News
PA challenges Netanyahu to accept 1967 lines
Elior Levy
Published: 22.05.11, 15:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. to # 26
jew from the east   (05.22.11)
""we are "animals" in your eyes, right ita ?!!!!! "" according to the arab behavior,you are 100% right
32. To #26 "Palestinian" Salma
Jonathan ,   Palo Alto   (05.22.11)
The only reason people refer to Palestinians as animals, is because of atrocities that they have committed and capable of. This is just stating the obvious - if 18 year old brainwashed arabs are capable of deliberately killing infants and toddlers in their sleep - they are, in fact, much worse than animals.
33. Pentagon Assessment After 1967 War
Roy Chweidan ,   Netanya, Israel   (05.22.11)
After the 1967 war, the Pentagon made a comprehensive and detailed assessment on the essential border requirements for Israel to be able to defend itself in the future. The assessment concluded that Israel was obliged to keep permanent control of the whole of the West Bank, all of the territory on the Golan Heights controlled by Israel after the war, and also the eastern part of the Sinai Peninsular. I declare that I myself heard this in the media at the time and am not relying on information given to me. As I urgently want to transfer this info to Bibi Netanyahu in USA before he addresses Congress on Tuesday, will anybody who can get me the email address of the Israel Embassy in the USA, PLEASE send it to me at royperla@bezqint.net urgently. I am asking here for help from ynetnews to send me this email address. THANK YOU Roy Chweidan, Netanya
34. 67 BORDERS JUST A DISTRACTION
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (05.22.11)
Israel already offered 100% of the Gaza and well over 90% of the West Bank with some land swaps, the deal was turned down, by the Arabs Plus we have four addition points, 1) recognition of Israel by the new unity government (including Hamas) 2) forfeiture of the return of Pal refugees; 3) the IDF presence and control of the Jordan river 4) Renounce terrorism, violence and incitement against Israel. Without a prior agreement that includes these points BEFORE any New Arab entity would be considered, it's just a distraction, and not a serious offer by the Arabs. . After all it's Israel that's taking the chance, not the Arabs. Israel is giving up something real (Land), while the Arabs are just offering their word, big deal.
35. Desert compression & cross dressing
Gideon Reader ,   United States   (05.22.11)
Curious is it not how stress can be so negative towards one's health and outlook. PM Netanyahu's firm stance vis a vis the ZerObama Mis-Mal and Non-administration's positive viewpoint of Community organizing of Arabism, and his (ZerObama's) "Muslim Outreach" and blatant anti-Israel (and by extension, anti-Jewish) attitude, has made poor Saeb ill. I submit he would do well with my "Special Desert Compression Anti-Depression Program", specifically designed for his troubles. In fact I recommend that the entire political echelon of the alleged "palestinian authority" follow the program. How you ask? Simple and elegant. They simply Pound Sand.
36. 1967
Andy ,   Canada   (05.22.11)
I remember it well. No issue in my mind using June 10, 1967 as the basis for the border lines. Didn't Moshe Dayan offer exactly that and get the Khartoum 3 no's? "Palestine" has no consistent definition in history or geneology or even mythology to serve as a basis for Salma's continuous bogus posts here. The Arabs living in the area called Palestine by the Ottomans and the British were never a homogenous people but part of the Arab nation. Tens of thousands moved into the area from Yemen and Egypt and Iraq and Syria after the small Palestinian Jewish community was joined by European and Middle Eastern Jews after the 1869 construction of Yemin Moshe and the beginning of development of wastelands. That is the Jewish enterprise that we now know as Israel. Why don't the "Palestinians" get along? Because they are not a people other than all being Arabs. Why have they no identity other than being bitter and dispossessed? Because they have no other common history. Not before 1948. And surely not before 1869. Salma and Saeb why don't you move your people to Saudi Arabia or Iran? They love you there apparently and you would fit and there's tons of room.
