Israelis, soldiers clash in Nablus
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 30.05.11, 08:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. Riotera ...... not Worshipers.
Salma ,   Palestine   (05.30.11)
why don't you move "Joseph's Tomb" to Tel Aviv ?!
2. Salma
Dudi ,   Jerusalem   (05.30.11)
Why don't you move "Palestine" to Jordan?
3. danger
sharon ,   Israel   (05.30.11)
Why right do these idiots have to endanger our soldiers and police because of their idiocy? When is somebody going to throw them in jail or in a hole somewhere!!!
4. reckless indeed. risking soldiers lives for this stupidity
Joe   (05.30.11)
such things cost more than their stupidity. The IDF is right to sanction them
5. Leftist Propagandist Edomites Cheat Israel Of Her History
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (05.30.11)
In 72 C.E., after the great Roman desecration of 70 C.E., the Roman Emperor Vespasian, ethnically cleansing Israel of all things Jewish, renamed this existing Jewish city "Flavia Neapolis." The city remained Neapolis until 636 C.E. when it was finally Arabized to Nablus. The original city was שְׁכֶם (Sh'khem, corrupted to Shechem), between the mountains where Israel was commanded to read the blessings and the curses from the Torah every year. It's treasonous for Edomite Leftist "Jews" to be a partner of the misojudaic Arab propaganda machine. Then to call Jews visiting our historical city of Sh'khem "illegal" "infiltrators," while the army supposedly of the tradition of King David's Army is embarrassed to be seen there "in broad daylight," where Jews should be required to behave like Dracula, not to be seen after dawn, is doubly treasonous. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-observant Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Discrete Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, they have refused to post it. Find our reply in our Web Café at
6. When Jews behave like Arabs
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (05.30.11)
Arrest them all. Throw the book at them. You can't outlaw stupidity, but you can make people pay for their stupid actions.
7. Re: 1
Yisro ,   Australia   (05.30.11)
Hey Salma, Why don't you move "Palestine" to Jordan?
8. Not even........
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (05.30.11)
Not even one fingernail of one soldier should be endangered because of the crass stupidity and irresponsibility of these idiotic people.
9. "Reckless behavior"-not removing the threat threatens you
Kerwood Derby ,   Frostbite Falls, MN   (05.30.11)
Reckless behavior is allowing a PM of an elected party to implement the plan of the opposition by tyranical decree, disenfranchise the elctorate and order the so-called defense forces to destroy the lives of ~10000 Jews and 22 Torah learning centers. Reckless behavior is accepting such evil decrees and destroying the lives that they are suppose to defend er than removing the threat. Even Moshe Dayan refused the order that Rabin accepted from Ben Gurion to mass murder those survivors of the Holocauset who came on the Altalena to defend the land of their own name. Reckless behavior is when the no one says bupkus after the PM of an elceted party creates a new party and maintains the PM office without the benefit of the new party having even been in an election much less win it and then another PM (Olmert) cotninues to order atrocities against the people he serves that the so called defense organization accepts and proceeds to do unspeakable things to women and children, fingering them and smaing skulls and breaking limbs even of MK's who ast least try to protect the electorate. Reckless behavior is now having as chief fo the so-called defense forces one who without question delivers the iron fist to those who love the land of their own name and he and his civilian leaders serve ostensibly, yet seek to destroy instead of the threat that should have its right return enforced back to the homicidal, Hamite peninsular homeland fotheir own name.
10. Not Israelis in any way
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (05.30.11)
They behave like Arab terrorists. The same way as there is no such thing as the Palestinian people, these are not Israelis.
11. #6
Larry ,   Or Yehuda   (05.30.11)
Or send them to Palestine, which is Jordan
12. Haredim, just get a job
Ron ,   Israel   (05.30.11)
13. #9
IZL   (05.30.11)
I have never heard the part of Dayan refusing the orders. I did not know he even part of the picture. I knew about Rabin and Gurion. Where did you hear/read or know about this? Even though Dayan was Labour? I always admired him. If what you say is true I have gained even greater respect for everything he has done.
