Opinion
Land of Israel is ours
Miri Regev
Published: 24.05.11, 00:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
31. #27 Delusional thinking
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (05.24.11)
If you think that the ethnic cleansing of 750.000 Palestinina Arabs in 1948 can be reproduced again in the future, but now involving millions of Palestinians from the occupied territories and even from within the 1949 armistic lines, who are put on trucks and dumped across the border without resistance, you are simply delusional. Not only will the Palestinians fight to the death, even within Israel many Jews will refuse. It will tear the whole Zionist state apart. Israel will be then another crusader state in the Arab world until the next Salahedding al-Ayyoubi comes along and will throw you out. On top of that Europe and even the USA will put so much pressure on Israel that it will become impossible. I am amazed at your rightwing delusions. The scenario that Regev paints is the one state solution by default. The Palestinian Arabs, like the blacks in the United States and the blacks in South Africa will struggle for equal rights and they will win and defeat the chauvinist zionist ideology.
32. What a great idea!
Avi ,   NYC, USA   (05.24.11)
Why didn't we all think of this great idea to tell the Goyim that Eretz Israel is ours, since the days of the Bible? Now that we will tell them this simple truth our problems will disappear, or at least reduce markedly, won't they? So simple! Is there something in the drinking water of Kiryat Gat, where the writer grew up, that increases IQ? Can we all get a sip?
33. #24 Alofs, do you actually believe the tripe you write?
Phil ,   Ireland   (05.24.11)
You are comments are so out of touch with reality that they should be prefaced "A Walt Disney Production". Do you listen to what is preached about Jews in mosques? Can you not read what Hamas want to do to Jews? Islam only knows one type of democracy - to be able to vote in people who bring about Sharia Law. I have heard this for myself in a discussion about democracy on the British Islam Channel. What rights would Christians and Jews have under the only type of "democracy" Islam accepts? Wake up Alofs and live in the real world, not your (not too well hidden) fascist right wing ideological world.
34. #29 Mikesailor, what are you on about?
Phil ,   Ireland   (05.24.11)
You accuse Jewish nationalism of wanting an ideological and racial purge of both Arabs and those who do not agree with its "fascist vision". The Hamas Charter calls for extermination of Jews by Muslims but this seems to be left wing liberalism to you since you don't condemn that. Will you take the time to condemn such right-wing rants by this so called "democratically elected government" of Gaza? Or will you just condemn Israelis who refuse to accept such ideology?
35. on #2, MP
joel ,   usa   (05.25.11)
you should know better that the PM Netanyahu was speaking before the republican majority US congress, ok?
36. Sarah at #19
Cameron ,   USA   (05.25.11)
Really? She can give me military commands any ole time.
37. A question of trust
Fairness4All ,   London, UK   (05.25.11)
How can anyone trust Bibbi when he says: (Now) The 1967 borders are indefensible (A few months ago) Recognized the 1967 borders with agreed swaps was a fair starting point (NOW) He cannot negotiate with the PA now that it includes Hammas (A few months ago) Cannot negotiate with PA as they are a nation divided Israel and Bibbi are not serious about peace, they hope to drag it out for as long as possible so more settlers can steal more Palestinian land.
38. #37 What fairness?
Phil ,   Ireland   (05.25.11)
You call yourself "Fairness4All" but then accuse Jewish settlers of stealing Palestinian land. Under the British Mandate Article 6, Jews are legally entitled to settle in Mandate Palestine west of the Jordan River. This right is protected by Article 80 of the UN Charter. The only legally binding UN Resolution on Israel (UNSCR 242) never mentions Palestinian Territories or a Palestinain people, so how can Jewish settlers be "stealing" Palestinian land? Have you read the Hamas Charter which openly calls for the killing of Jews in Article 7? Is this fair? Is it fair that the PA unite with Hamas without any objection to said Charter? If you truly want to see peace between Israel and the Palestinians, and "fairness for all", then at least acknowledge the anti-Semitic stance of the Palestinians. At least acknowledge the refusal of the Arabs to negotiate peace instead of war.
39. Thank God he didn't use this
Mack ,   Boston   (05.29.11)
Mrs. Regev you need a speech writer, your accent is in the speech, your lack of knowledge of the English language, history and biased content renders this no better than a 6th grade project, and a grade of C for close, but not close enough. Thank providence no content of this was used.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article