News
Itamar massacre solved; 2 arrested
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 17.04.11, 12:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
31. to #22 they murdered 2 years old baby
ghostq   (04.17.11)
I don't think that behavior should get reward, no excuss is for murder entire family, and the walls r there to secure Israelis, ever since than the sucide bombs reduced in 85% meaning the walls r good security mesure.
32. Does it matter????
Atalya ,   Israel   (04.17.11)
if someone murdered your loved one, would fo off and cut the throat of an infant??? I wouldn't! and if you would - you're just as much a phsycopath as they are...
33. it's not about the numbers!!!!!!!
israel   (04.17.11)
and how many people are killed in car acceidents?? it's not about the numbers, it's about the basic human nature and the cultural differece. an IDF soldier would NEVER EVER EVER slash a baby's throat. EVER!!!!
34. Two more names...
Marco ,   Spain   (04.17.11)
Will be added to the list of those to be exchanged for Shalit...
35. #23
Marco ,   Spain   (04.17.11)
Did the Israelis not hide those criminals of your I.D.F that massacred the children of Kana while they were sleeping?
36. #20 ... A cousin of one of the involved
She ,   Sderot, occupied IL   (04.17.11)
was murdered ... and burnt ... by him. Another was involed in another murder of settlers and so on... What was your point remind me? Your romantic aspect of the Palestinian "freedom fighter" is childish and pathetic.
37. Inhumane
Jose Esposito ,   Valencia, Spain   (04.17.11)
Hard to understand. The press in Spain keeps on saying that Israel is the bad part of the story. But now I understand why Israel has no choice but to defend its citizens from this barbarity conducted by Palestinian Islamist terrorist, that slaughter babies in their sleep and feel no regret. I hope my government will wake up and listen to our former prime minister José María Aznar who said that "The real threats to regional stability are to be found in the rise of a radical Islamism which sees Israel’s destruction as the fulfilment of its religious destiny"
38. Salma #15
donna ,   Manchester England   (04.17.11)
Salma, it is no IDF fantasy.....
39. #25 to #27
Salma ,   Palestine   (04.17.11)
babies have no fault in who their parents are . anyone is thinking just thinking of stabbing babies to death in their sleep, simply he is not a human being.
40. peace peace peace this what both sides need
lina ,   usa   (04.17.11)
41. peter #20
Danny Fella ,   Paris France   (04.17.11)
Hello man, you are sick...
42. Wish
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (04.17.11)
...say they wanted to 'die martyrs' death'... So, make their wish come true!
43. Itamar murderers
E. Ness BErgstein ,   Jerusalem Israel   (04.17.11)
To #26 in particular: We shall have to repent in this generation , not so much for the evil deeds of the wicked people, but for the appalling silence of the good people Martin Luther King, Jr. Speak out against this heinous murder of an innocent family instead of trying to explain it away by talking about war casualties.
44. Are Jews ready for an Arab terror State?
Zeroing ,   Germany   (04.17.11)
Netanyahu: "A society that permits such wild incitement ends up prompting the murder of children." He was honest, right and absolute realistic. Riyad al-Malik: "No Palestinian in the past killed an infant and butchered people in such way based on a nationalistic or vengeful motive." He was in hallucination- mode. Like always, denying the reality and fostering incitement to murder Jews. Hamas and Haniyeh: "The report of five murdered Israelis is not enough to punish someone.” This is the expected reaction from the Emirate of darkness and death. Are Jews ready for another Arab terror state over the other half of Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria? Conclusion: No Palestinian State even within the coming two generations. May be in the third or forth generation. With this type of mind-set, it is better to stop them now, then to wait till they have their own State. Only a peacefully neighbour is sustainable for the tiny Israel.
45. Salma # 15
Isragirl ,   Here and there   (04.17.11)
Really? I have 2 names for you - Juliano Merr and Vittorio Arrigoni. Please, explain that to us...
