News  Magazine
Interview with a spy
Einat Fishbein
Published: 28.03.11, 19:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
31. sounds to me like she is upset she got caught & thats all
zionist forever   (03.29.11)
" I don't like thinking of myself as naive but whats characterizes my actions plenty of naivete. The thought that you can take documents of an army base without getting caught, that you can hand them over to a journalist and he'll protect you. " That sounds to me the fact she was caught rather than actually regretting what she had done. The woman is an idealist and you don't give up on your ideals just because you got in trouble because of them. If she knew 101% if she did this again she could get away with it and there would be no comebacks I can imagine she would do it again. If she didn't strongly believe in what she was doing she wouldn't have done it. Alot of this little speech sounds its come from a lawyer who probably wants her to speak out and say the right things to influence public opinion in her favor. Turn public opinion from traitor to naive little girl who didn't understand what she was doing was such a bad thing. Public opinion helped convict her now they want public opinion to keep her out of jail. It is not treachery what she did but she was also not a naive little girl who didn't know she was doing wrong. She deserves to be locked up for a long time not only as a punishment but to also send a message to anybody that dreams of following in her footsteps. Make sure everybody understands this isn't like jaywalking and they will be severely punished for it.
32. Anat Kam
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (03.29.11)
Perfect example of new law - take away her Israeli citizenship - she was a traitor - naive or not. Let me put this another way - if a worker steals property from a company and said company finds out, this worker is fired. Anat Kam stole property from the Army; stole sensitive information and gave it to the media - hence a traitor. My guess is she has no ruler for right and wrong. Maybe we caught a sociopath in the making.
33. Hate, ingnorance and revenge
Leonid   (03.29.11)
Most of the comments on this thread reveal hate, ignorance and revenge. The young girl is grappling with mixed feelings about what she did. She's not sure why she did it. Can you imagine that she's just trying to be honest about her feelings? She is a human being caught up in very unusual circumstances. She will be severely punished, so there is no need for you spitting out your hate, ignorance and complete lack of understanding. If a loved person of yours, perhaps a child, did something like this, wouldn't you have a bit of compassion for them? And by the way, classified information is often leaked by the army to the press. So you may go ahead and vent out your hate on those unnamed army officials often quoted in most papers.
34. 33
Zionist forever   (03.29.11)
True the army leaks information to leak. Anat Kamm did not own that information she STOLE so it was not hers to give to the press. If I want to write a diary If I want I can give it away. If somebody I employ picks up my diary reads it and doesn't like something they read in it they have no right to steal my diary and give it to somebody else. She was not a naive victim she is an idealist and she was not so stupid that she didn't believe she was doing anything wrong. It may not be trachery but she knew what she was doing when she stole that information and gave it to Blau. Her intent was have Blau publish this stuff that so angered her. If she s a victim it I Blau led her to believe she would not get into trouble. She deserves to be locked up for many many years as a punishment for committing this crime and to send a message to other idealists you do this and you will pay a heavy price, I only hope the IDF have learned from this and have updated their security systems to stop it happening again.
35. #34
Leonid   (03.29.11)
I unsderstand your point. I don't claim she didn't know what she was doing. She did what she did. She is confused about it, but she is prepared to take responsibility and go to jail. Your diary analogy doesn't always hold. If someone reads in your diary that you're intending to kill someone, then they may steal it and give it away to somebody else to prevent the crime, right?
36. 33,35 Leonid Wake up.
Eran ,   Singapore   (03.29.11)
Very nice for you to be compassionate towards this poor girl who lost her way.. You don't give a damn that her act may have killed the sons daughters and brothers and sisters of Israel in large quantities by enemy terrorism and military actions. Why don't you act to get back Gilad Shailt instead of your jeremiades here? You really are full of it. Shame on you.
37. FREE POLLARD NOW!
Cameron ,   USA   (03.29.11)
right?
38. She says she's not really a leftist...
Aharon   (03.29.11)
but votes for Meretz? Come on. She may as well carry around a "palestinian" identity card.
39. 36 Eran get real
Leonid   (03.29.11)
The poor girl will get her punishment. I don't need to be hateful towards her. How do you know what I do or don't give a damn about? I am talking about the hate that you and others like you are spitting out, while she is getting ready to go to jail. Prove that her act may have killed anybody. I don't see how. If you can't prove it, then it is just your wild imagination. How do you know whether I act to get back Gilad Shalit? And what do you do to get him back? Did it ever cross your mind that you yourself could be full of it?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article