News
Arab MKs furious at Shin Bet chief
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 08.04.11, 16:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
76 Talkbacks for this article
1. Agreed. So leave. ASAP.
Ben Yisrael ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (04.08.11)
Jordan is Palestine, by the way. Have a nice trip.
2. sana and zoabi
moshon   (04.08.11)
they say that they are part of the palestinian nation yet not at the expense of their israeli citizenship. Consider what this means. They want to destroy israel but want to keep their israeli citizenship, benefits, modernity, democratic rights even though israel may not exist since that is the goal of the palestinians and entire arab world. No, sorry there are limits. Liberman is 100% dead right. If you tip off the enemy, or incite, you lose citizenship and go to jail. And weinstein, you better be 1000% sure of conviciton should you decide to indict liberman. He has more bravery in one finger than all of your buddies, especially the coward lawyers-olmert, livni and ramon, the coward trio, and israel needs lieberman who stands his ground and gives barak some strength as his tendancy is constant concessions. Liberman is worth 2 divisions to israel as the arabs are scared of him whereas they do not fear livni, peres or barak.
3. WHy ? What said Diskin is not true ?
Yossef   (04.08.11)
Come on "cousins" you know very well that Diskin said the truth, remember your travel in Libya, for example. But is this inevitable ? Can you work for your arab brothers in Israel, for the well being of the whole Israel ? This is the question ?
4. you think we dont know
Israeli   (04.08.11)
when you take the oath of loyalty to the State of Israel when entering the Knesset - you are lying through your collective teeth? Hamas and Hizbollah might as well be sitting in our Knesset as you represent them, you think we dont know? do you think it will be tolerated by us forever? You abuse our democracy to destroy us from within. Even the Leftie politicians have no illusions about who you really are. I assure you this foolish state of affairs will not always be this way, you will end up in jordan one way or another. There can be no co-existence with those that wish to destroy and exterminate us every day. We Jews build and respect life, you lot only know how to destroy and worship death. Any wonder your societies all around the world where Islam dominates is in its primitive state? As long as you have Islam you will always live in poverty, destruction and backwardness and caveman primitivism. Yes you dont belong in the 21st century. Get with the times or become extinct.
5. The Truth hurts, eh?
Isaac ,   USA   (04.08.11)
6. MK Zoabi clearly u don't care because if you did....
just askin' ,   right here   (04.08.11)
you would be working on assisting women who suffer at the hands of their husbands. Particularly Arab women who are subject to "family honor" killings.... where were you this week when the latest one was murdered?
7. Diskin has defined us as enemies not citizens
zionist forever   (04.08.11)
WHERE IS THE EVIDENCE HE IS WRONG? Bishra - he is hiding out in Jordan after betraying us to Hizbollah during a war. Tibi - when has he ever been proud to be a Israeli citizen or condemned a terror attack instead he justifies them by blaming it all on occupation. Zouabi - She has even said before she thinks it would be a good thing if Iran got nukes so they could counter Israel. "We will never deny that we are part of the Palestinian nation, but this is not at the expense of our Israeli citizenship" What have you done to earn the right to that citizenship? You support terror, you hold special events where you burn the flag and say its a catastrophe Israel was ever created. The whole bunch of them are treacherous and should have their citizenship revoked and then be deported to Hamastan where they can be amongst their own kind.
8. Arab MKs furious
Df ,   Beer Sheva, Israel   (04.08.11)
Has any Arab MK said anything about Azmi Bishara consorting with those who aim at destroying Israel ? And then leaving Israel to escape being put on trial for treason ? Has any Arab MK condemned the rocketing of the school bus by Hamas ? Zoabi has lost all of her credibility for her lies about what happened on board the Marmara.
9. Zoabi
Moragh   (04.08.11)
Please YNetnews, do me one favour - whatever the clown Zobi has to say, by all means print it. However please try and avoid enclosing her picture with the Caption. She simply has a smug face that I'd like to punch in.
10. "Palestinian nation" Who are they?
Shabbat Shalom   (04.08.11)
How many years have they been around? Are they any different than other Arabs, esp. your brothers the Jordanians? Since the answer is an obvious 'no', I'd advise you to take all your Palestinians brothers from the Jewish country, back to where you came from; i.e. Jordan. For the sake of peace, please do this as soon as possible. Thank you!
11. The Pure True
Abraham Nachmias ,   Petach Tikva IL   (04.08.11)
No matter what the left may say, this is the truth! Arabs MK are not a proof of Israel's democracy but a proof of Israel's naivety. If we banned Kahana, why should we support this enemies of the state sitting at the Knesset? They use democracy and we should make a case to shout this to the world and forbid this perfidy use.
