News
Hamas: Let's discuss 1948 lines
Elior Levy
Published: 23.05.11, 14:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
100 Talkbacks for this article
31. The mask of Hamas
John M. Davies ,   Harveys Lake USA   (05.23.11)
Hamas uses ambulances to move terrorists and weapons and explosives. In battle they hide behind women and children. They use Mosques to hide military equipment and terrorists..They give aid to civilians much like a mixture of the Red Cross and the Salvation Army and this is the mask they hide behind. They are terrorists and murderers but pretend they are good guys. They are a poison which must be removed from this planet. They use religion as an excuse to steal and plunder and murder. They must be destroyed. They have no right to talk to Israel. Just ignore them . They are a tool of Iran.
32. You can discuss the 1948 lines with the IDF.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (05.23.11)
33. REMEMBER MARK TWAIN
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (05.23.11)
Remember Mark Twain's famous line: "There are lies, Damn Lies and Statistics" The 22% figure is the classic example, the Pals use it...falsely... to describe what they are being offered by the Israeli's. They say based on the 1948 Partition plan (that the Arabs refused and went to war over) they are only being offered 22% of that offer of 1948. But they refused it, and stated they would annihilate the Jewish people in a war they lost. So clearly that plan is Null & Void. But interestingly, if you look at the original Land offer for the Jewish people (from the Balfour Declaration, The Palestine Mandatory land) 78% of that land illegally went to Jordan. So Israel is now on the 22% of their original land offer. Just a funny coincidence that the percentage is the same (22%). As is typical, the Arabs only tell us half the story, omitting the facts that nullify their view, and prove it to be false, and a pure lie. We call it "lying through omission", it's an old Pallywood trick, used by them often.
34. To: No. 16
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.23.11)
A head of state for a fictitious country? How very, very ersatz "Palestinian" of you. However, I am all for voting with one's feet -- you know, backing up words with action. So I expect you are busy packing in order to move to Gaza, right? Or are you just another in a very long line of ersatz "Palestinian" hypocrites? You have no idea how good you had it in the days before the ersatz "Palestine" Authority dismantled everything that the Jews did for you in the West Bank. No appreciation. Just endless whining. I think if you're going to complain, you should do so from Gaza. That would at least lend you some credibility. Of course you do realize that you will not be permitted to re-enter Israel. So temper your valor with a little bit of discretion and ask yourself this: do you really, truly want to live under Hamas rule? If the answer is "no" -- then shut your mouth. If the answer is "yes" -- start packing, bubbeleh.
35. does al zahar know that er.. he has something on his nose
does Al zahar know? ,   IL   (05.23.11)
maybe they should pass him a tissue
36. Let's revert to the Mandate Lines
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.23.11)
before the British lopped of 72% of Israel and gave it to Jordan
37. I have a great Idea
Chaim ,   Arad   (05.23.11)
Let us discuss the boundaries that HaShem gave Avraham. Now that we can talk.
38. There is no "historical Palestine" it never was a country
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (05.23.11)
39. Hams and the borders
Robert Nagy ,   Budapest Hungary   (05.23.11)
Hamasa is correct, instead of looking at the 1948 borders let's look at border over 5,000 years ago.
40. 26
birdi ,   israel   (05.23.11)
ROFL. Talula you are in great form today. Thanks for the many laughs. Kudos.
41. Hamas: Let's discuss 1948 lines
Edmond Silber ,   Montreal, Canada   (05.23.11)
Then why not return to the 1922 lines before England gave 2/3 of Palestine to a so called "King" without Kingdom ?
42. Hamas' accidental truth.
Joe ,   new york, n. y.   (05.23.11)
The terror-monger points out accurately that the west bank represents just five per cent of historic Palestine, and that Israel comprises 22 per cent. So where is the remaining 73 per cent? In the hands of his Arab brothers in Trans--I mean Jordan. He wants land for his terrorist state? Let him take it up with King Abdullah.
43. #26--Sarah you are absolutely correct !!
Don Rosenberg ,   Palatine USA   (05.23.11)
I agree with you 100%. but I believe the saudis are using the threat of oil stoppage over the US and Europe. I would recommend taking over the oil fields of arabia, which we built ,if necessary. Then the arabs might have to work. Also, this would stop some of the money going to terrorists which arabia supports.
44. mohamid al-zohar 1948 lines?
