News
Barak: Iron Dome not perfect
Tova Dadon
Published: 31.03.11, 12:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. protection.
almina ,   rochester, kent   (03.31.11)
jarmil explained that the two leather clad men living further up the road were both "barrens". this seemed to mean homosexual, to judge by their silver chained caps. because they were barren, homosexual thus sterile? only lords carried shields, of whatever colour. and i do not mean press lords, i speak of bum barons.
2. Several years
JEW1 ,   ASHDOD   (03.31.11)
Several years? Does it mean that shderot, eskol and negev have to wait several years till they get protection? They should be the first in line to get this dome and not Beer-sheva and Ashdod. But our government is protecting Dimona and port in Ashdod and not the people.
3. what ?
fad egypt   (03.31.11)
additional batteries will be deployed in the next years that means that israel according to barak will never defeat the terror from gaza or invade gaza to bring hamas down and will deped all the time on the defensive approach wich is useless and ineffective and expensive shame on barak
4. Iron Dome... more like a hair net.
seadog1946 ,   InTransit, USA   (03.31.11)
5. JEW1 @ 2, I see your point, but think about it for a moment.
leo ,   usa   (03.31.11)
Isn't protecting Dimona and port in Ashdod would be the same as protecting people? Just imagine what would happen to the entire country if either is our of commission.
6. Israel Must Remember On e Thing
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (03.31.11)
If Hamas uses civilians as human shields. Then they become legitimate targets for the IDF, clearly you can't give any enemy a safe harbor, so to speak, from which to attack their enemy. So when the IDF attacks, it may need video proof to make their point. But don't think it's a necessity. Look the IDF has dropped pamphlets (warning civilians to get out of the way), giving up the element of surprise, and host of other impressive moves. But in the end, from a Pallywood PR view it made no difference. In fact there are recorded instances where the Arab leaders called and text messaged the Arab citizens cellphones, asking them to come to the target, and stand on the roof, to prevent Israel from attacking the target. This is the epitome of cynicism on the Arabs part. So don't worry about that aspect anymore. When many in the world attack you, even when clear proof exists of your innocence, it frees you in way, Because you have nothing to lose! In the PR sense they will always portray you as demons. So do what is truly necessary to win the battles, and War.
7. please stop throwing good money after bad
zionist forever   (03.31.11)
Iron Dome was not even developed because the government felt there was a need for it the thing was developed as an attempt to boost Olmert's image after Lebanon. Hizbollah fired rockets during the war so Olmert announced after that we were not going to develop something to stop that without having any idea how much it would cost etc. The only condition is this system must be made in israel we must not buy anything that anybody else has designed. It must be made in Israel to boost the feel good factor. He just said here is $300-$400 million dream something up and the end result was Iron Dome. Not only does each battery cost millions but each interceptor cost $50,000 and they are used to shoot down $10 kassams.. In Lebanon if we had Iron Dome operating we would have run out of interceptors within less than half an hour so it has zero use as a battlefield weapon. The other week when a load of Grads were fired, if we had shot down every one of them with iron Dome it would have cost near $1 million. Each battery which Barak wants to buy more of cost around the same price as three F16s. The three years between the pull out of Gaza in 2005 - Cast Lead in 2008 we would have been able to buy an entire squadren of F16s for the same price as it would have cost us in iron Dome interceptors alone. If we start buying more batteries the IDF is going to have to drop plans for many more valuable assets to fund it. As for Barak announcing the thing isn't perfect. What kind if idiot defense minister announces that the system we are about to put into operation against rockets isn't perfect for Hamas to hear and at the same time says we will buy more batteries of this imperfect system. If we were smart we would sell off the current two batteries to anybody who wants to buy and then buy something useful.
8. #4 seamongrel
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.31.11)
Nothing is quite as perfect as you pretend to be With your great wisdom you should be able to impart a suggestion or two that would make it perfect Hmmm, despite all the security at American Airports, they still manage to smuggle explosives on board planes, concealed in shoes and underwear If instead of a hairnet, maybe then can design it to resemble a scumbag, in your image ?
9. iron dome
colin   (03.31.11)
After years of lies and waste the minister of eviction of woman and children hides behind a few truthful words that the iron dome is a useless piece of junk.It was always another means to extort money from the state for his leasure trips.