12. The truth hurts
Jake   (04.08.11)
These Arab MK's (who have never done an iota to advance the interests and well-being of the Arab Israelis) are upset because the cover has been blown on the real root of the problem: The "Palestinization" and Islamic radicalization of parts of the Arab sector, due to immigration into Israel of palestinian Arab 'refugees'. Bedouin have also been taking wives in Gaza (that's up to 4 per man), and settling them in Israel, where they are prolific in being fruitful and multiplying. The Negev has become a hotbed of the Islamic Movement, a political party with close affiliations to Hamas and the Moslem Brotherhood.
13. Is it same Zoabi that was onboard flotilla that attacked IDF
Jeremy ,   UK   (04.08.11)
Ah ok.
14. if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck..
arshile gorky ,   nyc, usa   (04.08.11)
...and sounds like a duck, it's probably a duck.
15. Evidence
mea   (04.08.11)
By visiting enemy states against Israeli law, by refusing to support an oath of alliegience, by never condemning killings like the Itmar murders, by never bringing forth legislation which is about equal rights instead of anti-Israel rights, by never really getting in line with the communal idea of nation building but always taking adversarial positions, the Arab faction lends itself to what Diskin said and what he echoed from all Israel supporters, these MKs represent a prying away isolationists faction of the Arab culture in Israel. That is the problem Diskin spoke of. He was right.
16. They finally got it!
tiki ,   belgium   (04.08.11)
"We're part of the Palestinian nation, but not at the expense of Israeli citizenship" (including all Israeli benefits). These people don't 'flirt with the enemy, they ARE the enemy!
17. But they are "hostile enemies." They think Jews are stupid
Sami ,   New York, USA   (04.08.11)
But they are "hostile enemies." They think Jews are stupid
18. Aren't you enemies? If so, demonstrate it to us!!
JBI ,   Israel   (04.08.11)
19. Part of Palestinian nation?
Abed ,   Nazareth, Israel   (04.08.11)
Then leave! Go to the territories and see how long you last. You've gotten too used to how well you are treated in this country and how free you are to ever survive in a real Arab street. You make idiotic statements because you think you are important. Go live in Gaza, there you will be nothing! No one will pay attention to you and your life will be worth nothing! Do you think Zouabi that just because you speak out against "zionism" that they won't put a muzzle on you for being a woman in Gaza? Wake up and shut up!
20. Yuval Diskin is almost right
john   (04.08.11)
Zoabi not only flirting with the enemy.SHE IS THE ENEMY.She is no different to the traitor Bishara.She should be expelled from the Knesset and shipped out of the country as a traitor a.s.a.p
21. Diskin definition
Arie ,   BaGolan   (04.08.11)
The truth hurts. If they claim Israeli citizenship, then they should have no issue to take an oath of loyalty to the State
22. Being an Arab in Israel, sadly, Diskin is right. Some of
Fawaz al-Qudsi ,   Israel   (04.08.11)
our leaders, instead of realizing that they are leaders of a minority group in a legitimate Jewish state, do all that they can to undermine Israel's legitimacy and in the process collaborate with Israel's enemies. Some of us, those Arabs who choose to do military service in Israel, are then placed against the enemies of the state who collaborate with our political leaders inside Israel. This must stop by these Arab leaders who must accept that they represent us, the Arabs of Israel, inside the state of Israel and not the Arabs outside of Israel to the world.
23. Arab Israelis
Daniel Shir ,   Fort lLauderdale US   (04.08.11)
No offense to the Arabs in israel BUT you are Israeli citizens only on paper. I agree with the Mossad. You are enemies of the state who need to be assumed are such until proven otherwise. yes there are good and bad people everywhere, but this is not speaking about someone's goodness, this is centering around a person's desires. And I can honestly say that there are few Arabs in Israel (no such thing as Israeli Arabs) that would not work to bring the nation in favor of a future Palestinian state. So, El Sana and Zoabi... please just say it like it is and stop pretending to be shocked.
24. Israeli citizens(including arabs) furious at Arab MKs
(04.08.11)
here's a headline for you .
25. bull shit. words, she crossed the line. leave now join your
ralph   (04.08.11)
failed supposed nation.
26. citizens loyal to Israel?
ploome ,   usa   (04.08.11)
How do these 'palestans' describe their Israeli citizenship? What are their responsibilities as Israeli citizens to the state?
27. REMEMBER KAHANE
Israeli 2   (04.08.11)
He was banned and jailed. These Hamas representng scums walk free A great justice system in Israel? NOT.
28. Zoabi and her friends
Texan   (04.08.11)
Zoabi ,you do not care Sami put at very eloquently You are a embarrassment to the palestinian people , Libya ready for you big mouth ...Honor killing and murdering innocent families like a Fogels and they three children slaughtered down you palestinian terrorist , I know you evil heart , was very happy ... Get out from our Government , from our country ...
29. Just kick them out - send them to live in Gaza - simple !!
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (04.08.11)
30. she doesn't speak for arabs who reject the pal identity
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (04.08.11)
and rather to embrace being israeli. she even has relatives who want nothing to do with her and what she preaches.
Next talkbacks
Back to article