News
Iran cleric: Killing Israeli children OK
Dudi Cohen
Published: 31.05.11, 02:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
219 Talkbacks for this article
61. # 11
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (05.31.11)
Dear Luiz Felipe! I am sure that your intentions are good. But the history teaches us, that when such an evil country is arising, the world should not turn its back and count on diplomacy only. I am sure that I don't have to remind you about all the diplomatic efforts before the WWII erupted, all the treaties that were signed, and as you know, it didn't help at all.
62. You believe this?
John Smith ,   London   (05.31.11)
This is absolute rubbish. Anyone can validate this newspiece by simply visiting the website of Mesbah Yazdi: www.mesbahyazdi.org. There is no such nonsense. I can't believe how many people fall for this silly propaganda inciting racial hatred between two nations (just look at all the talkbacks)..
63. To: Judge Haddad at No. 11
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.31.11)
Revulsion isn't the half of it -- but what can expect of a country that tossed its own boys under the wheels of Iraqi tanks? Sanctity for human life is not an Iranian strong point. But I say, if so much as one deluded fanatical Moslem takes this idiot's words to heart, and straps on a suicide vest and attempts to attack an Israeli target -- whether the attack succeeds or is thwarted, Iran must be made to pay, and pay dearly. Blow up their oil terminals; shut down their economy. Just for starters.
64. 31 starting with u idiot albi!
which OUR rabbis? ,   il   (05.31.11)
are u jewish? What do u mean by OUR rabbis
65. Playing victims??????
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (05.31.11)
Who are the one in USA that play victims? "Discrimination because with are hispanics", "He cheated me because I am hispanic". If you like the ayatollah, remember he is going to put you in the death row because you drink cerveza corona.
66. Could do it without leaving armchair? Words are fine,but
Jim Jones ,   USA   (05.31.11)
But actions must speak louder than words..If the US is so able,then why have they not put foot forward instead of SUT-UPPING, Appeasing.. by only soft words ..doing ZILCH. You tell me that shlomo..
67. Could do it without leaving armchair? Words are fine,but
Jim Jones ,   USA   (05.31.11)
But actions must speak louder than words..If the US is so able,then why have they not put foot forward instead of SUT-UPPING, Appeasing.. by only soft words ..doing ZILCH. You tell me that shlomo..
68. 8, 31, 43, 60
Deebo_ ,   Holon   (05.31.11)
Rabbi Ovadia Yosef has a history of controversial remarks and he regularly receives condemnation from every respectable Jewish organization. Although he has NEVER condoned murder. For Iran, Hamas, et al. killing Jews is part of their official policy. Do you see where the difference lies?
69. Ahmadinejad loves all
calm ,   Iran   (05.31.11)
"who is known as President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s spiritual mentor" maybe it is not bad for you to know that this mentor recently said I'm 90% sure that Ahmadinejad is under spell! he is not Ahmadinejad's supporter but Khamenei's supporter. our problem in Iran is not Ahmadinejad, our problem is Khamenei with all his clerics and revolutionary gaurds. I'm sure Ahmadinejad himself never wants even one jew being killed.
70. While I Agree with all of you,wonder how the Iranian Jews
JOSHUA ,   IL   (05.31.11)
Iranian Jews still live there,and free to worship in theie synagogues. I am curious.can anyone enlighten me on this subject.. I'd be mch obliged for any replies Thanks
71. Saed I Jew.. As if the countries would dare...They bend back
Richard ,   in DC   (05.31.11)
They bend backwards to appease them all because of their depedance OF THE OIL. Expect no reaction what ever. Think thar Germany is one of its customers ..Take it from there and you'll get the gist of it.
72. killing of childrem permited
trainman6 ,   ontario canada   (05.31.11)
This once again shows the deparvity of these so called clarics, to encourage the killing of innocent children is beyond my comprehention. you sir Ayatollah Mohammad Taghi Mesbah are a very sick man and are possessed by a demon and led by Belzibud himself prince of all demons.One day the muslim people will wake up to this type of poison and embrace a true religion of peace and not Islam one that respects people.
