News
Deadly clashes on Israel's borders with Syria, Lebanon
Hagai Einav
Published: 15.05.11, 18:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
93 Talkbacks for this article
61. what about those who illegally entered Israel?
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
I don't care about the ignorant saps who were shot at the border for trying to illegally enter a country they've been hostile to for 63 years.... I'm interested in the illegals who made it to Israel. Once inside, what did they hope to accomplish? Arrest them, throw them in cells with the "Palestinians" they so much wanted to be with, and throw away the key. At least they'll be treated better than those languishing in Arab jails for years.
62. I'm actually a bit disappointed with the IDF
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
I know this was a mass infiltration of unknown persons all with hostile intent against a nation they sought to destroy for 63 years... but I wonder why better crowd control instruments weren't used? There are ear-splitting directional speakers that cause people to vomit, there are skunk smells and tear gas, and I would have catapulted in pig feces onto the crowd. Amazing how in dealing with this illegal action, the IDF still honored the sovereignty of its neighbors borders, though legally it didn't have to.
63. "We come in peace"
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
Maybe an alien who just arrived here would believe that claim, but we've been hear for decades and have seen the racist ill-intent of Arabs. If you truly came in peace, you would have adhered to the call by the IDF to stop. Once you ignored them and broke through a border fence, your actions became violent.
64. Don't worry # 43
Harvey ,   London   (05.15.11)
Dont be too concerned by assads attempt to deflect Syrian rage on to israel thereby hanging on to power Always remember better the barbarian you know rather then the barbarian you don't know Assad knows only too well what will happen to him if he goes too far with israel whereas the next fanatic might want to chance his arm in order to prove himself to the so called ummah
65. #8 - Many have accepted Israeli citizenship and do serve
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
Apparently, education isn't your strong suit. Go read post#1 for starters. Only some of those Druze in Migdal Shams refuse Israeli citizenship, some admitting they are afraid of what would happen to them if Israel cedes land to Syria. Judging from the past weeks in Syria, they're concerns are justified.
66. #35 - their home is in Syria, Lebanon collectively
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
That's where they were born, that's where they will live. It won't be Israel....it could be West Bank if Abbas grew a backbone. I didn't see one 68 year old (or older) in these protests which means NONE of them came from Israel back in 1948. Case Closed.
67. #38 - what's the message?
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
"Take our citizens because we can't handle them anymore and will kill those citizens who oppose us"? We already knew this.
68. #40 - that's worth noting, isn't it?
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
These same Arabs who claim to hate and despise Israel are rushing into its arms for asylum because they know they will be taken care of....in the face of Arab massacres. How ironic!
69. #44 - it seems no one is surprised by the outcome...
William ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
except these ignorant protesters. Ooops! Somehow, I doubt the instigators of these protests are anywhere close to the border with Israel.
70. I celebrate this day ...
Samuel Prime ,   Canada   (05.15.11)
the birth of the only democracy in the middle east - best thing that happened in the M.E. As long as the Arabs behave like frantic idiots, they will live a 'nakba' life of their own making. They created their own nakbas, namely: their own tyrannical governments that to this day exploit, repress, and kill them. No greater nakba than this.
71. The BBC are of course underplaying arab terrorism ..
Lee ,   Manchester UK   (05.15.11)
just a few kms away over the other side of the Golan, al aSSad commits GENOCIDE against tens of thousands of his own people unhindered with no media presence. As once again they are all in and on Israel, watching her every move as she DEFENDS herself under obligation against enmasse premeditated border assaults in every direction by sociopathic murderers brainwashed in rewritten history and outright lies. This is just how al aSSad had planned it to be he knows the BBC et al are a JOKE like we do. How can the supposed free world even attempt to adopt a SUCCESSFUL war on terror when it opposes Israel over against the most disgusting 'people' in the world and possibly the most disgusting 'people' the world has ever seen!? 'palestinians' murder sleeping 3 MONTH OLD BABY GIRLS AND REVEL IN IT - FACT!! We are on a losing battle and seem to expect the Israelis to commit suicide so as the arab oil will keep flowing in our filthy imm,oral 'leaders' pockets. How stupid does the world think Israelis are? - How stupid does Western media believe it's audiences are?.. and what an insult to humanity. They are really disgusting and They have got to be kidding!
