News
Paris trial: Al-Durrah beats Israeli doctor
Aviel Magnezi
Published: 29.04.11, 22:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. "subsequent investigative reports" by who?
(04.29.11)
By a Zionist Jew?
2. Jewish arrogance has no bounds....
(04.29.11)
No wonder the whole world is becoming anti Semitic.
3. Curiouser and curiouser ....
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.29.11)
"The Palestinians accused the IDF of killing Muhammad al-Durrah, but subsequent investigative reports reached the conclusion that the child was shot by the Palestinians." Is that why he became the "poster child" for the intifada? I guess the slogan is "We kill our own!" Bet they're even selling tee-shirts. I think that Dr. Yehuda has been slandered and libeled. I think the al-Durrah family are a bunch of money-grubbing thieves, trying to capitalize on the death of a son who was murdered by ersatz "Palestinians." Does it get any more despicable than that?
4. the continuing saga of palliwood tales
Ovadyah ,   hales   (04.29.11)
truth continues to be twisted and weaved
5. Excuse me?
Carsten Schmidt ,   Old Europe   (04.29.11)
"I expected integrity from France and from the judges"... What?!
6. One more reason I've got to leave this miserable country
Charles ,   Paris, FRANCE   (04.29.11)
With so many Islamists here in France, the ruling is no surprise.
7. France has never heardd of QB VII or Leon Uris
meir elazar   (04.29.11)
France showed its anti-Semitism in the Dreyfus Affair and things have not changed. France cannot be trusted. With France for a friend, one does not need enemies. At least HAMAS does not try to deceive the world. Haniyeh is very clear about the HAMAS position and echoes the HAMAS Charter constantly. France pretends to be honest and part of the western civilized world which is far worse.
8. #2 did you really waited that to become anti-Semite ?
Yossef   (04.29.11)
I doubt...
9. Video show boy unharmed and Alive!
EZ ,   US   (04.29.11)
I don't understand this whole thing! There are clear videos showing the father and son during this incident as part of a "movie set" with the boy alive and well, raising his head and blocking the sun out of his eyes BETWEEN TAKES as the French & Palestinian film crews filmed the "incident" directly next to an Israeli guard tower that was peaceful and silent. This is TOTAL WAG THE DOG BS!!! Screw the FRENCH BASTARDS!!! Shame on ALL OF FRANCE for their bigotry, stupidity and LACK OF HONOR AND SHAME!!! BOYCOTT FRANCE!!! THEY SUKK!!!!
10. Fear of Moslems is making Europeans lie against Israel
(04.29.11)
11. who killed el dura?
fad egypt   (04.30.11)
i remember that day , it was published in the newspaper that the IDF killed el dura during exchange of fire between the IDF and the palestiians gunmen i said at that time that there is no proof that the IDF did it he may ve been caught in the exchange of fire but the IDF didnt intend to do it and it is the responsibility of the palestinians to turn a civil streets to a battle field three years i read the final investigations which proved that the IDF have not done it shame on the false propaganda shalom
12. Our Hero
Levi ,   Brooklyn   (04.29.11)
Dr. Yehuda, you are a hero to expose the lies at the cost of some money. If only more Israelis were like him!
13. but #2 is not anti-semitic
Golan ,   Modiin   (04.29.11)
he just "anti-Zionist"
14. # 3
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.29.11)
Oh yes, I love it Sarah B. "We kill our own" Tshirts, coffee mugs, key rings, etc, etc. I'll go one further; the majority of Arabs are money grabbing thieves & liars. Shabbat Shalom to you.
15. ***Sarah***at 3, You hit the nail on the
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.29.11)
head...they seem to celebrate that picture for what it is NOT...but can this really be a surprise...?? These people are SO wicked...
16. #5
Spencer ,   Israel   (04.29.11)
You're dreaming Mr, Schmidt. I expected nothing less from the French who are vehemently anti Israel.
17. Justices for Jews…
B.A. ,   Sweden   (04.30.11)
… in Eurabia??!
18. #1 & #2: Frightened by the Jews?
shrinkDave ,   Miami   (04.30.11)
I think so.
19. Here is a simple solution
Batman ,   USA   (04.30.11)
stop treating Palestinians in Israeli hospitals. Let them fix themselves. Why should the Israeli taxpayer fund the surgeries of Jew haters?
20. if I were him
observer ,   Egypt   (04.30.11)
I wouldn't have endured the terrible scam and the personal sense of insult to pay 13,000 Euros unless someone else had to pay that sum of money for me.
21. libel?
steve ,   usa   (04.30.11)
So in France, truth is not a defense for libel? Correct when the defendant is a Jew. From Dreyfus to Yehuda. And #3, you are so right on that point.
22. Talkbacks
Gavreil ,   Arizona USA   (04.30.11)
Liberal France became the dinosaur of Europe three plus decades ago. It simply needs being buried and forgotten.
23. Scam
Zyx ,   Paris   (04.30.11)
The whole thing is a scam masterminded by Charles Enderlin a French Israeli TV "journalist" who makes his living from Anti Israel propaganda. The official version is that the report was put together by his palestinian cameraman. Enderlin added comments to the images but he never attended the event. He was supposedl manipulated. In reality Enderlin masterminded the whole thing. He put together a fake story in order to harm Israel.
24. Suing the doctor that saved your life?
Tahl   (04.30.11)
This pretty much sums up the Palestinian conduct vis a vis Israel... Dr. Yehuda should've left this ungrateful liar to die.
25. This is one future Israeli doctor...
Sarai   (04.30.11)
That won't be working with Palestinians from Gaza, to avoid situations just like this one. Let them seek treatment with their own awful doctors, or in Egypt.
26. #=14
bob ,   canada   (04.30.11)
Please, have a bloody courage, even once to admit unjustice and manipulation on arab's side. Not a man, ha? Becides, pal, we don't bring our kids to fight and get killed.We love them.
27. #18 shrinkDave,,,
(04.30.11)
The answer to your question is NO. With Hezbollah around, we have no reason to be frightened from anyone.
28. arrogance vs. humility?
miri sofer ,   miami, fl. usa   (04.30.11)
no 2 you dont hate us because were arrogant, you hate us because were Jews. cold day in h--- when we change and stop being proud.
29. Puppet judges
Raphael ,   Netanya   (04.30.11)
How can a court decide that medical documents are fake? And that an arab crook's word is more worth? My father, who was a lawyer, told me "If you are indicted by french justice for stealing the Eiffel tower, first cross the border, then talk". Dreyfus is still considered guilty by many of them.
30. I've been fighting the State of Israel's just war
Max Maier ,   Germany   (04.30.11)
What about medical confidentiality? To release medical files without the patient's consent and to abuse them for political purposes is a most flagrant breach of medical ethics. For this alone the judgment is justified.
Next talkbacks
Back to article