News
IDF: Protesters caused their own deaths
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 06.06.11, 13:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
31. #20 Tim from Brighton
Daniel ,   Brighton, E Sussex   (06.06.11)
Are you from Brighton in East Sussex, UK ?
32. #22 Brian Cohen , NOT TRUE.
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.06.11)
You know very well that 99 % of Palestinians who worked in "Israel" are not copies of Amjad Awwad, they did not hurt your children. that was one example for you. Mr. Cohen, do not let your absolute hatred of us make you lie.
33. #26 You are either kidding.
Talula ,   Israel   (06.06.11)
Or you are from another planet.
34. #33 NoTalula , I'm not kidding
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.06.11)
Most of the Arab wars with "Israel" were FAKE wars.....any way, you're free to believe what you want.
35. The Red Cross is in the pay of the Arabs!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.06.11)
The Red Cross was bought by the Germans and now is enhancing its position in the Neo-Nazi Arab world!
36. SALMA - what do you have to say about #14's TB
Talula ,   Israel   (06.06.11)
Do you disagree that this is what is written in your holy book, the Qur'an?
37. # 32. Salma if were all not careful
Tim ,   Brighton   (06.06.11)
We will all end up sounding like some demented record sounding the same old rhetoric the same old tired positions..on and on and on... So we all fail yet another generation of Israelis and Palestinians Where a Palestinian child I was introduced to cried when he was told I was Jewish and an Jewish child at a fancy dress party cried when he saw someone dressed as Lawrence of Arabia If only we could give some talkback time for genuine constructive ideas, highlight the many areas of cooperation and mutual interest, our common ideas....Perhaps Salma you and I could give it a try sometime
38. SELF INFLICTED, AGAIN
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (06.06.11)
As with most incidents the self inflicted nature of the Palestinian problems becomes evident. We read this phrase in the article: "Syria claims 23 protesters were killed on the border and 350 injured," Which means it can't be trusted as accurate, so we'll never know the real numbers, if they were treated in Syria. Like Pallywood among the Palestinians, The Photo Fraud in Lebanon, the Arab press simply cannot be trusted to tell the truth, like the boy who cried wolf. Nobody believes proven liars. In Gaza Hamas shoots so many rockets some always end up landing in Gaza, and they kill their own people. That's what happened here, the Palestinians threw firebombs, which set off the landmines, which I would bet my house, is what caused most of the deaths and wounded. Basically they killed and injured themselves, what fools. That's what blind hatred does, the Arabs and Palestinians are guilty of it, so they paid the price. With their shear stupidity they hurt themselves. Now they want to use that to elicit sympathy. But nobody believes them, the normal person looks at these guys and knows it's just a staged PR stunt, and don't care. Well not exactly, we just don't want anybody fooled by this phony, premeditated BS.
39. WHY NOT SUE THEM[bbc][cnn][ski] FOR LIBELING
TO # 10 ,   israel   (06.06.11)
FOR LIBELING WE HAVE ALL THE PROOF
40. #37 you are right , Tim
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.06.11)
but our colleagues here do not help at all : (
41. #18 Carey: A Canadian calling the Golan "Occupied"
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.06.11)
What about the "occupation" of the lands of the Aboriginal peoples of North America - Canada, the USA and Mexico? Before 1492 there were NO "Europeans" on the North American Continent! The indigenous peoples were massacred, put into reservations and forced into servitude so please, get your own house in order and have a good look at the plight of your own before you side with those who over and over drove the Jews out of their home - the Babylonians, the Romans, the Crusaders and the Turks! And remember, if you are not too blinded by hate, that Islam goes back to the 7the Century AD or BCE. Mohamed never came to Jerusalem and Muslims turn their back on Jerusalem when they pray facing Mecca. Jews go back in this area 4,000 years! Proof? Go to Hebron and visit the tombs of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and their wives! I don't think that our dear departed forefathers and their wives were brought from Europe 4,000 years ago to be buried in a non existing Palestine! You may also note that in Jordan their is a grave on a hill call Jebel Haroun which is the garve of Moses' brother. Aron! So, Carey, who was here first and as for your peaceful thing please tell me where you have ever seen "peaceful protest" by Muslims? No doubt the bombing in Pakistan, 9/11, 7/7, Bali, Madrid, Jersualem, Haifa, Tel Aviv and so many more were peaceful! As for War Crime, well the only war crime is the kidnapping and illegal detention of Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit, who is even denied visits by the Red Cross by your heroes, Hamas!
42. RUSSIAN ROULETTE????????
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (06.06.11)
Wow, $1000.00 bucks to play Russian Roulette, I'll pass, thanks anyway, we have Vegas for a reason, and you don't have to bet your life for a grand. If true, and that is a BIG "if" how desperate can you get. Assad figures hey 1000 people will cost him $1 million bucks for diverting attention from him, good deal!! Try buying advertising on every major network, heck it would cost a lot more than a million bucks. I hope these guys got there money up front. Plus $10K for each person shot and killed, life is cheap there I guess. Even Saddam paid $25K for each Pal killed during the intifada. I'll tell you what, have you ever seen such cynicism in your life?