72. Israel hasn't stood firm for independence. Plan now
Thinking Jew ,   Israel   (05.15.11)
organize for aggressive, mass, violent, "in their face" protests next, and all future, Independence Days. If Israel is going to remain, and remain free and Judaic, it will only happen by force. Or suffer the consequences. Arabs go blood-thirsty when they sense weakness.
73. BUILD A WALL: YES, A WALL: NO APOLOGIES
EZ ,   US   (05.15.11)
The Arabs (collectively) want the freedom to make their own choices, their "own" kind of government and when the status quo is tolerable, they abuse Israel, attempt to destroy it, etc. But when their OWN PEOPLE go against them, they are so cowardly they'll RUN TO THEIR SELF DACLARED ENEMY: "we're tired of the killing...we want asylum"..."we want to come home". These expressions are such disgusting displays of a multi-faced, opportunistic group of COWARDS! Go fix you own damn country: if you fools are so 'willing' to "die for our brothers in Palestine"...you'd think you'd have the honor of fighting and dying for your own damn country! Two-faced, backstabbing buffoons! The Arab community is SO schizophrenic and insane, they NEVER make up their minds. Do these people think that repressing the Jews and murdering them en mass FOR CENTURIES will garner A FLECK OF COMPASSION??? UH, NO! Build the wall across every damn bordering Arab nation and forget peace with these total losers!! Yes, losers!!! No dignity, no honor, no shame, no compassion, no generosity, NO HUMANITY. "Bloody Sunday" YNET called this? What the hell do we call yesterday when a Palestinian mowed down a bunch of Jews, murdering one of them? "Happy Shabbos"??? Get a clue: the blood was SOLELY from the "peaceful demonstrations" promised by the irresponsible Arabs. Israel should count it's true friends on ONE HAND and be happy with that and that alone. The world hates the Jews: if we have a few friends, cherish them and we'll be much happier. Iron dome, arrow 3-4-5-6-7-8...whatever it takes to keep the animals out and from terrorizing our people on our TINY little historic homeland. Screw the rest of the Arab nations around us: they are NUTS!
74. Shiek Ratlle&Roll is right
JS ,   USA   (05.15.11)
Libya is in chaos, Egypt has fallen, Hizb has taken Lebanon. Syria is on the brink and Iran is foaming at the mouth. If Israel is the superpower that the likes of SaraB say it is then do something about this. According to her your a nuclear power, yet to be proven, but as such you should do something, YOU should do something to fix this neighborhood. Act like the superpower you want to be. DO SOMETHING.
75. #40 Do not for one minute think they want asylum.
Harry Wright ,   UK   (05.15.11)
They can go to Lebanon for that. They want an Islamic invasion of Israel again. They have to be pushed back by force of arms if necessary. But it is far better that they go back home from whence they came.
76. Stupid Arab bullies ....
sk ,   USA   (05.15.11)
Stupid idiotic Arab bullies, you Arabs have over 99.96% of Middle East land and oil ... go after your oil rich Arab cousins to solve your pathetic problems!!!
77. #64 How far? They have crossed your borders
JS ,   USA   (05.15.11)
78. Time to install and electric fence or shoot to kill
israel   (05.15.11)
We cannot allow this to happen. The borders must be either secured by an electric fence, not a touch sensor, but electric OR a shoot to kill policy. The USA have the same down south, no-one moans about that. Kudos to our boys, they were amazing - all the 10 that I saw at the border on the news. What the f**k was THAT? why weren't there more of our boys there?
79. Peace
michael Pielet ,   boca raton, Israel   (05.15.11)
Remember you make peace with your enemies. Quoting the late P.M. Rabin. So make peace.
