News
Obama: Israel must act boldly
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 19.05.11, 20:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
158 Talkbacks for this article
31. Let me get this straight Obama
Maurice ,   Los Angeles, USA   (05.19.11)
If I understand you correctly, Israel is to make all the sacrifices. Israel is to give up land that were captured as the result of being attacked. The arabs do not have to give up any land for their palestinian brethens. I don't think so Mr. president and I can wait unitl we the American people vote you out next year.
32. Obama's speech
Colin Smith ,   Torquay, UK   (05.19.11)
Rubbish we should never go back to the 1967 lines. God has outlined the borders of Israel and that will prevail.
33. Obama "offers" the Arabs money - Congress will decide terms!
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (05.19.11)
Here's reality - There will be no billions in taxpayer funding appropriated by Congress to bankroll Egypt and other "emerging" Arab democracies without strict terms demanding and enforcing that Egypt scrupuloisly and stricly follow its peace treaty with Israel, including shutting off all weapon smuggling across demilitiarized Sinai into Gaza, coordinating all crossing across Philadelphi with Israeli wishes, ending demonization of israel in its press actions, and dialing back - way back - its dealings with Iran, including strict observance of sanctions. Or no money, not even what they already get. And there's not a thing Obama can do about that, except to go along with Congressional restrictions. With joblessness rising in every Congressional district, Obama will have little luck sending billions to Egypt to create jobs, and Egypt is going to have to respond to Congress' demands - or get nothing.
34. 6 - They will not support him as in the past.
split ,   US   (05.19.11)
So, how many votes will he lose and how many will he gain as a result of Jewish boycott ? ,...
35. '67 Borders? Palestinian People?
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (05.19.11)
Whoa, there, Mr. Obama. The '67 borders are no longer relevant. That was some.....44 years ago! A lot has changed since then. There never was a Palestinian people. They are merely Arabs who live in the Land of Israel. There is nothing distinct about them which distinguishes them from any other Arab - same language, same religion, same culture, same food, etc. They don't even have a unique history. Now, if we understood you correctly, Israel is to be a Jewish state and Palestine a Palestinian state. Okay. Does that mean that no Jews can live in Palestine? And if so, then can we evict all Arabs from Israel or, at least deny them the right to vote and be members of the Knesses? But, if Arabs can continue to live and build in Israel, then why shouldn't Jews do the same in Palestine? Seems like after all this time, Mr. Obama still does not have a clew as to what is really going on in this part of the world and what has to be done to achieve peace. Oy vey.
36. for me it all starts with israel's right to exist
Amit ,   israel   (05.19.11)
and the understanding that "right of return" to the jewish state (living along side to the palestinian state) is impossible. and that involves educating for love between the 2 people.
37. take off the blinders
Hopeful   (05.19.11)
Obama's speech is realistic and pragmatic. Those Israelis among us who do not internalize the truth he is speaking are wearing blinders and are oblivious to where things are heading. They are 'still dancing in the ballroom while the Titanic is on a collision course with the iceberg''.
38. to obama:
david b ,   NY, USA   (05.19.11)
The only things I could not agree with are the order of things: Previous experience has shown clear that the negotiations must begin with the major controversies that always blows everything. And that means., recognizing Israel's right to exist, the right of return is not realistic vision for the twostate solution and the issue of Jerusalem the eternal capital of the Jewish people that 3000 years. Another issue, that less people are aware of is a matter of Palestinian archaeological terrorism in the city of Jerusalem which destroys all traces of historical buildings, archaeological findings that are not of Islam. This thing has to stop. Even if Jerusalem will be divided at the end as part of the arrangement honor all religions in the city have to stay. The destruction of Jewish Christian and Armenian history has to stop immediately even before the end of negotiations. thank you and may god bless you all!!
39. Obama just doesn't understand!!!
JP ,   Israel/USA   (05.19.11)
HaShem did not give this land to the Jews for us to be like ANY other nation. Unfortunately, Netenyahu doesn't understand this either!!!
40. Obama did not say Israel must retreat to pre-1967 lines
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (05.19.11)
He said that there should be MUTUALLY AGREED UPON land swaps, the same as all previous U.S. administrations.
41. #14 with a lot of American MOOLA $$$ :)
rachel ,   tel aviv   (05.19.11)
42. Also, the 1967 "borders" really means...
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (05.19.11)
The cease-fire lines AFTER the Six Day War, when Israel controlled Gaza, the Sinai, the West Bank. If he meant when Egypt, Jordan and Syria controlled Gaza, the West Bank and Golan, he would have mentioned the 1948 lines. Just thought I would throw that out.
43. We Love you Israel
maria ,   US   (05.19.11)
Most Americans do not agree with the POTUS views on Israel and the ME. I for one love Israel.
44. OK. Start at the beginning - which is always
Harry Wright ,   UK   (05.19.11)
the best place to start. So Obama acknowledged the importance of the refusal of the Pals to recognise Israel as the Jewish state for the Jewish people. Let him work on that basic issue and put everything else in a basket and shove it in a corner until.... There is no need for further discussion until he gets the answer for that which he expects the Pals to answer "soon". Whenever he sorts out the recognition issue, then and only then can he bring back out the basket. Now, why did he signal yesterday that '67 borders would not be mentioned? I tell you, he will be zig-zagging up to his death because it is in his genes... lies and more lies. He is so unreliable EVERYTHING must be obtained from him in writing - like there will be no more building freezes - easy for him to say, but impossible for him to put in writing. Easy for him to say that America's commitment "to Israel's security is unshakable", but how does that translate with reality regarding '67 borders? He said that "Israel must act boldly to advance lasting peace" meaning that Israel must compromise that same security of which he spoke so glowingly. He is contradicting himself as far as I am concerned.
