Culture  Art&Culture
'Spock' calls for Jerusalem's division
News agencies
Published: 09.06.11, 08:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
145 Talkbacks for this article
31. scotty beam this retard up please
(06.09.11)
32. Former stars
Jarda ,   Czech Republic   (06.09.11)
are often moony. For example Gene Simmons.
33. EVEN Israel's Nationalist Prime Minister....
m ,   diaspora   (06.09.11)
Doesn't that sum up Mr Spock's 'orientiation'?!. All PM's and Presidents and heads of state SHOULD BE 'Nationalistic''--shouldnt they? Unless you are biased against Israel and think they should care more about someone else. Why is he commenting about Israel's leadership and not the terrorists that they are supposed to negotiate with?
34. lol he take meteorite shower.
ghostq   (06.09.11)
got hit his head preaty badly.
35. to #28 and #14 you r officially Nerds.
ghostq   (06.09.11)
36. Waht Nemoy misses is that the ME is not Star Trek
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (06.09.11)
What Nimoy has not realized is that the situation is not like the Star Trek episode he cites. In it both sides hated and wanted to destroy the other. In the Israel/Palestine fight Israel has agreed to the 2 states for 2 peoples model with some Arabs living in Israel, while the Palestinians still insist on a Jew free Palestine and a 2 states for our people mentality. Until they are willing to accept Israel's right to exist at all let alone as the homeland of the Jewish people, there can be no peace.
37. "Thank you" Mr. Nemoy for Peace Now Offer.
Yoav ,   Germany   (06.09.11)
But Mr. Nemoy you have no even idea how the ME work and to give advices to the Jews which face every day the danger of agression which comes out from arab moslems. Here is the best solution to achieve "peace" in the ME. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIEeiDjdUuU P.S. Mr. Nemoy "thank you" that you show us how many of selfhating jews do we have. Shame on you!
38. Will boycott nimoy
John cone ,   USA   (06.09.11)
I use to like nimoy as Spock but no more am taking the last star trek movie we were going to see today and dumping it. When did this man ever help or speak out against israel hatred and anti Semites or help real Jewish causes.
39. To Mr. Spock
JDL ,   USA   (06.09.11)
I grew up watching the original Star Trek series and I am still a big fan. It is not logical for you to speak about something you nothing about. Divide Jerusalem? I don't think so. We know what Jordan did to the Jewish relics when they had control over the area and would not allow Jews to pray at the western wall also. Stop spewing your leftist liberal bull and start standing up for your people. What a disappointment you are!
40. build the palis land called palestin in your back yard
sheldon lee cooper   (06.09.11)
and we solved the problem! oh, right, there is a place called palestin in the US... so they can all go and live there. obama would love the idea. more voters for the "islamocratic" party.
41. Israel offered this already. Arabs rejected it
Golan ,   Modiin   (06.09.11)
Barak and Olmert offered to divide Jerusalem (against the will an common sense of the Israeli people) only to have their offer be rejected by the Arabs. Will people like Nimoy then offer or demand that Israel take on millions of hostile Arabs trained in terrorist camps in Lebanon, Syria, and Gaza? War is a fact of life. You cannot appease Fascist ideologies of the Baathist of Islamist kind (or any other kind) If they arabs wanted a state they could have had it a long time ago.
42. Dividamos Washington
dori lustron ,   israel   (06.09.11)
Yo quisiera saber por que no pide dividir Washington....divida su pais, no el mio....nadie pidio su opinion y no vive aca, por lo que esta descalificado para opinar....devuelva Nuevo Mexico o California a los mexicanos ...pero no opine sobre nuestro pais porque solo hace daƱo
43. Spock forgot the Prime Directive
Sarek ,   Vulcan   (06.09.11)
Don't interfere with someone else's cultural development no matter how good your intentions. The real Spock would know that. This must be the evil mirror Spock. It's the only logical conclusion.
44. Spock
Jason Alster ,   zichron yacov israel   (06.09.11)
Spock also played Gold Meyer's husband. Yes to two state solution, but unlike what Israel says the two states should include donations from other vast Arab countries bordering to both Israel and Palestine to make them viable. the Ottoman Empire map has to be re-drawn. It's realy very simple. It is amazing that Israel does not propose this. I wonder why?
45. ears
nosson tzvi ,   J-M   (06.09.11)
I'm sure that Mike Tyson was Spaced out when he bit off the tops of Nemoy's ears.
46. Spock
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (06.09.11)
Why is his comment important to be in this news?
47. Who asked you?
Bless israel. ,   United States   (06.09.11)
It's easy to make decisions for a land thousands of miles away from you. Unfortunately, he's typical of many Jews who neither live in Israel or, sadly for them, don't even live as Jews. They've divorced themselves from their heritage and reality by thinking nothing of endangering their fellow Israeli Jews and ignore the 'Terrorists' Hamas organization and their desire for not only E. Jerusalem, which is categorized by the US government as "Terrorists" ( that aint gonna happen folks) but, ALL of Israel. What an idiot, is he knowingly or unknowingly being used as a useful idiot by the pals or, is he just a plain old fashioned garden variety idiot?He's going opposite of US official policy.