80. Israeli Left's Burden
Joe K ,   Silicon Valley   (05.15.11)
I hold Simon Peres, Ehud Barak, and the perpetrators of the Oslo conspiracy responsible for the deterioration of Israel's position vis a vis Arab irredentism, and the perception of our rights in the world. There is no compromise with Anti-Semitism. Israeli's have not developed the radar as have Jews in the diaspora. We have stupidly and collectively refused to make our case for self determination, and have forfeited the power of that narrative to those that prefer us dead. I shall not forget or forgive Peres' missives that "Good Policies don't require Good Hasbara" in glib response to criticisms that Israel was not making it's case in the the world media more forcefully. I shall not forgive or forget Ehud Barak's claims that Assad makes a good partner for peace while he was still in uniform, during his period of sinun, and jockying for position with the Labor Party. The right has been banished and ridiculed by the left leaning self hating, self appointed "enlightened ones". Now look what we have around us. Our perceived weakness now burdens the next generation with terrible concerns of self defense. While not wanting to spark a 'rightist' backlash, the time has come to recognize that concern about potential unfavorable outcomes from naivete, are legitimate issues. Had the Left been intellectually honest and not delusional, we would not have found ourselves in this position. I can only pray that it is not too late to find the strength and undo the damage to our collective future as jews in the middle east caused by the Israeli left. Perfidy is the word that comes to mind.
81. Fire Barak NOW!!!Do we have an army of a bunch of piss asses
Al   (05.15.11)
Netanyahu do your bloody job or get out of the way. You are as useful as tits on a bull. The Army is there to protect the army. Orders should be to shoot to kill. No army in the world would tolerate this. Damn what the F*** is going on there?
82. This one does not pass the smell test
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (05.15.11)
"IDF officials said the casualties were likely hit by Lebanese forces, who directed heavy fire at the protestors. " Yet the Lebanese were trying to keep the protesters away from the border. Does anyone really believe that the Lebanese would be so interested in helping Israel out that they would kill and injure over 100 civilians? What does the IDF official mean by "likely"? Unless someone has concrete proof it is most UNLIKELY. And obviously these officials did not know or they would not have used the word "likely".
83. wrong #17, when a mexican crosses into the US
mea   (05.15.11)
They are NOT shot on sight. Been living in America long? People captured along the US-Mexican border are detained and released. They are given a court date and let go, on site, not back at the border, but right at the cop shop, inside the US. Many people do not like that they are not transported back. It is called 'catch and release'.
84. #62 - in the Guantamo Cuba detention facility,
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NY   (05.15.11)
they use incessant reruns of Barry Manilow tunes to destroy the incarcerated terrorists' psyches.
85. #26 Yossef and #65 William, re Golani
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (05.15.11)
Druzem: Just to add to your comments, my understanding is that the Druzem in 1948 sided with Israel because they were told to do so by a Druze prophet who knew that the (Israeli) Jews would win the War of Independence. They are very practical people. With respect to the Golani Druzem, I agree, they hesitate because they are not sure where Israel will go with The Golan. They don't wish to be caught in the crossfire. Once Israel establishes itself irrevocably on The Golan, the Golani Druzem will also commit to the State of Israel.
86. Leo, #57, Yes
Yossef   (05.15.11)
Samir Quntar is Druze... I hope he is just an exception.
87. #36 Button your burqa
Cynthia ,   USA   (05.15.11)
Cloudy in London, you must feel the chill. Where would the Palestinians be without Arab/Muslim provocations? They would likely have a state by now. Diversion away from Arab/Muslim brutality is far more important than Palestinian statehood. Just like your post.
88. #82; Doug, POOR GUY
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (05.15.11)
It's always sad when people speak from a pure sense of ignorance. Then draw a definite conclusion as if it's a fact. Yet not realize the shear stupidity of such actions. Doug writes: "What does the IDF official mean by "likely"? Unless someone has concrete proof it is most UNLIKELY." Well that's simple Doug, It is an incident that just occurred, the IDF usually investigates these things before they make any "concrete" conclusions. As you put it Doug. Yet apparently you have already jumped to conclusions based on what? Reports from Arab sources, what are you, a moron? You would believe proven liars without question? Doug writes: "Does anyone really believe that the Lebanese would be so interested in helping Israel out that they would kill and injure over 100 civilians? " Who said they were doing it to help Israel, you? But just think when Hezbollah attacked Israel in 2006, what was the Israeli response? Would the Lebanese army be protecting Israel, or Lebanon? Do they want to risk what Nasrallah said after that war? That he underestimated the Israeli response?
89. nakbay day
spookey ,   birmingham uk   (05.15.11)
shoot on sight , if infiltrate
90. to dog 84
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (05.16.11)
I recommend that you howl along Barry Manilow songs too-never mind that he is Jewish.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article