News
UN 'deeply troubled' by Golan killing
AFP
Published: 07.06.11, 18:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
101 Talkbacks for this article
31. Don't tell us how we shall defend ourselves.
(06.07.11)
UN is joke and an imbarassment.
32. Do not participate in another Goldstone report
Rachel ,   US   (06.07.11)
The UN does not have 2 words for the Syrian massacres but condemn Israel. Tell the UN to go to ....
33. Israel Needs To Dump The U.N.
Edward ,   Savannah, USA   (06.07.11)
Israel needs to just pull out of the U.N.!!! There is no reason or advantage for staying there and by pulling out, it can determine its' OWN destiny and tell the rest of the world where to get off. THEN, it would NO LONGER be bound by nor have to put up with all of their Anti-Israel B.S.!!!
34. DISGUSTING Navi Pillay will retire a very rich woman indeed.
Harry Wright ,   UK   (06.07.11)
I am sure she is very generously rewarded by her ME clients for championing their causes against Israel. I have noticed that most of her statements are about Israel - maybe this should read "exclusively" about Israel. Anybody saw any statement from her about Assad's criminal ruthlessness in dealing with his people? Maybe if I surf the net I'll find one because there ought to be lots since this is definitely a major Human Rights issue. There is a HUGE disparity between Syrian authorities ruthlessly murdering almost 2,000 Syrian civilians and 23 foreign invaders loosing their lives as Israel protects its borders from invasion. Actually about half that number since some of them died at their own hands when they themselves detonated the minefield. Navi is evil personified, like Assad, Nasrallah, Mashaal, the devils over in Iran etc. Oh! How could I forget to make dishonourable mention of Erdogan
35. joke
david ,   panama   (06.07.11)
you can not call "protesters" those who cut the fence!! Those are invaders!!
36. Ethiopia is Key for Israel's stability
EthioJegna ,   Addis Ababa Ethiopia   (06.07.11)
We control the source of the Nile River which we use as leverage to control Sudan and Egypt. The Eritrean refugees that are flooding into Israel is a result of Eritrea's dictatorship and forced slavery of its people. Somalia is a threat to Israel too as they are involved in hijacking vessels and supplies to Israel. The only partner you have in the region is ETHIOPIA~!
37. Deeply troubled, eh?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.07.11)
I wonder how she feels about the ongoing massacre of Christians and Animists in Dharfur. Or about tribal violence in the Congo -- six million dead in five years. Neither did she opine about the deeply troubling situation in Sierra Leone and the Ivory Coast. Or Somalia. Or Zimbabwe. Or Libya. Or Jordan. Or Iran. But a handful of dead Syrian protesters -- that's deeply troubling. Assad has been butchering his own people for several months now, but that does not appear to trouble her. The United Nations should be dismantled.
38. Pillay
Roy ,   USA   (06.07.11)
What a useful idiot she is! More ignorant and devoid of any sense than most of the UN travesties!
39. She’s right. Shoulda let the mob
Stephen in New York   (06.07.11)
take over the whole country. Wouldn’t that be tolerant?
40. Border Violations
Andy ,   Canada   (06.07.11)
Nice for Ms. Pillay to equivocate between Syria encouraging a protest at Israel's border, allowing its citizens (maybe even paying them) to enter a Syrian-laid minefield and then breach the border fence--and Israel defending the integrity of its borders. Would Ms. Pillay use force to prevent someone from breaking into her house?
41. To: The Bald Scotsman at No. 23
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.07.11)
National Brotherhood Week, by Tom Lehrer.
42. PILLAY MAKING A FOOL OF HERSELF
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (06.07.11)
Israel wanted trouble on its border like it needed a hole in its head.The UN is making a fool of itself and it is embarrassing to witness.
43. Pillay
Lippy ,   Proud Israeli   (06.07.11)
Don't tell us another stupid and hypocritical South African like her landsleit Goldstone is telling Israel how to behave? How come she isn't back home attempting to solve her country's and that of it's neighbours problems?
44. It is true, Navi Pillay is deeply troubled.
Ypip ,   Canada   (06.07.11)
45. Syrians taking Assad to ICC for killings
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (06.07.11)
Where is her concern while "Syrian and international human rights groups urged the world's top war crimes prosecutor on Tuesday to investigate the killing of more than 1,000 civilians during protests against Syrian President Bashar Assad. " (Ynet report today)
46. Syrian border-bashing
R Blum   (06.07.11)
The correct terms must be used to portray the reality. These are self-professed genocidal border-bashers, not mere "protesters returning to their bucolic villages." If they are being paid by the Syrian gov't $100, & the families of the dead $10,000, this is financial incitement to commit genocide of the Jewish minority of the State of Israel. Obviously, this is to deflect media attention away from current Syrian suppression of its own people, but that is not the main point to be made. The main point is that the int'l media is misrepresenting what is actually occuring, & that the Arab hoardes storming Israel's borders are not democracy-seekers, but genocidaires.