45. We are again BETRAYED!!!
Dan ,   Florida   (05.19.11)
46. now or never
observer ,   Egypt   (05.19.11)
US veto which prevented a UN condemnation of settlement construction did. Attempt to retract Goldstone report didn't end isolation. UN panel is due to make a final decision on the report of the UN Human Rights Council into the massacre on the Mavi Marmara aid ship. Identifying the objection expressed by global public opinion to the occupation policy as anti-Semitic does add to the isolation. Israelis are not as strong as they used to perceive themselves. Obama!, resolve the now already isolation, so that you don't have to lie in September, you cant then say that you are preventing Israel isolation.
47. damn pharaoh hussein
Gertrude   (05.19.11)
and his evil baby-murdering jew-hating minions
48. Obama's refusal to look at the Arabs' faces directly and...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (05.19.11)
...demand that they accept Israel's right to be, to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people - and not only its right to exist - is indicative of the fact that he has little understanding of the core reason for the conflict. His expectation to see the 1949 armistice lines (dubbed 1967 boundaries) as the future borders of the Jewish state come as an added insult. Even UN Security Council Resolution, 242, does not expect Israel to withdraw its troops to these lines, and 242, let's remind Obama, has been the basis for all peace talks to date after it had been accepted by ALL parties to the conflict. Obama is either removed from reality or is deeply hostile to Israel or both!!
49. obama-Do you know what racism and
Don Rosenberg ,   Palatine USA   (05.19.11)
terrorism are? Apparently racism and terrorism is ok against Jews , but not blacks. These arab fakestinians are arabs that deserve no state, let alone on top of Israel. obummer read my lips "Go back to kenya or wherever you came from."
50. I urge the American Jews to march on Washigton
Al   (05.19.11)
voicing their displeasure with Obama. First he starts with Isreal a far away land then he will start with you. You my dear fellow Jews in America are in his crosshairs. As long as you support this turd with money its cool, once you wisen up to him, then he will unleash his real followers on you. You bloody well know who they are. Get rid of him by chocking off his relection coffers. He must go!! He does not deserve a single nickel from the Jews of America. He has openly declared war on Israel. He is a declared enemy of Israel and of the Jewish people. We Jews in Canada support PM Harper en mass as he fully supports Israel. Obama does not warrant your support.
51. Obama to Israel....DIE a death of a 1000 cuts
Al   (05.19.11)
This turd is an enemy of Israel and the Jewish people. I urge the Jews of America to vote him out of office. Mitt and the republicans must replace him if only for the safety of Israel. The Jews of America are in a terrible state for they are afraid of being called racist by Obamas backers. Here is news for you...The Jews in America are going to sink as America is sinking. Americas days are over if Obama is re-elected. I warned that Israel would be the korban after Bin Laden was offed... I was right.
52. OR ELSE WHAT, CHUMP?
FREEDOM FIGHTER ,   Erertz   (05.19.11)
You will give a thumbs up to Pali statehood in Sept? Remove US cooperation and Impose sanctions? Looks like this is where this Geo-"pragmatist" is going. After all the world still REALLY, really needs Arab oil and any justice regarding the Jews is strictly optional in an world bereft of ethics and gone insane. Barry or Ramses or whatever you and your chums call you, read our lips: NEVER AGAIN. Got that?
53. 23 - Israel is democratic and Jewish
split ,   US   (05.19.11)
Hard to find a better example of an oxymoron ,...
54. Obama will end up like Osama
Marco ,   Spain   (05.19.11)
For following the most radical Muslim agenda.
55. USA stands with Israel
Rightwingheroes ,   USA   (05.19.11)
King Obama does not speak on behalf of the majority of Americans. He is a wolf in sheeps clothing. He is the serpent who speaks with a forked tongue.
56. Obama and 67 border
Benjamin ,   Greenville   (05.19.11)
If you think that Obama's guarantees are to be trusted just ask Hosni Mubarak.
57. Obama Breaking International Law
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (05.19.11)
Eugene Rostow Under Secretary of state author of UN resolution 242 wrote in 1991 that Israel and Jews had a right to settle the West Bank, and that the British Mandate cannot be rescinded. He also said that Israel was not required to go back to the 67 borders.
58. Bibi: Talk Sternly to Congress; Snub Obama
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (05.19.11)
59. what about Hizballa ????
AM Israel chi ,   ISRAEL   (05.19.11)
He didn't mentiond the terror from north (leabanon) and he didn't talk about AL- Qaeida bases on syria borders and inside gaza. and what about irans neuclear weapons ??? it's not so easy... he made it sound very easy for a moment but this moment has passed.
60. so what about the upcoming PROVOCATION OF THE IHH?
question ,   ottawa canada   (05.19.11)
if peace talk starts, and the UN already says ther is no humanitarian crisis why EU are backing them???
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article