Opinion
Our Saudi Arabian allies
Shoula Romano Horing
Published: 15.04.11, 00:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
1. dude, it's the saudis
johannes   (04.15.11)
bunch of fanatics, dangerous situation there, u don't want 2 mess with that, after messing it up in libya?
2. Israel & Saudi Arabia are already de-facto allies
Jake ,   USA   (04.15.11)
Obviously, the Saudis can't admit it, as it would enrage their brainwashed anti-Zionist population. Those who have been following Mid-East politics should know by now, that Israel secretly cooperates with most Arab countries.
3. I guess the guys in YNET have nothing better to publish
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (04.15.11)
Here we go again with the usual nonsense of bombing irans nuclear sites. Haven't we heard all of this for around 12 years now??!!!!
4. The saudies don't like you any more than the Irian do...
Ziki ,   AZ   (04.15.11)
Stop drinking tohe coolaid shula and get with the program.
5. to nr. 2.
realist ,   world/planet earth   (04.15.11)
perhaps that "israel" secretly cooperates with most old, dictatorial arab regimes. their peoples still may not/cannot express their opinions.
6. #3 Peter
solomon ,   bklyn   (04.15.11)
Are you getting impatient waiting for Israel to do the work that the rest of the world should do on their own?
7. What is wrong with this guy. Saudi Arabia is the
Harry Wright ,   UK   (04.15.11)
Vatican of Islamic extremism. The incubator for all this primitive and violent nonsense that now has the world in turmoil, so what's with these endearments? What was sown is now being reaped in the Arab world. What nuclear weapon? Israel is just waiting for the right moment to cause a nuclear meltdown in Iran and that moment will come when Israel needs to respond to Hamas and Hizbullah or when Iran gets too close to the bomb - whichever comes first.
8. It's a long time clear conclusion
Yossef   (04.15.11)
9. regional NATO would be good for peace
zionist forever   (04.15.11)
If we were looking for the best solution for regional peace making it would not be based on politics it would be creating a NATO of the Middle East. Israel has the best hardware and know how of fighting wars. The arabs have money to fund it and certainly Egypt and Saudi Arabia would be capable of being major players which I am sure they would find very prestigious. An organization like this is what the region needs and I imagine that the west would probably welcome it. A military organization that binds the region together for mutual benefit would be much more effective solution for creating regional peace. Unfortunately the arabs would not go along with it because they prefer to take, take, take to take from others and give nothing in return. As for Saudi Arabia helping Israel attack Iran, now more than ever they wont get involved. The Saudi royals are terrified they are going to be the next victims of a revolution and they cannot be seen as helping Israel attack Iran.
10. The Saudis are not Israel's allies.
Zvi   (04.15.11)
Don't mistake being stuck in a bad situation vis a vis Iran with being willing to set aside decades/centuries of bone-deep anti-Semitism and behave responsibly. Very few Arab regimes have ever dealt civilly with Israel, much less behaved responsibly.
11. Saudi Israeli alliance
Romano ,   Mission viejo, USA   (04.15.11)
I absolutely agree with Jake. This is why the Arab governments are so unpopular. Iran's foreign policy is focused on arab masses as opposed to their govts . with the exception of Syria. Israel waited so long to come to a genuine peace with the palistinians that I am afraid time is running out for israel and fast. Mark these word, if the situation in Egypt does not resolve into a democratic political system without western intervention and Syria's uprising does not quell or Iran is attacked for any reason or even an uprising resurfaces in there; unfortunately war against Israel becomes very possible and inevitable. I hope I am wrong.
12. Pragmatic saudis could live with Jews easier than death by
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (04.15.11)
persians.
13. Arab hatred of Israel
roberta ,   Binghamton NY USA   (04.15.11)
Great article they clearly are natural allies. Unfortunately, Arabs hate Jews so much that they constantly act against their self interest. Imagine how Arab countries and their people could benefit economically by cooperating with prosperous Israel Instead they vilify Jews and their religion through ceaseless and vicious propaganda.
14. A trial balloon by Israeli government?
Zipi ,   Bat Yam. Israel   (04.15.11)
Debka reported that there were secret meeting between Israelis and Saudis in Moscow recently. Israel can be the only one to save the Saudis, Jordanians from evil Iran.
15. NO to Palestinian state !
Avi ,   Miami, US   (04.15.11)
Great idea! THe US, Europe, and UN should stop forcing A Palestinian state on the world. They will promote terrorism, hatred, MARTYRS, and caused troubles to Jordan and Israel. It will be an Iranian base!!!
16. King Abdullah 's Position is Already Precarious
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (04.15.11)
with the Arab democracy tsunami sweeping through the region. Forming an aliance with an Apartheid regime that imprisons 1.5M Pals in Gaza and illegally occupies, colonizes and forces 2M Pals to live as serfs would do nothing more than assure his demise. I am sure that Iran would love the King to do something so foolish.