37. #26 Salma, You are projecting
RickD ,   USA   (05.22.11)
Calling Israelis inhuman is simply wrong. Yes Israelis have fought against you Arabs. But they fought honorably, and always will. It is the Arabs that use suicide bombers. It is the Arabs that revel in the blood of Jews. It is the Arabs that negotiate with the body parts of Israelis. It is Arabs that honor child-murderers like Sami Kantar. It is childish for you to believe that the Israelis and Jews are like you. We are not. In psychology this is called projecting, where you imagine that others are like you.
38. Hamas' FOREIGN ministry - UNITY govt ???
CK Tan ,   Singapore, Singapore   (05.22.11)
"Hamas' foreign ministry issued a statement saying..." Abbas SAYS that he and ONLY he will REPRESENT the palis under the new UNITY govt. That hamas has a SEPARATE foreign ministry CLEARLY shows that the unity govt is just a SCAM.
39. to Salma # 26
david ,   herzlia,Israel   (05.22.11)
Salma, you are talking rubbish !!!!, majority of Israelis accept the right for a Palestinians to have a state, but 100% of Israelis ( right,left,center ....) do not accept the so called Right of Return, we are not going to commit suicide.. Forget it... it will not happen. Palestinians can all go back to teh future Palestinian state, to Jordan or to stay where they lived for the last 60 years with some financial help to start nromal lives by working and not just by getting UN aid..
40. Who plays and loses, it pays!!
~~Lengualima~~ ,   I   (05.22.11)
Saeb Erekat and the Palestinians must accept that they played 4 times in the casino of the war, and who plays a war and lose, PAY, WITH INTEREST!!
41. #9. Why should Israel negotiate with the P.A.?
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.22.11)
#9. Israel isn't "sitting" at the negotiating table. The vast majority of Israelis know there is no point in negotiating with the P.A. It is all a very stupid political game. Why should Israel negotiate with the P.A.? How could Israel possibly benefit from doing so? What does Israel have to lose by doing so? Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, defensible borders, freedom from constant rocket attacks and inundation by hostile Arabs. What does Israel have to gain? An 8 mile (15 minute tank ride) waist!!!
42. Up to this Point a Palestinian state is an Impossibility
Douglas Fireman ,   Chicago, USA   (05.22.11)
"Hamas' foreign ministry issued a statement saying that Israel was deepening its aggressive positions against any political solution claiming Netanyahu does not genuinely want to achieve a two-state solution." If Hamas and Abbas wanted a two state solution, then they would recognize Israel's right to exist. If this does not happen, then a Palestinian state is an impossibility.
43. no26 Salma
LION OF JUDAH   (05.22.11)
There is no such thing called Palestine.During ther Roman empire to punish the JEWS, the Roman have changed the name from Israel to PALISTIN.Arabs came to Israel to look for jobs with the JEWS.GO HOME where you belong
44. Gabe no 29
LION OF JUDAH   (05.22.11)
Jordan was part of Israel.Jordan is stolen land given to the KINGDOM OF HASHMITE OF SAUDI ARABIA by the BRITISH MANDATE.
45. Obama's foreign policy a mess
Mark Jeffery Koch ,   Cherry Hill, NJ USA   (05.22.11)
Funny how Obama says one thing which makes the Palestinians then make it their new demand and then suddenly backtracks a few days later. If he wanted to say the 1967 borders should be used a starting point but that all the settlements since 1967 had to be taken into consideration as a fait accompli that was not going to change and that were going to be part of permanent borders of Israel (as both Bush and Clinton said when they were in office) then why did he address the world last week and make everyone, including the Palestinians believe they would have all pre 1967 borders?? Either state what you believe and stick with it or keep quiet because all you are doing is raising the expectations of one side falsely, and then angering both sides and making it impossible for them to sit down and seriously negotiate.
