News
Watch: Police commander slaps Arab protester
Aviel Magnezi
Published: 16.05.11, 14:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. mea 24
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.16.11)
If she is going to dish it out then she should be willing to take it. It's funny how some women scream for equality but at the same time they demand special treatment. If a man treats a woman like he treats a man women cry foul. I remember when they allowed women into West Point. The men all wore uncomfortable hard shoes but the women all wore nice tennis shoes. If women want to be treated like ladies then they should act like ladies.
32. I say it again
babawawa ,   new york, usa   (05.16.11)
when a police officer tells you to move, you move. No argument, no talk back. Here in my country, they beat the crap out of you and then jail you for resisting arrest. The woman should have been arrested.
33. Slap in the face to dignity
Ron Grant ,   Nova Scotia,Canada   (05.16.11)
The arrogance of the colonizer.The humility of the colonized.
34. He would have gotten a medal had he struck a Jew
uzitiger ,   Ramat Gan   (05.16.11)
35. #13 What is with you guys that pretend
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.16.11)
you're sailors of some sort or another ? She hit a cop, she got slapped in return Of course, in Miami, a woman can go around slapping a cop without any problem The real probmem in your case, is that your mother didn't get slapped for having you, an abomination to mankind
36. So he should have turned the other cheek?
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (05.16.11)
I think not. I can't imagine anyone so stupid as to strike a police officer and not draw reaction. Had she done that to a cop in the PA or Syria or Lebanon, would she have lived to tell the story?
37. Long Overdue !!!!!!!!!!Bravo !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SpittingInOurFaces ,   china and israel   (05.16.11)
38. She should of been arrested
JAy3 ,   Israel   (05.16.11)
She deserved more than just a slap. The video doesnt show her slapping him first....typical arab propaganda that only tells half the story.
39. If she's a lawyer, she should know better
reasonable ,   usa   (05.16.11)
than to strike a cop. But the policeman acted like a thug, so I would hold both of them accountable for their actions.
40. Israeli police at least allows our arch enemy to protest
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (05.16.11)
How it would end in Syria, Libya and Egypt we all know all too well. Arabs are our enemies - they want our land, our freedom and our lives, they rewrite our 4000-year old history in Israel, they want to take over our land, the behave as if the land is theirs, they attack our ethnicity and accuse us of racism while they glorify and deny the Holocaust and applaud 1400 years of Moslem/Arab anti-Semitism. They ethnically cleansed 800000-900000 Jews from Iraq, Yemen, Egypt and North Africa. They have started wars on us in 1948, 1956, 1967, 1973, 1982, 1991, 2006 and 2009. And these FOREIGN LOOKING people are accusing us (sick!) of having an appearance that is "not native to the land". It's actually vice versa. They are only projecting their own characteristics on us. And after all this mistreatment of Israel and the Jewish people they expect decent and respectful behavior? Hell no woman! You provoked the police officer and he responded accordingly. There is something called the LAW. You OBEY IT!
41. Even if she did slap him
Chaya ,   Tel Aviv   (05.16.11)
there is nothing that justifies a policeman - and especially an officer! - striking someone! Yes, they were there illegally. But she should have been restrained and arrested for striking a police officer (if she did - it's hard to see from the video).
42. typical bully
Matt ,   UK   (05.16.11)
Yes yes.. nothing new here. Israeli thugs select weakest target to attack.
43. the hypocrisy
SA ,   USA   (05.16.11)
Oh right slapping hard is a real display of violence. Their assertion that rule of law is a foreign concept in Israel just disproves their point--they were able to file a complaint against him in Israel...imagine if a Syrian protester filed a complaint against the military for firing a tear gas canister at him...
44. wait did she slap him? i can't see it in the video.
SA ,   USA   (05.16.11)
45. Got to wonder, Matt
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (05.16.11)
If some ill bred protesting, British-hating Irishwoman took a swing at one of your cops, what do you expect he would do? Dance the minuet with her? Do refrain from ignorant comments on a subject you know nothing about.
46. Typical Thug!
IRAN#1   (05.16.11)
It's business as usual when it comes to Jews treating woman. \W We saw it at the highest level with Mr. Kahn and the maid in NYC the other day., and he is educated type LOL!!!!!
47. I don't know what she's complaining about
Ish Kabibble ,   Delancey   (05.16.11)
She got equal treatment, slap given, slap returned
48. A clear case of police brutality...happens all the time.
african-american ,   usa   (05.17.11)
49. #48 Afircan American
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.17.11)
Since you've taken it upon yourself to butt into Israeli affairs, let me remind you that the ratio of African American prisoners in U.S. jails, far exceeds their ratio in the American Population Clean your own house first, before you judge others "Factoid: Black Male Incarceration Rate is 6 Times Greater Than Rate for White Males Statistics from the Department of Justice indicate that black males are incarcerated – held in prison or jail – at a rate that is over 6 times higher than that for white males. For every 100,000 black males, an estimated 4,777 are held in federal or state prison or a local jail. By contrast, for every 100,000 white men, only 727 are estimated to be incarcerated." If you wish, just ask, I'll give your the ratio of your births out your of wedlock From your post, you must have had some of your own difficulty with the Law This woman assaulted a Police Officer in the performance of his duties, she’s lucky she got away with a mere slap, slug an American cop, you won’t just get slapped
50. no.45 Condoning Violence
Matt ,   UK   (05.17.11)
Well done, promoting police brutality and violence against women in one sentence. You are ready to make aliyah , i think.
51. out of control cop
td ,   ny   (05.17.11)
It's bizarre to me that so many commenters mention that she slapped him even though there is no indication of it in the video. It's inconceivalbe that she would have slapped him in these circumstances -- she was angry but not about to strike a much larger person who has the power to put her in prison, not to mention strike her back. Cops can't stand it when people don't show them respect and cower in their presence and apparently many commenters think it's okay for a protesting lawyer to be smacked for showing disrepect. That is nauseating.
52. #51 td - out of sight comments
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.17.11)
Don't bear false witness The woman has never denied she slapped the cop In NY, where you live, would a cop allow himself to be slapped without retaliating? I don't think so; I would say a tap with a nightstick upside the head would be an expected response Size had nothing to do with it, she assumed her being a female would grant her some sort of immunity from retaliation, she was wrong View in the video was rather narrow; you weren't there to see the entire scene, others were and saw her assaulting the officer
53. #50 Matt - YOU are condoning violence
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.17.11)
You're saying it's O.K. for a woman to slap a policeman, just because she's a woman, which should grant her automatic immunity for breaking the law to perform assault She was fortunate that the officer didn't bop her with a billy club It may be that way in the U.K., but most countries won't allow it
54. Huh?
td ,   ny   (05.18.11)
What are you talking about? There's no indication that she slapped him. Did the cop say that? If so, why hasn't it been reported in this Ynet arcticle? As to your question about what would happen in NY if a cop hit a woman with a nightstick in the head after she lightly struck him (which didn't appear to happen here) -- if it were filmed on tape, he would be in serious trouble. A cop can use measures that are necessary to protect himself or apprehend a suspect but he can't deliberately harm someone just because he's been insulted or feels angry. It may be a human reaction -- but we should all expect better.
55. #53 td-Illegal protest without permit
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.19.11)
That in itself was a violation of the law, try that in the U;S.A., they have handcuffs and paddy wagon to carry away the garbage You were'nt there, the camera view was that of only a narrow field of view If you want to see more, get on over and participate in the next demo td "out of sight comments", you betcha, you're in NY and saw nothing
Previous talkbacks
Back to article