and for these people it isn't. they will of course seize upon immoralities in zionist endeavour to paint zionism itself as immoral. every nation has immoral history, neither has israel has been around long enough to have effected the ethnic cleansing of tasmania or manhattan, nor am i ever radically chic about these people. i recommend radical indifference. plus: as the european and western right wing elites have only been quite recently quite open and receptive to jews/zionism/israel etc.. many jews have a history of left wing politics as that was the only place they were politically emancipated. this is moving the other way now actually. bread is buttered.

Sorry to tell you, Gaza is part of Egypt, and The palestinians home is Jordan, to call Israel and occupier is to ignore all relevant facts, When palestinians love their kids more than they hate Israel there will be peace,... BTW, I challange any of the defenders of the Islamo-facists and left wing idiots to go live in a Muslim country especially female ones,... I am sure they will take to Sharia law,..... I heard getting stoned for wearing a mini-skirt feels great.

Chomsky loves the Clown in Chief of the Bolibananian Revolution. A movement born to create a CIVIL WAR in Venezuela, aiming to destroy democracy and test Chomsky dream of comunism in a OIL Rich country...............killing people seems right to el Che followers as do Chomsky's.

Israel is the only country in the world that can turn oppression they impose on Arabs and remake themselves into victims. Those 'peaceful' IDF soldiers were attacked by violent Turkish activists. Peaceful Israel was attacked for 'no' reason by the terrorists Hamas. Israel never invaded Gaza, the WB, the Sinai or Lebanon, they simply 'defended' themselves. The author has named numerous, decent and intelligent people who can see through this Hasbara and they are speaking out.

THESE RATS ARE NOT SELF-HATING JEWS. THAT IS A SILLY TERM. THEY ARE JEW-HATING JEWS. THEY MUST BE FOUGHT WITH THE GREAT JEWISH WEAPON- "JEW-MONEY". JEWS MUST DIVEST FROM ALL UNIVERSITIES PROMOTING ANTI-ISRAEL AND ANTI-JEWISH MOVEMENTS. THEY MUST BOYCOTT ANTI-ISRAEL COUNTRIES SUCH AS BRITAIN AND TURKEY. THESE ANTI-ISRAEL JEWS SHOULD BE TREATED AS THE ENEMY.

The first marine picked the bean, the seond marine cooked the bean, the third marine ate the and the fourth marine (so he claims) was Jeff, who is all shit over the submarine, HINKEY DINKEY PARLEVOUS Hey there our Ersatz hereo, you should be in Palestine helping out instead of just hiding in the USA pretending concern Your MOS WAS ?

and their terrorists are unfairly occupying the Jewish land of Israel causing nothing but misery to both Arabs and Jews.They always align themselves with thugs and all those who prefer commotion and chaos to peace and tranquility. May Hashem forgive the delirious Jews who spew their vehom on Israel.

We have always had them and we will continue to have them. They just bring with them more challenges to the Jewish world. Naturally, they are used and appreciated by all haters of Israel.

Paul Johnson...I can't figure out how the people that had fought the hardest and waited the longest for their own state both in antquity and since WW2 are so innclined to worry about everybody elses rights to statehood and then deny their own aspirations-it makes no sense. There is nothing moral about the Arab cause, the Pal cause, hezbollahs cause, hamas cause Irans or Syria's. Israel is a noble cause and an honorable one. The Jewish left are what they always have been: Useful Idiots, nothing more, nothing less.

Wonderful analysis. You forgot to add to the list Karl Marx and Leo Trotsky - great company to Rosa Luxemburg and other commies!

The British Guardian has a stable of Jewish and Israeli writers who write sick and nasty anti-Zionist articles.The Guardian itself would have to be one of the worst anti-Israeli and anti-Semitic rags.Mean and nasty.

If you call Marek Edelman a traitor, what hapend to Holy Land ceases to be my concern.

you are trying to make Einstein (z´l) speak words he never said. Although he was critical of some aspects of Israel (then "Ishuv") policies, however he was an ardent Zionist, he gave violin concerts for fundraising, he travelled specially (no planes then) to the launching of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and he left all his papers to them. So please don't try to tarnish Eisntein name with your foul opinions. Don't mix his name with those dirty, self-hating jews.

To the human body, these so called "intellectuals" are ashamed of their own people, they dont beleive in G-d, they despise Torah and all of Jewish traditions and enlightment, and they have to attack other Jews and of course the Jewish State, so that they can be a part of the "inn" people, The so called BEAUTIFUL PEOPLE, they dont know, that whatever they say or do, they will always be "Jews" in the eyes of those trying to please on the outside, and sadly, They are traitors, a real Cancer to Israel and the Jewish people. As history has shown, and in spite of them, Israel and the Jews will survive, to their sorrow AM ISRAEL HAI

Why don't we change the name "Israel" ABV, The Association of Blameless Victims? Everyone hates us, simply because they envy us: The German hate us because we are so clean and punctual. The French hate us because of our rich literature and culture. The Black hate us because we are so well endowed (with good qualities, that is). And now...even the Jews hate us! And we have done nothing to deserve that. And ,by the way, even if their criticism is true, why don't they criticise global warming instead?

