrests? Oh, I guess their perfect and never commit crimes, right Jeff? Talk with David Duke lately? Stay tuned you may also get your picture in the dictionary under the word"hypocrite" too!
48. video
al ,   united states   (03.29.11)
its a shame because it makes an otherwise above reproach army look bad. To all those saying hateful things, the IDF is in general a group of moral young men doing their duty to their country...this is not typical. It only takes one bad apple to make the bunch look bad, but they are not.
49. # 35 Jenny
Wintergreen   (03.29.11)
Jenny - would you approve such behaviour if it were a member of your family? Would you allow any son/daughter/brother/sister or yours to abuse and humiliate a weaker individual (not to mention take pleasure in the act)? The IDF has a moral code to which soldiers should adhere. It behoves us as a people to confront such acts.
50. to#49
Jennie ,   US/Israel   (03.29.11)
I dont believe it for one minute...Neither should you...This what they do, when there is nothing left for their justification...You have to decide who's side are you on...Who is is protecting you and risks their lives for you...Don't be such an easy prey for their brainwash and lies..., wintergreen...I know my children and their friends...None of the IDF would stoop to such low....They risking their lives to save a pali child, if they can...Don't you know?See the big picture..
51. to # 50 Jennie
Wintergreen   (03.29.11)
Jennie - I do not jump to attack these soldiers. Don't twist the argument. The 'big picture' as you state is the notion of due process. The investigation of individuals when there is evidence suggesting inappropriate behaviour. The fact that they are soldiers should have nothing to do with it (Katzav being a fine example that position should not dictate immunity). Please re-read the headline. The big picture concerns how we behave. I would not generalise that none of the IDF would stoop to such lows as you do. That is wrong. There are bad apples in every bunch, the IDF included. Our task is to minimise the incorrect behaviour and to instil a strong set of ethical and moral codes within our sons and daughters. As a society we must lead by example.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article