14. #3 who are the idiots?
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (05.30.11)
Are the Zionists worse than Israel's leaders like Sharon, Olmert and Barak? These idiots ethnically cleansed Gush Katif and surrendered Philadelphi to Hamas. Thanks to them, Gilad Shalit (an Israeli solider) has disappeared and another almost 300 have died. Thanks to them, Israel will have massive civilian casualties in the next war. As Avi Bnayahu said "we know how to tell a family their soldier died, but how do we tell a soldier his family died?"
15. #5 Paqid
Logic ,   Israel   (05.30.11)
Are you for or against anarchy?
16. Settlers are breaking the agreement!
Westbanker ,   West Bank   (05.30.11)
By entering Nablus city which is fully controlled be PA....the Palestinian police should kick them out!
17. Oh dear, the monster they's created turns on their master!
Avi ,   Tel Aviva...   (05.30.11)
The Zionist project will implode in time..
18. Joseph's tomb. Desecrated by Jews!
Spencer ,   Israel   (05.30.11)
All that these idiotic so-called religious Jews are doing apart from endangering the lives of our soldiers, is giving fuel to israel's enemies. They should be arrested and thrown into jail. Truely religious people uphold the law of the land.
19. #2 & # 7
Salma ,   Palestine   (05.30.11)
the answer to your question is in your question. because it is Palestine and it is Jordan.
20. arab palestine is a myth
meir ,   haifa   (05.30.11)
all in the name Arabs =Arabia Jews = Judea also know as west bank of the river yarden of we all go back to where we are from = peace
21. religious clash with army
moron ,   galut   (05.30.11)
at least they did not kill anybody just because they were ''having a bad hair day'' like arabs..they forget it is only because of the army that jews are not in exile still or worse..the attack on jewish sovereignty over holy sites is part of arab war on the State..therefore jewish access is vital
22. So the Jews have to worship like thieves
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (05.30.11)
in the night at a Jewish Holy site which was overrun by Muslims. Is this a glimpse of things to come at the Western Wall.A country that has no pride in it';s Holy sites and historical sites will cease to exist.
23. Joseph's tomb is turning out to be a disaster
Ravino   (05.30.11)
These fanatics are behaving like arabs ; savages, rioters, lawless. The IDF, the law and order, our leaders; well , this is another story, and not a pretty one at that
24. #13-srce for Moshe the refusnik
Kerwood Derby ,   Frostbite Falls, MN   (05.30.11)
Altalena Israel, 1994, 53 minutes, color/b&w English and Hebrew with English subtitles Directed by Ilana Tsur
25. Moshe Dayan: Also the man who gave "Temple Mt." to Arabs!
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (05.30.11)
26. #20
SAM ,   ME   (05.30.11)
LOL...What a simplistic world view you have there!!! How about Canaanites, Phoenicians, Romans, Copts, Barbers, Assyrians, Babylonians, etc... To say that all the people who speak Arabic today are from Arabia is statistically impossible.
27. #13-there were others who refused the evil decrees too
Kerwood Derby ,   Frostbite Falls, MN   (05.30.11)
In reviewing the tape I see that 8 from 33rd battalion of the Alexandroni brigade refused to fight another Jew. One named Yarimi was court martialed and sentenced to two weeks in prison and his head shaved.
28. Israel should have full control over Joseph's tomb.
Bless Israel ,   USA   (05.30.11)
Why does Israel allow her enemy to hold guard over such a religious site? Seems to me the pals should be the ones stealing away in the night, not religious Jews who come to pray. Would one Jew be allowed into Mecca? I don't think so. Still, the law should be followed while it is the law.
29. idiots
shoshan levi ,   kiryat arba   (05.30.11)
although i strongly believe that the tomb of yosef should be ours, these people should behave in accordance with the militray and not put these soldiers lives at risk. furthermore, by behaving in this manner, it is no different than the behaviour of our supposed enemies. when the time is right it will be ours!!!!!!!!!
30. 19
birdi ,   israel   (05.30.11)
talking in circles is what you do best salami.
Next talkbacks
Back to article