47. She's Out of Her Mind
Douglas Fireman ,   Chicago, USA   (06.07.11)
This woman is another one of those antisemites who seem not to give a damn about the thousands of unarmed protestors who are being killed in Syria by the Assad government. Where is her 'verbal' condemnation for Assad's atrocities? Israel has every right to defend its borders and will continue to do so even though it may mean death to anyone foolish enough to try to invade a sovereign state. These folks have been warned many times of the consequences for trying to breech the borders of Israel. Hopefully they realize that they are totally responsible for their actions.
48. The UN must be dissolved!
Frank ,   USA   (06.07.11)
49. Is This Ignorant Fugly Women
Wondering   (06.07.11)
related to helen thomas? She is Just as Ignorant and almost as ugly? What do you think ? Just Wondering?
50. how to avoid bad press
doro ,   Germany   (06.07.11)
just wanted to know, if there is a way of handling this situation w/o getting these pics. I mean people that illegally cross a foreign border is a violation against a sovereign state - it is totally understandable that Israel is protecting its borders like it does. But I would like to know, if the IDF could also control the crowds by teargas, rubber bullets or also capture everyone, imprison them and sent them back...? Still I really see the measures also now that they take 24 killed against 70 people killed by Syria itself in their demonstrations...
51. Navi Pillay Syria is at war with Israel!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.07.11)
So is Lebanon!. Therefore any encroachment on Israel's border by either belligerent is an act of hostility and had to be viewed as such by Israel. Further, Madam, any sovereign country has the right under international law to defend its border. The hostiles who approached Israel's border were not at all "peaceful". Peaceful protest does NOT include the throwing of rocks at Israeli soldiers. Many an Israeli soldier has been seriously injured, paralyzed or even killed by "peaceful rock throwing Arabs"! Many don't realize that you are a South African and you were the first "non-White Woman" to be appointed to the High Court Bench in the post-Apartheid era. Madam, I too was born in South Africa and lived under the oppressive Nationalist Regime for 40 years and I am fully aware of the antagonism of the South African Colored, Indian and Black people against Israel due to Israel's cooperation with South Africa on military matter. Some report indicate that hostility against Israel has turn to blatant Anti-Semitism in South Africa and it seem that South Africans of Color have forgotten how many Jews, like the Late Helen Susman, fought Apartheid! By your actions you spit on their memory and that of my father who died fighting Apartheid and championing the rights and human right of the victims of Pass Laws, the brutality of the South African Police and the injustices of the regime! Therefore I accuse you of total bias against Israel. You have seen fit to condemn Israel over and over but have miserably failed in your task by not condemning the Hamas bombing of Israelis in Sderot and the Negev settlements. You have done nothing to secure the release of Gilad Shalit, kidnapped by Hamas almost 5 years ago from Israel and held incommunicado and without any access to the International Red Cross. Madam, you disgrace the high office that you hold and I hope that others like myself will expose you true anti-Israel bias. This matter will not rest until the world knows that you are totally unfit to hold the position of UN High Commissioner for Human Rights as it appears that Jews are not human in your book!
52. Yes, Judge Pillay is South African anti anti-Israel
David ,   Karmiel, Isrsel   (06.07.11)
But YnetNews has no seen fit to publish my Talkback on UN High Commissioner Chief Navi Pillay! I have posted my TB again which points out her hatred against Israel because Israel cooperated in arms development with the Apartheid regime in South Africa. Pillay has forgotten the Jewish South Africans who opposed the cruel and inhuman regime. Believe me, I lived under it for 40 years! I hope YnetNews will still publish my TB as I do not intend to let this matter rest!
53. #29: Actually the USA, the UK and France are to blame!
Israeli ,   Israel   (06.07.11)
They did NOT force the UN to enforce Security Council Resolution 1701 after the end of the Second Lebanon War which called for the disarming of Hezbollah and restricting Hezbollah to North of the Litani River!
54. This creature of the useless nations...
Adam ,   Golan Heights Israel   (06.07.11)
...gives "evil" new meaning.
55. The United Nations, a true joke!
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (06.07.11)
56. there's no precedence on how to deal with such a thing
(06.07.11)
since no country in the world ever had to handle a mass attempt to cross a border. If the UN has a better way to deal with such a thing, please, speak up. otherwise, accept that what they did was the ONLY way to deal with it.
57. Syrian Border demo.
Ruben Jacobi ,   Altrincham. U.K.   (06.07.11)
Can Madam UN HR boss explain why only Israel defending its country is the only one to use exesive force. her words for Syria seemed to be an afterthought.
58. Hilarious but sad.
Maurice ,   Montreal   (06.07.11)
Enough siad.
59. the UN should seek psycholigical counseling for its troubles
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.07.11)
maybe it could straighten out some things and start being an arbiter of truth and decency. nah, this is the UN we're talking about.
60. Israel ''deeply troubled'' by UN hypocrisy & bias.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (06.07.11)
Ah, the old ''disproportionate response'' BS. Maybe we should shower the rioters who attempt to invade our country with rose petals? I think, however, we could be more creative in methods of crowd control. I would fill tanker trucks with excrement (merde, alors!) and use high-pressure hoses to blast the rioters. I think it would be very effective. Of course, then the UN would accuse us of copying their own tactic - BS.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article