News
Israel braces for 'Nakba Day'
Ynet reports
Published: 11.05.11, 01:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
31. Don't see anyone leaving
Harvey ,   London   (05.11.11)
32. OMG
Eliza ,   UK   (05.11.11)
I am trying to understand how stating all Arabs are terrorists and all Palestinians are bad is not racist. Usually, I expect to see at least a reasoned debate, but all I see here is biassed, bigoted slander. Removing Arabs from Israel is ethnic cleansing -you'll be calling them rats or insects and we should all remember what comes after that.
33. Israeli-Arabs should not restore to violence
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (05.11.11)
If police suspects there would be violence in the planned israeli-arab rallies, then they should coordinate with organizers to prevent such incidents. No one wants violence and i do not believe there will be any from the israeli-arab side. unet should not be inciting...
34. #1: from you comment, I doubt you actually live here..
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (05.11.11)
35. nakba???
oded   (05.11.11)
the disater as they call it, is ours and ours only. we were left with a 5th colum,contingency in our midst, bent on the distruction of the only jeiwsh homleand. you can't form "peace' with the arabs when the celbrate martydom, andand morn the establishment of our nation. have a lousy nakba day!!!
36. #27 sammy
oded   (05.11.11)
you sound like a reasonable man who thinks straight. the only thing, imho, that palsteinan arabs deserve is already availbe for them- jordan. with the right economical andlogistical avenue , this could solve the me conflict- a resettlemnt of palstinan arabs in jordan ,w/ fully compensated paackge.
37. #32. Eliza
Tim ,   Brighton   (05.11.11)
Without using any immotive language - 1. The Nakba is simply the perpetuation of the dream of the destruction of Israel and the birth of a Palestine from its ashes 2. MOST Israelis want to see a Palestinian State at peace with Israel but not from the ashes of Israel 3. The idea of a Nakba is simply a means to perpetuate the notion that the birth of Israel was a disaster for Palestinians. It follows therefore than only the death of Israel can mean progress for Palestinians 4. Yes we have to remember our past but not be straightjacketed by it. Nakba locks Palestinians into the notion that there is no middle way 5. And heres the rub the nuts and bolts Eliza. A Peace formula between Israelis and Palestinians is not nuclear science. It just needs trust and goodwill and its there for the taking
38. #36. Thanks - but no thanks
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (05.11.11)
Our homeland is an independent Palestine just as yours is Israel
39. HAPPY NAKBA DAY !!!
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.11.11)
May you enjoy many more of them Have a Nakba cake, light a candle for each year, I want it to look like a forest is on fire
40. right of return
Noachide   (05.11.11)
all arabs may return and the jews to judaea and samaria but the jews will have to control security and martyrdom votes allocated to the jews who died in the shoah and their potential descendants .
41. war
nichole ,   tennessee   (05.12.11)
Wars and rumours of wars before the glorious coming of The Lord Jesus Christ.
42. 38
birdi ,   israel   (05.12.11)
sammy why are'nt yo uhere with your brothers building your future land?
43. #41 nichole
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.12.11)
Beleive as you wish, however there were wars while he was here the first time
44. #40 Noachide
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.12.11)
Don't be so generous, the dead can't vote, if they did, their ballots would be questioned The Arabs having had nothing to do all these years, have propagated like rabbits Unless you to put some up in your house, don't make such all encompassing offers Let's deal with facts, not intangibles Besides, Arabs have no legitimate claims, though I've asked a rather simple set of questions, I have yet to find any that have the answers, proving that they're merely invaders, not legitimate occupants, their claims have no value
45. ref Give me a Break
Leah Lax ,   USA   (06.04.11)
I see you think Muslims are so sweet and kind. Their Koran is full of Kill the Jew and the Christian. I suggest you go and live nin Iran since you love them so much and so Liberal of you to want to help them.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article