73. Similar Edicts have come from Zionist Rabbis
Jeff, Ex-Marine ,   San Diego, US   (05.31.11)
Let's not forget that Rabbis have issued similar statements calling for the murder of Palestinian children. The stench of hypocrisy emanating from these talkbalks is overwhelming. Israelis are in no position to lecture Iran or any other state on civilized behavior
74. Salafi Shaykh Abi-Ishaq al-Huwayni may differ
traintalk ,   upcountry, israel   (05.31.11)
He says - Go on jihadist raids a few times a year, and bring back prisoners, including women and children, which can be sold in the market like groceries to bring in extra income when times are tough...Multiply each head by 300 dirhams, or 300 dinar. In Egypt! http://translating-jihad.blogspot.com/2011/05/egyptian-shaykh-jihad-is-solution-to.html
75. Come here! I'll kill you slowly over 20 years in my basement
Yaniv ,   Israel   (05.31.11)
76. to # 70, JOSHUA
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (05.31.11)
The reason why Iranian Jews can continue to warship in their synagogues is in the scenario that Ayatollahs wrote for their country to follow. Jews aren't free in Iran. They can't leave Iran and travel for studies or business. They are not revolting only because their numbers are very small, and they can be easily eliminated under many pretexts Islam is holding against them. You can easily check how many Jews and other minorities are living in Iran.
77. #73 Jeff, prove it, or are you another liar?
JMK ,   NYC   (05.31.11)
78. #73 only questions
Eli ,   Yerushalayim   (05.31.11)
From where got you your "knowledge"? Can you let me know one source at least (The Protocols of the Elders of Zion?)? What would be your civilization without Judaism (Tanach)? What about your hypocrisy? ... and Jews killed kids for the matzot bakery, right?
79. #73
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (05.31.11)
give one example. You can't. You FAIL
80. to no.8
Jennie ,   IsraelUS   (05.31.11)
You have been drinking too much tequila, juan...Stop halucinating...Never in the history of Judaism such a thing had or would ever happen...You can't prove your stupid lie..Fact is:while they are killing us, we are saving their lives...Did you know that, moron ?
81. Clearly not a "true" Muslim
Carl ,   USA   (05.31.11)
We have been told that Muslims are forbidden to kill and are, in fact, the most peaceful of people. Therefore, this Islamic cleric must not be a true Muslim and his followers are apostates. Oh, also all the other imams who scream murder of "infidels" from their mosques and the civilian Arab leadership that names streets, buildings and public squares after the most monstrous terrorists. But this isn't Islam...
82. why insert islam
chahrazed ,   barbaria .algeria   (05.31.11)
islam did not command us to kill civilian people ,our prophet mohamed "sala allaho alayhi wa salam" has forbidden killing the monks ,women,children ,elderly and unarmed paople in the war whatever their religion and not to burn trees . so my lovely cousin do not talk of things you don't understand.
83. #73 The only stench is you killing innocents in Afghanistan.
(05.31.11)
84. to ##81 & 82.
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (05.31.11)
I agree with you 100%. Islam is religion of peace. It's just not clear for everyone who reads Qur'an. The old and new Testaments also have controversial messages. But people who follow the old books learned to deal with it. Followers of Islam didn't yet. What bothers me is your ignorance about the multiple atrocities, murders and threats of terrorism from the quite numerous groups of Islamic fundamentalists who don't read the same suras of Qur'an as you. Why don't you condemn those who murder, who sacrifice and mutilate their own women and children in the name of Islam? Or maybe you believe its a norm in the modern society? Maybe our definition of PEACE doesn't as yours? Explain, please, yours. And try to explain why there are so much blood must be spilled for the name of Allah.
85. Juan is a Liar
Hal ,   Jasper, Alabama, USA   (05.31.11)
Claiming something doesn't make it true. Show me a single instance of an Israeli slashing the throat of a toddler, or an infant.
86. #73 Jeff, the phony ex-marine
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.31.11)
I have repeatedly asked you what your MOS was, every real Marine had one, you never saw a day of service in your miserable cowardly life As for the alleged incitement by the Rabbi''s, it's time to put up or shove it in your rearmost orifice I have learned something new, shit pretends to be a Marine and knows how to type
87. #1 Sarah B. Now Do You Understand
Wondering   (05.31.11)
that the little bearded monkey and ALL their henchman, don't deserve to breath the same Air as You and I? Just Wondering?
88. Propaganda
Goy to the World ,   U.S.A   (05.31.11)
The only reason this story was printed was to justify hate. Now all of you regular people can say whatever racist things come to mind without guilt. They do the same thing when Ovadia Yosef spews this type of dribble. I spend a lot of time debating racists that bring up ole Yosef. It's sad you guys are susceptible to the same propaganda. Chosen my ass! Even this goy can see through it.
89. Whatever you do, Israel...
Nancy Cohen ,   Sydney, Australia   (05.31.11)
Just sit back and wait for them to attack you. Play nice now! You want everyone to like you, right? So just sit back and don't hit.
90. Rabbi Ovadia Yosef
Zvi Zaks ,   San Jose, USA   (05.31.11)
Rabbi Ovadia Yosef did indeed make remarks as insane as Ayatolla Mesbah. The difference is that Bibi rejected Ovadia's remarks, whereas Acmadinijad seems to consider Mesbah his spiritual mentor.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article