News
IDF chief warns of violence on 'Nakba Day'
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 11.05.11, 13:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
1. Possible solution.
Jules   (05.11.11)
All potential participants (who hold Israeli citizenship) of "Nakba" events have to be officially informed that court proceedings aimed at stripping their citizenship, with consequent deportation from Israel, will be immediately initiated against them. That may reduce the amount of intended trouble.
2. The solution is to get rid of all those
Vardina   (05.11.11)
or Fatrouble makers and their families for good, namely to drive them out of Israel either to Hamas land or Fatah land. Let them enjoy the enthusiastic welcome of their brethren. They will soon learn how much "lkoved" they will be there... We have to get rid of them. The sooner the better.
3. Pity we cant copy the Syrians
Rebecca ,   Modi'in   (05.11.11)
4. You should have listened
Marcel ,   Florida   (05.11.11)
For I will deliver the inhabitants of the land into your hand, and you shall drive them out before you. 32 You shall make no covenant with them, nor with their gods. 33 They shall not dwell in your land, lest they make you sin against Me. Exodus 23
5. Is PeaceNow General Director Yariv Oppenheimer the leader
(05.11.11)
of these Naqba rioters?
6. AMEN Marcel Florida Exodus 23.
musher   (05.11.11)
7. call in the syrian army
shuli ,   londonstan, england   (05.11.11)
they will know how to deal effectively with this problem...plus the world won't say a word
8. everyone get ready to witness a whole lotta stupid
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (05.11.11)
nothing special, just the usual nonsense.
9. To Rebecca #3
Gregg ,   Haifa, IL   (05.11.11)
Are you telling us you'd use weapons against protestors? I ll be among them, supporting their cause, as I was celebrating in Yom Hatzmaut as well. If you are preaching for violence like in Syria, you are not better than the syrians rats politicians Rebecca... You're such a disgrace
10. Go to Jordan to celebrate your nakba.
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (05.11.11)
You are either a citizen of Israel or a foreign agent provocator. Patience has limits. Jewish spring is next !
11. To No.4, Marcel
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (05.11.11)
I wish the Government would abide by those words.
12. you mean another violance, maybe this
ghostq   (05.11.11)
is the only thing palis know, the date is imaginary, around the Month of May the only bloody riots were during the communism creation aka 1 of May, baaaaa talking about extreem stupidity.
13. To Gabe, #10
Gregg ,   Haifa, IL   (05.11.11)
And an Israeli citizen is not allowed to be different and think different than the mass?
14. To: No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.11.11)
You are the disgrace. The Syrian protesters have been demonstrating against an oppressive regime. Arabs who would demonstrate -- violently -- against the State of Israel on so-called "Naqba Day" (which is really nothing more than a commemmoration of their forebears having VOLUNTARILY LEFT their homes) are guilty of treason. The true disgrace is that you appear to be incapable of appreciating the difference. I think you should practice what you preach -- pack up and move to Ramallah, why don't you? Israel needs more Jews like Rebecca and fewer scum like you.
15. HAPPY NAKBA DAY
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.11.11)
I wish you many more, lbuy a cake, ight a candle for each year that passes, I want to see a blaze of light
16. #4, what's good for the goose ...
Ben ,   USA   (05.11.11)
If we're going to quote random feel-good scriptures, how about the following one? Ezekiel 47: 21-23: "This land you shall divide for yourselves among the tribes of Israel. You shall allot it as a heritage for yourselves and for the strangers who reside among you, who have begotten children among you. You shall treat them as Israelite citizens; they shall receive allotments along with you among the tribes of Israel. You shall give the stranger an allotment within the tribe where he resides - declares the Lord God." Wha-wha-what??? An Israel that isn't goy-rein? Say it isn't so, Ezekiel! Oy vey, Ezekiel must have been an arab sympathizer, what a 5th column tool ... [end sarcasm]
17. Nakba - feeling only pity for themselves
Ralph Haglund ,   Lund, Sweden   (05.11.11)
for not succeeding in murdering all Jews, as the plan was. Gosh what a chock to all the arabs! They still seem to be dizzy and confused. I have not counted but - the palis having 150000 employees they must pay? How many actually work? It is just a hidden unemployment trick, called "work" as it is easier to get funds from abroad for that. What about telling Abbas to fix more jobs, not stopping arabs from working in Jewish settlements!
