News
Netanyahu: 1967 lines 'indefensible'
Associated Press
Published: 20.05.11, 21:37
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
116 Talkbacks for this article
61. Obama is stuck in a time warp. There is a paradigm shift.
Harry Wright ,   UK   (05.21.11)
Obama deliberately threw Israel under the bus. There was no need for him to mention '67 borders at all. If he was truly a progressive man of vision and change, he would have said "within negotiated borders" full stop, rather than go backwards in time because the chaos and uncertainty in the ME now requires a paradigm shift in thinking and approach - and to go back to the '67 borders is counterproductive and archaic. We are in 2011 - pre-'67 borders is a retrograde step and it is OBSOLETE! Throw it out. There is no place for that in these times and circumstances. If it was not good enough for acceptance in '67, how the hell could it be good enough in 2011???? What is wrong with this man! Obama's speech has revealed his true intention to destroy Israel. In a nutshell, Obama offered "promises" in exchange for territory. He IMPLIED the "promise" of security while advancing a position that guaranteed Israel's destruction, albeit padding it with "negotiated". He is deceitful and wicked because he fully understands the repercussions on Israel. His word is worth nothing as he changes them like he changes his clothes and he does not honour past agreements. He is far worse than Carter. He attempts to cover his zeal for revolution by liberally using the term "democracy" never mind that the region is nowhere near prepared for such a thing. Obama shares the Ayres/Dorn revolutionary enthusiasm. He is ecstatic about the revolutionary chaos of the moment in the ME that he promotes under the guise of "democracy". He will leave a legacy of total chaos and insecurity in the ME as individual despots will be replaced by even more despotic Islamic organizations.
62. #7, Israel did grab the whole Sinai in 67
Jorge ,   tegucigalpa   (05.21.11)
But for peace, after developing an oil and gas industry, and several touristic spots, for a peace treaty, it gave all that back, if Israel wanted land, why not keep the Sinai, and that was a lot of land, and try to keep, that tiny spot that is Judea and Samaria, Israel is always for peace, REAL PEACE, Arabs and Palestinians are not
63. Obama NEVER visited Israel: how can he talk!!?
ZAL ,   USA   (05.21.11)
Obama needs to be INVITED TO ISRAEL AND FLOWN BY HELICOPTER AROUND ISRAEL TO SEE THE REALITY ISRAEL FACES. why the heck hasnt Netanyahu done this!? Why hasnt Leiberman ( whose been notably silent) or 'Barak'!? The whole damn government is asleep! Obama has visited a TON of Muslim countries but can't visit the ONE SINGLE JEWISH COUNTRY!? Make the public offer and force his hand!
64. EXCELLENT JOB MR. PRIME MINISTER!
Mea   (05.21.11)
Netanyahu has skillfully handled Obama. That he informed the president in front of the world, lectured him, was perfect. Reach over to the nearest wall and rap your knuckle on it. On the other side, "Palestine"--> that's how close it was until 1967, right on the opposite side of the wall, and they murder, murder, murder the Jews. Looks like the little three act play (Pretend to split, pretend to make up, declare a state) did not work out so well with the PA/Hamas sidling....lol! GREAT job Netanyahu!!!!
65. what is that "security"-threat of withdrawal to 67-borders ?
eporue ,   europe   (05.21.11)
its getting out the settlers... thats impossible without having lots of fatalities within the IDF, and then the settlers will go on a rampage inside israel.. probably mostly in tel aviv...
66. JORDAN......IS......78%......OF.......PALESTINE
Jordan ,   Is Palestine   (05.21.11)
67. Netanyahu: 1967 lines 'indefensible'
carmelita codilla ,   cebu, philippines   (05.21.11)
God bless Israel and all the countries that surround her.
68. Livni cant even speak english right
Joe ,   NY   (05.21.11)
So how she's complaining netanyahu ? he's doing the best he can and he just made a good move today
69. #3: How stupid and blind an you be....
Vardina   (05.21.11)
70. #7: Dogs bark and the world goes on...
Vardina   (05.21.11)
71. Mr Netanyahu Class Act.
David Powell ,   Everett, Wa. USA   (05.21.11)
So refreshing to see Obama get clocked by Netanyahu. Obama looked really pi**ed. PRICELESS
72. How much money did Israel as well as the US
Ypip ,   Canada   (05.21.11)
to defend her borders in 1967. It was an expensive and dangerous campaign. And so now, to go back is merely going to be more expensive. The planet is stressed out as it is while is ponders 1967, we don't need more bureaucrats with outrageous salaries re-inventing the printing press! It's just paper, get over it.
73. #34 WHAT IF..........
LARRY ,   US ARMY RETIRED   (05.21.11)
MEXICO AND THE AMERICAN INDIANS GO TO THE UN AND SEEK THERE FORMER LAND BACK THAT WAS TAKEN FROM THEM IN THE LAST THREE CENTURIES. YOUR MIND OPERATES AS A 9 YEAR OLD
74. "67 BORDERS"
Leon Waller ,   NJ, USA   (05.21.11)
THERE WERE NO "67 BORDERS". Those were the 1949 ARMISTICE LINES. Call it what it is!!!!!!!!!