46. Well said no. 13
JEW1 ,   ASHDOD   (04.17.11)
Anyone having any questions or arguments about this article, please read no. 13 comments. All your queries will be answered.
47. What anbout the family?
Peter   (04.17.11)
It's not only the murder of the Family Fogel which is so despicable.The aftermath of the murder it's pretty much the same.Not even one family member said to them;what you did was wrong,killing kids while sleep isn't fighting it's murder.Instead they were probably proud of their offspring and did everything to make sure they would get away.Now their names are known to everybody so let's see how long it takes till the first park,street or sports field will be named after them, the "great brave freedom fighters" in order to get another kids to follow their "outstanding example of bravery and willingness to make sacrifices"
48. Islam: Religion of Peace
Julian ,   Warsaw, Poland   (04.17.11)
49. Ao... Shinbet, IDF and police.
(04.17.11)
where's the PA's involvement? haven't they also talked about investigating this thing?
50. What are Israels critical security needs ? (Video) !!
(04.17.11)
http://emunadate.blogspot.com/2011/01/israels-critical-security-needs-for.html
51. captured terrorists
Yosef Aminoff ,   Elazar Israel   (04.17.11)
If tomorrow their release is requested in exchange for Gilad Shalit, should Israel agree?
52. @peter graafland No 20
Peter   (04.17.11)
"i wonder how many beloved ones of hakim and amjad have been murdered before." None in this coldblooded way! And if you don't see the difference between unwittingly colateral damage and a willful murder then you are beyond help.Why didn't they leave after they have killed the parents?To drive a knife into a body of a sleeping kid is beyond good and evil and it's just inexcusable
53. William Tel Aviv # 24
Moragh   (04.17.11)
So what you are saying idiot is to give them a smack on the bottom, a clean cell, educate them, good food, visitors etc. etc. etc. and all is well and good. Lol... you william are definitely a born comedian!
54. #25; seadog, WRONG POINT
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (04.17.11)
While it is true people can be a product of their environment, and certainly poverty breeds crime. That has nothing to do with this terrorist act. First, you see during the interrogation they admitted to wanting "die a martyr's death". In fact the full quote was: "Amjad noted that he went to Itamar to "die a martyr's death", which strengthened his willingness to carry out an act of terrorism." So we see the motivation for admitted murders, was to carry out "acts of terrorism". Second, the crimes you compare them to, have no goal attached to them. But are simply murder for money, maybe to buy drugs or whatever. So your excuses, as usual, are senseless. Comparing the Friday night drunken brawl to premeditated acts of terrorism is the epitome of silliness, but that's what expect from you. Comparing apples to oranges.
55. the bottom line
observer ,   Egypt   (04.17.11)
arming the sellers doesn't make them secure. A fence doesn't make settlement secure. neither do surveillance cameras. nor killing will deter.
56. #35 Gallego Marco
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (04.17.11)
Spain has all kind of blood in hands. Previous 1492, 1492 and during 1936-39 Franco kill inocents too and the repuplicants too. So please do not lecture us
57. why didn't Itamar people allow post mortum exam?
observer ,   Egypt   (04.17.11)
or the shin bet had been fooling people when it said all were stabbed and fooled them again by saying some gunshots were involved.
58. #54 - your "outrage" is misplaced...
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NY   (04.17.11)
as an Amurkin citizen you should calm down with the Israeli zionist "terrorist" hasbara and perhaps be more outraged at the recent acts of the Afghanistan "kill team". These Itamar muderers are in the same category as the rogue US troops involved in the My Lai, RVN incident... they too had "reasons" and it's not "terror". So what now... will the Israelis bulldoze Awarta? Is that your wet dream?
59. Ynet why you dont publish my comment
hadad ,   london u.k   (04.17.11)
all I said is that only death penalty would be fair for these wild beasts. whats wrong with that? this is what would happen in a free and democratic state like the U.S.A
60. You can always count on palestinians...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.17.11)
... to tell on each other. Thank goodness for that.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article