43. good morning
boker tov Eliahu ,   israel   (06.06.11)
44. #39: They don't care!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.06.11)
Look at the Antisemitic remarks on SKYNews' web site Comments and the expressions of the faces of their anchors, like Kaye Burley, when they report on the Israeli "aggression". When Israelis get killed, they don't report it, or the put it down to "serves you right Israel". Their news editors find pro-Israel news "not newsworthy"! Dead Arab kids who heal miraculously when the cameras are turn off cuase great sadnees on SKYNews but who care about real dead Israel children like the Vogels and their parents? I say stop their reporters going to press conferences. They can all all the information they need from the Government Press Office. The next time Dominec Waghorn doesn't report objectively, chuck him off the credited reporters list! Yes, Israel does have a heavy hand but our survival is at stake and this is what our friends in the USA, Europe, Australia and the very few in New Zealand don't seem to understand! They rather appease and prefer not to upset the Goyim! The Arabs use Facebook and Twitter to further their cause and hatred. Jews use them to prattle on and post nonsense. How can we win if we don't take the initiative?
45. S-A-L-M-A!!! I'm waiting for your response!!!
Talula ,   Israel   (06.06.11)
She always disappears when she can't answer something - how very convenient!
46. Is the IDF filming the action?
StevieT ,   USA   (06.06.11)
If they are not, it amounts to gross negligence.
47. Protestors causing own deaths......
DT ,   TA Israel   (06.06.11)
Situation normal ! No doubt most of the casualties were inflicked by their own so they could get the international Israel hating media to fully go along with it.
48. #ali abadan
Vivian Clayborn ,   Copenhagen, Denmark   (06.06.11)
Yes Ali, you are right, but both political as well as religous, leaders of the Muslims/Islam have chosen to ignore it.
49. it must have been symbolic cease fire, for
observer ,   Egypt   (06.06.11)
the Syrians' struggle was unarmed one. SYMBOLIC.
50. #14 Qura'an never refers to Bani Israel as Jews
observer ,   Egypt   (06.06.11)
Islam is never about race or ethnicity, so Qura'an never called Muslims Bani Ishmael. Strictly, Quraan never called Bani Israel (children of Israel) Jews. when asked them to enter the Holy land, Moses's people "Bani Israel" said to him: there were giant people in the land ( Sura 17:104) and in the next verse "they didn't enter the land", in another Sura; "Moses's people said to him; go with your God to fight, but here we stay". We made, as punishment, Bani Israel dispersed in the planet earth till the Last Day (Judgment Day) when we them to Our Judgment (Sura 17:104)
51. Salma #15, #32, #34
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.06.11)
Follow your own advice (#32): "do not let your absolute hatred of us [Jews, Israelis] make you lie". All wars were started by the arabs. All wars were won by Israel. This is includes 1967. Period. And you are following your own advice in that ".....anyway, you're free to believe what you want. " (#33). Even though you know it is patently not true.
52. The BBC have them on their conscience
Wanda ,   Italy   (06.06.11)
What other reason have these "peaceful protesters" than showing the world how bad Israel is? They know exactly how the flotilla incident and similar are reported in most European media (not only on BBC); so it's their new tactic to provoke Israel only because they know that BBC & Co will not condemn the border stormers, but Israel, as usual. So the biased European media have the deaths on their conscience. And I mean that very seriously.
53. #34 Fake wars where Arabs were still humiliated.
(06.06.11)
54. To number 50 Bani Israel is the
(06.06.11)
Children of Israel the 12 tribes which we the Jews are part of. We are call Jews because we are named after Judea (Judah) one of the children of Jacob(Israel), Bani Israel is the Israelites. What you are saying of punishement doesnt exclude the land promised by G.D the Bani Israel.
55. Good for those Syrian hooligans!
Harry Wright ,   UK   (06.06.11)
They went looking for their deaths. When you try to force your way into somebody's home you can get killed. They are nothing but hired hooligans on Assad's payroll. They were conceived, born and raised in Syria. That is where they belong.
56. #50 Which Qura'an have you been reading
Ali ,   Abadan   (06.06.11)
There are many mistakes in your post and your interpretation of Suras is completely erroneous. Only you use it because it suits you. This is blasphemy. Shame. Respect the Qura'an. Even Kaffir #54 knows better than you.
57. #56 - must be the Koran not sanctioned by Al-Qaeda
William ,   Israel   (06.06.11)
you know, the one that ignores the so-called peaceful religion stuff and focuses only on the "make everything Islam and kill those who oppose, especially the Jews which they're commanded to exterminate from the Earth" There are several Muslim scholars (a couple Egyptian, one Italian) that also support the existence of Israel under the Koranic Suras cited. And there are many others who have a tough time with Islam because of the massive contradictions inside it. You can tell who they are because they're the ones with fatwas on their heads.
58. Naksa? Nah. More like,....
Gideon Reader ,   USA   (06.06.11)
Idiotarian Dumbass Day. Maybe they can squeeze this into a regular feature on the first of April, each year. Seems made for this kind of thing.
59. #18 - if this isn't the border...
William ,   Israel   (06.06.11)
then why is there a border fence and the UN separating both sides? Anyone with a bit of sense would see this situation and know free travel in the area is not permissible. If they want to take their chances, especially after being warned many times, they hold the responsibility for the outcome. I wonder though - Carey - if a mass of Africans were to flood across the border of Western Sahara (the State) with ill-intent, would that be ok because its considered "occupied" by Morocco? Tibet is legally occupied by China, so too it would be permissible for hundreds of thousands of Indians to flood the border from Dharmsala, right? Just trying to see how deep your biased logic goes.
60. #58. Naksa= Day of Defeat for Arabs and V-Day for Israelis.
Harry Wright ,   UK   (06.06.11)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article