18. #16 Ezekiel wasn't referring to Arabs, but decent Gentiles.
Josh ,   USA   (05.11.11)
19. Message to Pali Arabs / Jews
sk ,   USA   (05.11.11)
Message to Arabs: You will always lose when you tangle with God (protector of Israel). Message to Jews: Quit the secular lifestyle and show your protector God some respect for his laws and principles.
20. to nr. 14.
justice for all ,   world/planet earth   (05.11.11)
it seems that you have never heard of the freedom of speech and expression. you can better go to a dictatorship. you with your "voluntarily left" is a big zionist lie. did gregg insult you why you gave your insulting, hatefull reaction to him? i read nothing about this. in this case keep your insulting, insinuating, hatefull reaction to yourself. if you insult somebody you can expect a reaction back. try before you die! if all the jews were like you and if were a jew i should be ashamed of my own people. you are the eternal, poor "victim" enjoy your victimrole and your selfpity because the others are always bad and wrong. if you always judge other people they are also judging you. other people and me have so often read your well-known, one-sided, partial, selective, biased mantras/zionist propaganda. invent something new. give me a break! and perhaps to other people too.
21. to nr. 9.
justice for all ,   world/planet earth   (05.11.11)
i totally agree with you. i hope that you will be able to live in a truly just country and that your ideals once will become reality!
22. @8 well said Mike. Simple and right on point.
Joe ,   St Louis usa   (05.11.11)
23. To No. 13
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (05.11.11)
An Israeli citizen owes loyalty to the State of Israel. You are free to give up your Israeli citizenship if you feel otherwise. Vote with your feet. Enjoy your nakba.
24. #21 justice, whatever
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.11.11)
They are free to live and go live in one of the Democratic Arab states, providing they can find one Nearest is Syria, they're busy shooting the population, or Egypt where the Muslim Brotherhood seems to be taking over, or Libya where thousands have been killed by their own Government, maybe Yemen, snipers are shooting people in the streets, oops, I almost for Bahrain That's the reality; you're just a pretentious blowhard
25. #1 Hey sport.
Nour ,   One-State   (05.11.11)
You may think you wield the powers of a "STATE", but you will never change the fact that you are a settler-colonist entity implanted by force and a European declaration. Now keep your hollow threats to yourself.
26. Any sovereign country may shoot border tresspassers!
(05.11.11)
We may just shoot a few crazed Muslim Brotherhod thugs if they try to cross the border, just as the Egyptians shot and killed refugees trying to enter Israel. The difference here is that theEgyptians killed refugees who were fleeing genocide in a Muslim country, while we'll be shooting at terrorists who declared that they want Israel destroyed. In this case too, our moral ground is much higher than any Islamo Leftist murderous thug who may preach to us about "freedom" and "human rights", regardless of his race, religion or nationality!
27. 23 & 24
Gregg ,   Haifa,IL   (05.11.11)
It's always the same old propaganda, aka "there is no better state than the "democratic" state of Israel, for Arabs" Change the disc. Nobody believe this bs anymore. Israel is racist and is far from being perfect, and we will fight to make it better, for it not to fall in the hands of extremists like you guys. You all talk like fascists... Jews first, and hell to others ! We live in the 21st century, in case you didn't know
28. Have yourself a merry little Nakba
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (05.11.11)
What is the Nakba really? In 1948, the Arab nations declared war on Israel and vowed to destroy it, slaughter all the Jews and loot their property. In order to accomplish this more efficiently, the Arab legions told their civilian supporters to move out of the way until the job was complete and then they could come back and claim their share of the loot. Well, big surprise, the would-be genociders LOST. War sucks. War sucks more for the LOSERS. Happy Nakba, Losers!
29. #25 Just the way all good countries are built, sweetheart !!
(05.11.11)
30. To No. 20
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (05.11.11)
Take your Prozac and move to Aljazera.
Next talkbacks
Back to article