Wondering   (05.23.11)
Is your statement prior to May ,15 , 1948 Shabat Eve the labnainai Attacked from the north, syrian (afaz) Attacking south east, jordan's (husain) saudi's Attacking from the east and eygpt Attacking from the south eilat region. So mohamid were throwing rocks back then at the future IDF? From the looks of your face you must have been involved in some kind of explosion, lots frag marks on your face? Just Wondering? No To Any Agreement with a TERRORIST Organization like hamas. You Just Don't get do you? Just Wondering Yella?
45. #6
Ariel ,   São Paulo - Brazil   (05.23.11)
Perfect the most brilliant think I have seen. I wiil reproduce it to everyone...
46. Worlds Fairs
seth bullock ,   south dakota   (05.23.11)
If you went to a World's Fair in the 1st half of the 20th century and found the "Palestine" display, you would see it was the Jewish display. The Arabs of the time were called Arabs. They didn't call themselves Palestinians until it became a political and military hammer against the Jews. Further, when Egypt held Gaza and Jordan held the West Bank, they were not considered occupiers. Why not?
47. Times is running...
Amir ,   Dusseldorf, germany   (05.23.11)
Time is on palestinian side. USA is getting weaker and weaker as world power. We would do good to reconcile with palestinians, before it's too late. I'm sure most 'Israelis' will leave, a.s.a. the first real threat becomes eminent. And this will andoubtedly happen soon.
48. Lieberman VS Zahar
Max ,   Germany   (05.23.11)
I'm not the same opinion like Al-Zahar but why you are upset about his opinion?? A lot of the jews are saying the same ... "There are no palis ... all land is us and the arabs should go to Jordan" Allways look at things from both sites.
49. Dream #17
Israel is for Jews   (05.23.11)
50. Peace process?
Shalom ,   U.S.A.   (05.23.11)
To talk or listen to this people is a waste of time.
51. Israel must
Ken Evans ,   Goose Island USA   (05.23.11)
Israel must keep its Borders because it is best for Defence of the Jewish Nation. I once saw a cat drag something out of an alley that looked very much like this guy.
52. Jordan is 80% of historic Palestine.
naro ,   nyc   (05.23.11)
Palestinians should be resettled in Jordan which is the vast majority of Palestine province.
53. Enough is Enough: Pal State Bid a Failure
ZAL ,   US   (05.23.11)
By their own actions and words the Palestinian/Arabs have failed THEMSELVES and the world at large. Not only do they not deserve statehood, they have PROVEN they can't even operate the simplest civil organizations without repression, fraud and theft. They're a complete failure as a people and should be absorbed back into the peninsula where they came from. The 'peace process' with the pals is over for good. It's just never going to work out: they're thugs through and through and have a mentality that is an in inconceivable failure for this world and humanity...by their own choice. Never before has humanity been faced with trying to create a peaceful means to secure a nation from scratch for a people so unworthy. It's time to make preparations for their departure from Israel or simply take the land away bit by bit until theyre all gone to other countries. It's been a circus. Shame on the arab/ pals for what they've put the Jews, the Arabs and the world through. Shame on every single one of them.
54. #9 abdel, #25 kevin
solomon ,   bklyn   (05.23.11)
#9- Thank you for being rational and forward looking. You add some reality to these discussions. #25- You, on the other hand, are totally unrealistic. Not only are we speaking of 'whose land it is, who was here first'. We also speak of murderous actions in the past, both immediate past and not-so-immediate. To think that the 'righteousness of killing Jews' will simply disappear is irresponsible to say the least. The arab side must prove itself. Would you let a serial killer walk free on the killer's 'promise' to be good?
55. to#47 amir
Marcelo ,   Berlin / DE   (05.23.11)
sure, sure...as it was the case in 1948 (5 armies against), 1967 (four armies), 1973 (three armies) and so on...you are indeed the only thread in the world since you were invented in 1964. You will get something, Jordan and then you will have to leave europe :-)
56. The appearance of this Neanderthal man
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (05.23.11)
is the impersonation of Hussein Obamas pro Arab speeches...GIVE ME A BREAK..!
57. Hamas
Phil ,   London, UK   (05.23.11)
Lets not talk about anything. Hamas will never be part of a serious negotiating team so talk of 1947,48 or 67 is irrelevant. Thats not my opinion it is theirs.
58. how about compensation for the jewish refugees kicked out of
rachel ,   usa   (05.23.11)
Arab countries ?
59. Taqiya Rules!
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville, USA   (05.23.11)
How can you trust a religion that teaches you that it is just fine for their followers to lie in Allah's name to achieve their Islamic goals? Simply put, you can't believe or trust a single word they say.
60. #27 - still, the point of #1 remains....
William ,   Israel   (05.23.11)
who needs another one in this world? No one.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article