75. I saw Beebee on prime time CBS...
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NJ   (05.21.11)
he totally owned Obama... he left bambi speechless... on US prime time teevee... in the US White House. On to the AIPAC convention and then the combined houses of the US congress... give it to him, beebee, again and again. Don't forget a parting shot while you board IAF one. When you are done, enjoy the Israeli kudos upon your arrival at the BG aerodrome... publicise your slapdown of that US Kaffir.
76. Who is this STUPID S. K. @ # 25! Full of B.S.
Israeli 2   (05.21.11)
77. @26, no one notices you
(05.21.11)
people stop opening your posts, don't bother any longer you already burnt all the good will posters gave you, you've become invisible it is time you get a job, lazy bum
78. Bibi finally had the guts
Joe cone ,   USA   (05.21.11)
Bibi now was that so hard to say no? He finally got some guts now if he can get the guts to fire ehud barak and investigate Peres livni and barak on why are they always undercutting Israel we may have a chance for israel to get some respect.
79. israel must rely on itself
zvi ,   los angeles usa   (05.21.11)
it is easy for others to lecture to israel because thy do not face possible annihilation. REMEMBER IT IS THE ARABS WHO SEEK OUR DESTRUCTION. G-d forbid this! Israel should take NO CHANCES with its security. PM was right when he said we are a persecuted people and that history will not give us a second chance. The PM did well in Washington and should take our case to the Congress and public on Monday Am Yisrael chai
80. Only Bibi could screw up this badly
StevieT ,   USA   (05.21.11)
He held the key to mint. He even made it point #3 out of his 3 talking points. Yet, by throwing out the big borders controversy, not one media outlet I follow even mention the 900 pound Gorilla. Yes my friends, I am talking about the right of return, THE issue that the Arabs can't win on. This is the centerpiece that needs to be out there and thrown into the laps of the Pals so they can stew in it. But by emphasizing the '67 Borders, and by upstaging the President of the US, Bibi is back where he started, with few non Israeli supporters and a dim future for peace.
81. A modern day Judas....Petrodollars at work
EST ,   Miami USA   (05.21.11)
82. To#46 What you propose is that the Jews of Israel commit
EST ,   Miami USA   (05.21.11)
suicide!!! First you need a peace partner...someone who recognizes in writing and in public the right of your people to exist! There was nothing to indicate that Obama set that as a precondition for any negotiations....how can you negotiate or give in anything to someone who is publicly calling for your obliteration????...unless that is what you have in mind...Obama has turned into the modern day Judas...Petrodollars at work!
83. Reply to "were borders indefensible before 1967"
Nicole ,   Los Angeles, ca   (05.21.11)
Yes, they were very indefensible before 1967 too. In those days the Jewish cities were easier to fire/shoot especially in galilee area in north. The farmers were unable to farm without Syrian troops harassing them with bullets from the golan heights. Once we captured golan heights in 1967 they could no longer abuse Jewish civilians. In addition having presence in Samaria and Judah hills offers Israel more defense. The situation was very dangerous for Israel pre 1967.
84. #23, please explain....
Brian ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (05.21.11)
... if Israel is guilty of genocide, how is it possible that the population, you are accusing Israel of committing genocide against, has and continues to grow exponentially? Your an ass, a complete ass.
85. Netanyahu is my man..
Mike ,   The Netherlands   (05.21.11)
Bravo Bibi. I am not jewish or israeli, but today I am very proud hearing you answering Obama boldly. Your answer sounds to me this way: who the hell are you telling Israel what to do? Your nation is not in a such danger like ours. So shut up and stop pretending you understand our struggles to survive among many nations who hate us, because you don't. Very well done Bibi ! God bless you !
86. Retreating to the 67 borders-suicidal !
SHARON ,   ISREAL   (05.21.11)
Is any sane country willing to let terrorists shell with a cannon its citizens?! Is any sane country willing to be split into two within hours? ! We want to live -isn't that clear enough?!
87. 3
birdi ,   israel   (05.21.11)
time for you to super-glue a lage sock to your mouth. your opinions fall on deaf ears here.
88. 8
birdi ,   israel   (05.21.11)
oh oh al, the truth pill becomes you. nice.
89. 9
birdi ,   israel   (05.21.11)
mrs/mr nour, bahrain needs your expert advice now. we dont. zip it darlin & show respect to your elders.
90. No 23 Jamal
Emma ,   London   (05.21.11)
You call the missiles fireworks, they are not they are real missiles that maim and kill (especially when fired at school buses). Genocide you say - if that is the case how come the Palestinian population has increased in the last 63 years and continues to increase, I understood that genocide meant the exact opposite. It is the Arab leaders who consider the lives of their own people unimportant which is why they use them as human shields. When Arabs have respect for the lives of their own people they may then start to have respect for the lives of other people. Compared to Arab leaders, the Israeli government are saints.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article