Hearing and reading the truth about Israel from 'noted' Jews themselves is somthing Israel and Zionists can't tolerate...hahahaha... I guess the one who really matters in all of it is OBAMA! TATA

How would you explain the causes to the big phenomian among some Jews. Do they hate the fact they were born of Jewish Blood. If so why don't they change their name and religion. Nobody would really know?? Or do they crave the attention and get a very deep satisfaction of some sort.

I was going to say: EX MARINE??? His MOS must have been 4300 (Yellow Journalism).

The supposed ''jewish elite / intelligentsia'' is only an infinite minority of the jewish people. The most humble of Jews is just as intelligent. It is the same group of that believed that Germany was their homeland and they were safe. It is also the same group that will quickly expect Israel to be there for them when ''anti-semitism'' which is on the rise will make them targets. I love the fact that ISRAEL is strong and will remain that way. I love the fact that Israel is at the forefront of innovation and technology, I love the fact that Israel is on the verge of becoming the richest country in the world. I love the fact that Israel will have wealth and technology and the like of "SOROS etc...'' can eat their heart out. NEVER AGAIN!

Yeah, insulte me! say i am disgusting, sick in my mind, but until you did not live inside Israel you can not understand. i used to be the most proud jew in the world, and i'm still proud when you put Israel between (). i will never harm the state, but i sincerly think that Israel should not have existed. i beleive that even if we suffered so much while being without a state, at least we stayed being Jews. Israel destroys pur identity that we built during 2000 Years. We should be a light among the nations and we bacame darkness among the nations. You CAN NOT imagine how i love my people, how i love my religion, how i beleive in the beauty of my religion, but a faith build during 2000 years does not go along with a moderm state. Are we safer now, with a stong army??? No!!! we are not! we survived because of our brain! no nation survived because of its weapons! Israel will destroy the jewish nation by itself. Israel will destroy 2000 years of achievment. Oh brothers, you can not imagine how i love my people and i'm so sad of what we bacame. May god brings asap his reing on earth so his prophetie can be fullfilled and manking can be saved from distruction.

These are the same Jews who will contribute heavily to Obama's election bid in 2012. They now know he is anti Israel and probably anti Jewish except when he wants their campaign funds, but they don't care because this shows how liberal they are.

sciense, he only got logistic sciense degree, he got no qualification in history sciense either, sad to say but people actually believe that he man of expert, but in relality he is pathetic, he didn't made that splash in the logistic world than he go to field he can get self credit better. but his self torment and abuse will hunt him for sure. ho the lost soul of an idiot.

Leaberman, Nathenyahu these two turn Perez into liar disgraced him front of nations, been humiliated and killing thoese Turkish citizens in that ship did more damage to Israel than anything, Turks were and still are very loyal suporters of the Jews 1000 years they were always there and what we do we kill them,and I am a shame

Given to one Muslim before achieving anything while the same Muslim conducting 2 wars and starting a 3rd one Such prizes are empty of any meaning No wonder you are incapable in comprehending such fine subtleties

Hi Michael. You can add me to your mile-long list but I don't give a damn. You seem incapable of distinguishing between loyal opposition such as Oz, Grossman, Haaretz, JStreet and real anti-Israel Jews such as Chomsky or Judt. Also unlike you living in your guilder ghetto of Boca I'm an Israeli living in Israel with children serving in the IDF. When you can put your sorry tusik where your brave mouth is and move here (into the sights of Hamas, Hezbollah) then you may be taken seriously, at least by the far right wingers currently running our lives.

What all those Jews you mentioned had in common was their unfounded faith in communist revolution. Communism like Fascism is a totalitarian Utopianism that brought death and misery literally to 100s of millions of people. That such Jews still exist in the form of Chomsky or the Roses only shows that intelligence is no substitute for common sense!

It seems to me that also you, as so many other (and many orthodox!) jews do not see all the open miracles which occured and occure before our eyes in and around Israel. Eretz Israel flourishes economically as no other country (it's Bracha min Hashamaim, not man-made), whereever Jews settle in Eretz Israel nature starts to blossom (its Bracha min Hashamaim, not man-made), Hashem pushing Jews gently to move to Israel (History is made in Shamaim) and Eretz Israel and Am Israel and Eretz Israel becoming more and more the focus of world History. The Jews making the Egel Hasahav did also not see the Yad Hashem at Kriat Yam Suf a few weeks earlier!

but i think the is one of the zionists propaganda machines , to show the world that there are good jews around !!! lies lies lies ...

who hate other Jews. These anti-Semitic Jews become the "good" Jews while the rest of us or the majority are treated as the "bad" Jews. Had it not been for the strident anti-Semitism of the hateful Jews they would have never been as famous as they are. Somehow the anti-Semitic Jews will get their day of reckoning. They shame their ancestors who must be tossing in their graves.

anti-Semitic Jews? These Jews are born sick to their very core. When the Jews hate their people as much as Finkelstein, Goldstone or Chomsky do they must be afflicted with an incurable condition on the level of cancer or muscular destrophy..