46. Same old Siren Song "Pre-conditions"
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.22.11)
As always, Arabs demand that they set the parameters for talks, in effect assuring Israel's Voluntary Suicide, which is what the pre-'67 lines are and were
47. #18 Salma, take consolation in the fact
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.22.11)
That in each and every War the fictional Palestinian's fought, they lost every one Restore your right? don't make me laugh, how about Honor Killings of women, which can as of now, result in a 6 month maximum prison sentence ? I'll give it a year, maybe less, that Hamas & Fatah will be at each others throats, fighting over who gets the largest share of the swag Your leaders (not you of course, you're in Bahrain) have kept the pot boiling, since it's a great source of income for them and their associates What better cause to raise personal funds, than to claim it's to help the people, and is then divert into their own pockets, as Yasser Arafat did ? Memo, you never did answer my questions, Whatsa matta, chicken ?
48. #26 Salma - you refuse to prove
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.22.11)
that you exist I have asked you countless times to prove it, simply put, you plain flat out refuse to So, if don't want to prove your existence why should we even try to As you act, so are you treated, you are the only people that use their women & children as homicidal bomb carriers Normal people protect the families, you intentionally use them for cannon fodder Right Salma ? Surely, you remember these ? 1. Photo montage of Hussam Abdo's confrontation with Israeli troops ... Jul 18, 2004 ... "A Palestinian boy who was caught wearing an explosive belt is .... Hussam Abdo stands bare chested after taking off an explosive vest at an ... emperor.vwh.net/abdo/abdopics.htm - Cached - Similar By Inigo Gilmore in Jerusalem 12:01AM GMT 28 Jan 2002 A PALESTINIAN woman was killed when the bomb she was carrying exploded in a Jerusalem street yesterday. It was the first attack by a female in Israel in more than 16 months of conflict. The woman, a student in her twenties, was blown to pieces when the device went off outside a shoe shop in Jaffa Street. An 81-year-old Israeli man was killed and more than 100 people were injured.
49. To No. 44, Judah
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (05.22.11)
You are correct without a doubt Judah. The Jordan River is a defensible border for Israel at the present time.
50. right: trust your lives to promises of saeb, the liar
dante ,   uk   (05.22.11)
that's a smart plan. just hand over your land, put your neck on the block, and trust old saeb. he'll treat you right. everything's going to be fine, right? DON'T BE STUPID.
51. Erakat the Arafatist and his fantasy
Brod ,   USA   (05.22.11)
Erakat's fantasy knows no bounds. It is time for Erakat the Arafatist Islamist-Jihadist to stop usurping the Land of Israel from the Jewish Nation.
52. You First "Palestinians"
Granny ,   Vermont, USA   (05.22.11)
How about the Palestinians turn over a new leaf, Hamas re-write their charter acknowledging Israel's right to exist and THEN we'll talk . . . Otherwise, what we will see is a Gaza redux.
53. to #19... Fake Salma
Salma ,   Palestine   (05.22.11)
Stop Taking about our people, you don’t know anything. what I do like its your optimism, we will get our rights with our just struggle, planted in the hearth of Israel. I know it, my uncle told me.
54. #7 - You're right
lara ,   Australia   (05.23.11)
The 67 lines are the current lines. However, why is there over half a million Israeli settlers currently living within those lines? And why is this population increasing? Give it a decade or two and it will all be occupied territory with no Palestinians. AKA, ethnic cleansing.
55. Israel can cause 2013 borders and beyond
Ypip ,   Canada   (05.23.11)
into the wild blue yonder.
56. to Salma 53
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (05.23.11)
Don't listen to your uncle he is as stupid as Hamas. Better listen to your wise donkey and move to Jordan where your queen will grant you a fabulous life.
57. 1967 LijnesRjpdesGreen/'67 War
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.23.11)
Are the very lines the Arabs created by their repeatedly attacking Israel They created it, they have to live with it
58. Borders
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (05.23.11)
What the hell! Why not go all the way back to 1003 BC? That ought to cover it.
59. #54 Lara - "Ethnic Cleansing"
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.23.11)
You did a rather thorough job of it when it came to your very own Aboriginies, so who are you to talk ?
60. #54 lara
solomon ,   bklyn   (05.24.11)
Gaza and the WB are already ethnically cleansed. This began in 1948 when Jordan pushed the Jews out of the eastern part of Jerusalem and asked arabs to come and repopulate the area. They did and now call themselves "Palestinian".
Previous talkbacks
Back to article