48. Your right, he's no Jew!
Bless israel. ,   United States   (06.09.11)
49. Nemoy the Nimrod.
bless israel. ,   united States   (06.09.11)
50. you are immoral outside and inside!
shame on spock ,   israel   (06.09.11)
51. Mr Spock should listen to his own advice & use logic
zionist forever   (06.09.11)
Forgetting the importance of Jerusalem for a moment I would love to know how you can practically have one city as the capital of two states. First you need to consider freedom of movement and security. If the city is going to be an open city then how are we going to stop terrorists or illegals coming from the palestinian side of Jerusalem with a bomb, walk into the Israeli half of the city and then get the first bus to Tel Aviv where he blows himself up? There is no way Israel can control its border if its an open city. The other option is a city thats physically divided which means barriers and checkpoints all over the city which will make everyday life a nightmare. Who do you pay your municipal taxes to? Mr Abdullah & Mr Cohen live round the corner from each other but legally in different countries who do they pay municipal tax to if its diifferent countries but same city? What happens to business? I assume the palestinian state will be using its own currency which will of course be worth less than the Shekel. If you have one city as the capital of two states then its going to mean all businesses will need to mark up everything in both currencies which means the complications of tracking exchange rates. It will also mean that the palestinian currency needs to be just as much an official currency in Israel as the Shekel so people don't find their paycheck is only useful in one part of Jerusalem. Will post codes be affected? If I am writing a letter from abroad will it matter if I wrote Jerusalem, Israel or Jerusalem, Palestine?. Who pays for public transport? The Jerusalem light rail will go through areas which would be in the palestiinian state as well as Israel so would we be able to demand the palestiians state contribute towards its upkeep because they use the service. Who is going to decide about events that take place in the city? On Yom Hatzmaut will certain neighborhoods be out of bounds for celebrating because Yom Hatzmaut will always be nakba day for the arabs and they wont want flag waving in their neighborhoods. If parts of the city are off limits then its not an open city. The light raili construction has been a fiasco.... if we had been sharing responibility for the city could the palestinians have decided they want the project canceled because its causing to much disruption can they force Israel to kill the project? Law enforcement... I imagine both countries will have different laws so what happens if you do something thats perfectly legal in one country but illegal in the other? Also who decides where criminals stand trial? If somebody robs a house in Silwan will I face a different legal system to if they rob a house in Katamon? That doesn't even include the Old City. The arab plan is Israel is allowed to keep the Jewish Quarter and they get the rest. Visitors will have to exit by the same gate they entered to make sure they don't end up in the wrong country. Rules like that don't exactly make the place very tourist friendly. Dividing the city might be a great victory for the palestinian politicians but both Jews and arabs who live and work in Jerusalem will suffer as a result. Its a shame Mr Spock doesn't use more of that famous logic of his.
52. Nimoy's support Jerusalem division
Theo Ghefner ,   Toronto Canada   (06.09.11)
He better stick to Vulcan politics, Jerusalem is not his specialty area.
53. Yes But What Is Rue McClanahan's Position?
M. Duvduvani ,   Yokneam, Israel   (06.09.11)
Now that we know what Leonard Nimoy thinks, I would also like to know Rue McClanahan, Susan Blakely and Morry Amsterdam's position on E. Jerusalem before I form my own.
54. Not that crazy
Barry ,   Boston   (06.09.11)
After the 1967 war the boundaries of East Jersualem were extended to encompass a lot of territory. Clearly giving up any part of the Old City would be a terrible mistake. But giving up some of the outlying areas of East Jerusalem would not be a bad idea. This would leave fewer Palestinians within the city boundaries and would meet the Palestinian demand for a capital in Jerusalem.
55. Just plain sad
David ,   Israel   (06.09.11)
It's sad seeing this old man pitching this re-hashed garbage. Do us all a favor and move to Miami and take up shuffle board.
56. Spock and Peace Now
Benjamin ,   Greenville   (06.09.11)
It is time to beam spock back to the enterprise and set a course for another galaxy.
57. This must be his human side interfering with his logic
Scott ,   Haifa   (06.09.11)
58. #43
Scott ,   Haifa   (06.09.11)
It's not the "Mirror/Mirror" Spock, he has no goatee. Maybe one of the Palestinians or Hamas, did the body/soul switch-a-roo and we are actually hearing Hamas talking through him to fool us. Or maybe he is having "Pon-Farr" syndrome right now?
59. Beam him up Scotty
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (06.09.11)
He's a Vulcan, not of this earth; send him home of his father Why does every has been actor feel it necessary to take a political position, they were not known as great thinkers, they just had the ability to read lines that others had written for them In other words, a parrot in human form, in his case with larger ears, like Obama, though a bit more pointy
60. Spock and the Pagans
Brod ,   USA   (06.09.11)
These elements pretend to be Jews. But they do not know the GOD of Israel and the Land of Israel. The fact is Israel means the followers of the GOD of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Those who do not know the GOD of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob or the GOD of Israel are not true Jews. They are Pagans. These Pagans should stop intruding in the internal affairs of Israel. Israel should not allow these Pagans contaminating its nation.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article