17. Saudis for friends? Be careful, you can get up with fleas.
leo ,   usa   (04.15.11)
18. OMG!!!
Michael Steiner ,   Bahrain   (04.15.11)
Ynet has really plumbed new depths by publishing this tripe. The Saudi regime is one of the most odious on this planet. Israel's reputation got besmirched enough through its unsalutary flirtation with the apartheid South Africa. Do you have NO principles at ALL, Shoula Romano Horing?!? Then this: "First, Israel’s leadership is more loyal to its Arab allies than President Obama. While Israel stood by Mubarak, it took Obama three days to call for Egypt’s president[.]" Friendship with and loyalty to a vicious despot is something to be PROUD of!!? The rest of this dross is a bunch of thinly-veiled attacks on President Obama; not worth the effort of commenting on. It is stupefying how even people in developed, knowledge-based societies and professions can so firmly be stuck in alternate realities. No morals, no principles, no values, no decency. Sad.
19. Only if Saudis smoke weed like you...
Gedinsky ,   Saudi republic   (04.15.11)
20. Saudi King is a Jew just like you
palidov ,   kiev   (04.15.11)
21. No threat whatever
Jerrold Cohen ,   Seal Beach, USA   (04.15.11)
The only "threat" a nuclear Iran is, is that Israel doesn't dare bomb it, thus ending that possibility to start WWIII.
22. Bombing unnecessary now. Stuxnet 11 will do the job.
Harry Wright ,   UK   (04.15.11)
That will keep the Mahdi man and mullahs so busy mopping up.
23. #16 "Arab democracy tsunami" Where?
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.15.11)
So far we've seen much head bashing but no democracy has emerged. The Palestinians have their own leadership to repress them. They just fired over 100 missiles at Israel so funds for priority items are readily available. And if anyone wants to use the Palestinians as serfs or shahids, it's Iran. I'm thinking an alliance between Saudi Arabia and Israel would be viewed as extremely threatening to Iran.
24. Don't make yourselves illusions about Saudi Arabia
Thomas ,   Germany   (04.15.11)
KSA is a totally back warded deeply religious country, only stabilized with oil billions. They don't undesratnd such rational considerations. Well, except some high level advicers, but the society got a 100 year long anti Israel brain wash and has idea about reality
25. A cross between misunderstanding and wishful thinking
Kazim Ali ,   Kut, Iraq   (04.15.11)
Strategically speaking Iran , turkey, Israel are contenders for regional dominance in the region, the question could Egypt and Saudi Arabia forms a new stronger alliance as a new contender . To # 11, Syria is not immune in spite of their artificial enmity to Israel ( notice if you are a Syrian officer who joined in 1973 you have retired w/ o firing a shot to Israel) , the Syrian people are keenly aware. To # 24 you are wrong the Saudi society is more complex and more aware than. What you have been led to believe, it is probably the most educated society in the world that does not have an election , which by the way does not. Mean much in terms of sound governance relative to the region . If the west and Israel continue to pressure Iran , it will fracture internally , it is weaker than what many led to believe.The average Frazad in Iran does not like not only the deplorable perforce of his government but also does not like wasting Iranian money on foreign adventures. The Iranian regional ambition has nothing to do with Iranian abilities or the desire of it's people. So, the only thing needed is more US pressure and maybe some selective assisnations like intelligence and scientists, and support of oppositions like the spertatists .
26. Israel friend with Saudi Arabia ??? madness
Pascal ,   Bordeaux, France   (04.15.11)
I totally disagree with the subject here!! Israel making friend with saudi arabia ?? that's complete madness!! The saudis donate over millions of hate books all over the world depicting jews as apes that must be burn and you call them friends ?? the wahhabi ideology is against all the values that israel stands for. We have problems with the iran government but ahmadinejad will go and the iranian people are very similar to the israelis and they are smart and intelligent like many israelis ! israel must never never ally itself with saudi arabia or else it will be the end of our democratic state too
27. Don't hold your breath israel
Abdalla   (04.15.11)
28. #16 Doug
solomon ,   bklyn   (04.15.11)
Israel WITHDREW from Gaza, remember? The arabs were left with a hothouse complex they touted as a new beginning of commerce. They then destroyed this new beginning and are now shooting rockets and sending terrorists into Israel. And where is this illegal occupation with serfs? Is it in the WB mostly populated by arabs who came in 1948 after Jordan made the area judenrein? In Gaza where Hamas steals most of the supplies Israel sends in, even during Cast Lead? Repeating stupidities ad infinitum do not make them true, no matter how much you wish it.
29. No. 27, Jews are not suicidal, only Arabs hold their breath
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (04.15.11)
Performing fake martyrdom is an Arab specialty and you do die for nothing. You would be rather exterminated by Iran and have Mecca/Medina wiped off of the face of the map in a Mushroom cloud than allow infidel Jews save you. Dr. Alofs Patient in Psychiatric Ward Ysbyty Gwynedd Hospital
30. #18;Naive!! US was with the Murderous Stalin!!
Adi ,   San Diego, CA   (04.15.11)
YOu make peace with your enemies!!You are so liberal and naive! You do not need your enemies to be pure and innocent. You need to protect your interests. We are talking about the survival!!!; The Soviet Stalin murdered millions of Russians and still US was their ally in World Wat II to defeat a bigger evil
Next talkbacks
Back to article