News
Rabbi Lior: Encourage Bedouins to leave Israel
Ynet
Published: 26.04.11, 23:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
31. Agreed! Send the aliens back to Poland, Belarus, Queens, etc
Wissam ,   Palestine   (04.27.11)
32. Rabbi Dov Lior & racism
Rabbi L. Finkelstein ,   Oakland, CA   (04.27.11)
The biggest difference between Helen Thomas & Rabbi Dov Lior is that she was fired for her racist remarks. Equaklity under the law was a founding principle of Israel. Dov Lior obviously doesn't accept that principle. The majority of Israel's citizens do - and so do the overwhelming majority of Jews in the diaspora who support Israel.
33. Rabbi Liar believes his
observer ,   Egypt   (04.27.11)
34. #32 Well said Rabbi!!!
Talula ,   Israel   (04.27.11)
35. We won't ask Rabbi Lior to go back to his country
Jeff ,   Maccabim, Israel   (04.27.11)
of origin, and request that he not ask the Bedouins to go back to their country of origin (which by the way, may be Israel)
36. "Bedouins should leave"
Ruth ,   Israel   (04.27.11)
Rabbi Lior has probably not gone to school.Otherwise he would now that Bedouins were always here
37. Time to return to Poland?
Luke ,   Oslo, Norway   (04.27.11)
Rabbi Lior was born to a Belz hasidic family, son to Moshe Leibland in Breslau, Galicia.
38. The worst clown between rabbies.
John ,   Europe   (04.27.11)
With Dov Liar as a friend, who needs enemies.
39. to # 32 Rabbi Finkelstein,
David ,   Herzlia,Israel   (04.27.11)
Well said !!,Agree with you completely, Haredim only want to suck dry the state and donors, SHNORERIM !!!, do not contribute anything to Israel, do not serve in the army,( beduin do !!!) do nto pay taxces, in other words LIVE OF OTHERS !!!!!
40. encourage the return to their countries of origin
Moshe ,   Netanya   (04.27.11)
Beduins came from Arabia. Some served in IDF for which they were given water, electricity, etc. which they never saw before. Many came to Israel via Sudan. They do want to go back to Arabia but Saudi family want them here. They are guests in our land, and we decide what to do with guests not Saudi family, not Sudan, not Jordan king. If you know it is not your land than leave. Simple and clear.
41. to # 3, 4, 36 beduins are not natives of the land
Laurence ,   Israel   (04.27.11)
Bedouins are either descendants of ancient Arabian nomads or descendants of those brought from Africa as slaves. They don't have any rights on our jewish land. Of course they are entitled to purchase land but most of the time they just grab land without any rights. Rabbi Lior is absolutly right, they should go back to where they come from. I don't see the problem. For those who spit their venon on the rabbi should explain why it is ok to deport jews and why it is not ok to deport bedouins. For your infos 40% of army officers are religious people . To ruth Rabbi Lior belongs to the land of Israel you should go back to school you would learn that jews were here since 4000 years.
42. Does that include those who serve in the IDF
Haim ,   Tel aviv   (04.27.11)
Does that include those who serve in the IDF, who give their lives to the country? At least they serve this country unlike Rabi Liors bunch of parasites.
43. Bedouins
Reid Elattrache ,   Washington,USA   (04.27.11)
The rabbi sounds like Helen Thomas.
44. I served with Beduin, Druze, Christians
jason white ,   afula, israel   (04.27.11)
and other moslims in a combat unit. In over 22 years of service in the I.D.F., I came across 2 hara-dim.One was a asst to the Battalion Rabbi. And the other had the same excuse to get out of going with our gun crew. Three times his grandmother died!He got away with that excuse only twice. Better yet jail all those that are draft dodgers or send them back to where they came from,if they are immigrants. Even those females that get pregnant to avoid army service. Put them in jail. National service for the religious and conscientious objectors should not count as military service.Warming a seat in a yeshiva should not be allowed,instead of national service in the I.D.F.. When these draft dodger defend Israel like the Beduin in the I.D.F., then they should be allowed to stay.One Beduin clan from Zah Zir lost 54 members in the service.This "rabbi" should be ashamed of himself along with others at that conference. As for inviting arab politicians, no one who did not serve in the I.D.F. should be allowed to vote, enter politics or work in the government.They do not deserve full citizenship.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article