10. The "Accord" is dead anyway.
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (03.31.11)
Regaining control of the Philadelphi Route would do the job at a reasonable cost.
11. A certain and fast way to get bankrupt ,...
split ,   US   (03.31.11)
Every time you push a button on that thing trying to shut down $15 home made flying gutter $50.000. will be gone with smoke - It will be fun to watching it missing and fail ,...
12. 7 - we would have been able to buy an entire squadren of F16
split ,   US   (03.31.11)
You ain't buying it I do - I'm paying for your "purchase",...
13. #12 Split/Schizo/Wes
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.31.11)
Console yourself; you're not paying for them, resulting in the loss of thousands of jobs that would have been created if the U.S. built the F16's Thereby increasing U.S. Unemployment instead of diminishing it Even the likes of you, should realize that every dollar that Israel receives, is mandated by U.S. Law to be spent on American products manufactured in the USA Feel worse now, I hope so !! They’re holding your place in the Unemployment line, hurry before you lose it !
14. Iron Dome will not provide deterrence
Brod ,   USA   (03.31.11)
Israel's deterrence will be insured when the Leftist Barak is replaced with a strong Right Wing leader like Ya'alon as Defense Minister. Barak might have been a strong soldier when he was younger. But when he grew older-now in his 60s he becomes a Leftist wimpy man in the face of external aggressions from Israel's enemies, and in the face of external pressures from the world of AntiSemites spearheaded by Hussien and his sidekicks Samantha Powers, Susan Rice, Biden, etc. This emboldens the dark forces-world of AntiSemites and Islamist-Jihadists/usurpers to crusade against Israel. Israel needs to reinforce its Deterrence by having a strong Right Wing leader as Defense Minister. This is not just common sense. This is Wisdom.
15. " IRON DOME NOT PERFECT "
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (03.31.11)
In plain english ; A PIECE OF CRAP (an expensive one at that ) .
16. # 2
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.31.11)
you are right israel doesnt protect its people lol
17. #3
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.31.11)
you are right fad israel will never defeat hamas, finally you are starting to get it LOL
18. #6 israel must remember one thing
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.31.11)
everything you said about hamas being a legitimate target when they use people as human shields applies to israel so it goes on both sides
19. #7 totally agree
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.31.11)
the iron dome was not developped to protect israeli people, israel doesnt care about its people but it cares about the image of its politicians like olmert totally agree with you, good thing you guys finally are getting it...
20. #9 totally agree
deutronomy 28 ,   world   (03.31.11)
the iron dome is to extort money from the state for his leasure trips and not to protect israeli people, israeli politicians do not care about their people but they care about their leasure trips...good thing you are finally getting it...
21. the pinhead @ 13,...
split ,   US   (03.31.11)
"that every dollar that Israel receives, is mandated by U.S. Law to be spent on American products manufactured in the USA". $3.00 out of $4.00 as a matter of fact, the remaining $1.00 stays in Israel and subsidises your military industrial complex making our products harder to sell. I have a better Idea that's going to work for both of us. Why don't we pass the money directly to six-pack Joe instead of to you and tell him to stay home and take care of his "latchkey" kids - This way our kids are going to be raised by their parents, we're going to keep that $1.00 that stays in Israel and you guys are going to learn how to survive without handouts ,... What do you say, deal ? ,...
22. 21 Split/schizo/wes
BENJABO ,   ISRAEL   (03.31.11)
Yup it stays in Israel and the new material that Israel develope is shared with the USA Case in point, to enhance your obvious ignorance, many of the electronics in American planes are devleloped and manufactured in Israel, some of these planes are delivered to our enemies, with Israel component markings removed ISRAEL & USA DEVELOP INFRARED BEAM WEAPON *PIC* Oct 7, 2003 ... Israel and the USA have actively developed advanced laser and infrared ... on the Israeli-American advanced weapons co-operation is found below: ... A plasmoid cloud is a heated and ionized gas that can be created and ... www.rumormillnews.com/cgi-bin/archive.cgi?read=37686
23. 20 - iron dome is to extort money from the state ,...
split ,   US   (04.01.11)
What State? For what I know it's US funded project. 6-pack Joe is paying for this piece of junk called "dome" keeping their "industry" afloat.
Back to article