News
Settler says shot Palestinian in self-defense
Yair Altman
Published: 16.06.11, 00:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Sure looks like self-defense
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (06.16.11)
Arabs seem to believe that they are free to attack Jews without any sort of defense. My only question is why either of the terrorists are still alive?
2. Give him a medal
Joel Busner ,   Galilee Israel   (06.16.11)
To all good Jews: Stop supporting phony right wing governments. This type of discrimination against a good Jew is typical of the weak policy.
3. That "Settler" should replace the current Defense Minister.
Great Job!   (06.16.11)
4. If one comes to slay you - slay him first..
Arthur ,   SF, Ca   (06.16.11)
Jewish hero should be commended for fulfilling a mitzvah
5. A rock is a deadly weapon. The only difference between me
Yaniv ,   Israel   (06.16.11)
and this so-called settler is that I would've fired off my gun without a second hesitation as soon as the Arab raised the rock. I have no legal obligation to turn by back to him and try to run away from violence. I think it's better to confront evil head on.
6. Settler protects himself
Mike guthrie ,   Seal beach usa   (06.16.11)
Why was this young man arrested for stopping two palestinians who were trying to murder him?
7. Only in Israel is self defense considered a crime
uzitiger ,   Ramat Gan   (06.16.11)
The police are nothing more than a leftist weapon against Jews.
8. Sad situation
John Phee ,   Sydney, AUSTRALIA   (06.16.11)
First, the Police should be commended for their work. Irrespective of the circumstance etc, the shooter needed to be identified. Second, bringing before the courts is what the Police should do. Third, the video is reasonably clear in what happened & self defense will be the reason for the shooting. No jury will convict him nor on the evidence provided so far should they. What was the Arab thinking when he appears to attack the Israeli, robbery, murder either one justifies self defense. What a waste of a human life.
9. Correct title: An Arab was shot while trying to kill a Jew.
its their culture!   (06.16.11)
10. Good News. Jews are starting to defend themselves !
Enough is enough   (06.16.11)
11. It's a tragedy.
Michael ,   California, USA   (06.16.11)
He clearly shoots in self defense. The two locals are approaching him and are seen lifting a stone or stones. He had no choice once they started chasing him. The tragedy lies in his presence where he was clearly at risk. If he was where he was not supposed or allowed to be, then he should be prosecuted for that, but he is innocent for shooting in self defense.
12. Settler turned the tables
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (06.16.11)
Defended himself and shot the fellow that wanted to kill him Let's just call it "An exchange of missiles"
13. Clearly self defense, heroic act
Mike ,   TA   (06.16.11)
The man bravely defended himself against an armed and hostile Arab. Kol ha kavod!
14. travesty
sablegsd ,   Omaha, USA   (06.16.11)
The man should never have been arrested. Clearly self defense.
15. Settler guilty?
Mark Rosen ,   Boston   (06.16.11)
This settler is guilty as the day light we see him in unless..... #1 here in the states we have concealed weapons laws as to registered or unregistered weapons. Who approaches anyone holding a weapon, a hand gun at that as we can see this was not a rifle. The deceased approached this Israeli settler with a rock, a rock not knowing, he the settler had a weapon you can bet. Several laws were broken here numerous enough to count and name in reference to the crime of homicide. Use of an unregistered concealed weapon in the commission of a crime, the crime of homicide regardless of a self-defense plea. If the laws of the land stipulate the settler is licensed to carry a concealed weapon we have self-defense case against one threatening bodily harm. A 26yr. old man afraid to turn himself in in a Self-Defense, also the time that elapsed form the crime till now. Iraq Burin is Palestinian, what was this settler doing in a Palestinian village with a gun as stated, said settler is from Alon Shvut did he go there looking for trouble if so now we have premeditated murder throw in the gun charges this mans goose is pretty much cooked. So young the players that die without the blessing of wisdom in this dispensation period.
16. Self Defense
Negev ,   Canada   (06.16.11)
I think that anyone would have shot a person running after them in such a fashion. That palestinian could have pulled out a knife for all he knows! Why in the world would you RUN at a soldier that is armed?! Any soldier from any government or country would have shot a man dead for running at him in such a crazed matter! Forget the conflict between israelies and palestinians! This is something that you simply don't do!
17. yes it looks like self defense .....they were attacking him
rachel ,   usa   (06.16.11)
18. He was definitely not looking for trouble.
Lemmings Hotline ,   sd usa   (06.16.11)
19. Clearly self defence
john   (06.16.11)
20. agree with 1 2 and 3
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (06.16.11)
what else is there to say except we need more people like him running the country.
21. 100% Self-Defense
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (06.16.11)
Open and shut. This guy never should have been arrested in the first place- and neither should anyone else who shoots what is clearly an Arab terrorist.
22. The other attacking terrorist shall go to jail
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv   (06.16.11)
and not him.
23. Guilty of self-defense, live in peace at home.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (06.16.11)
24. let the enemy know: you attack us, you die.
dante ,   uk   (06.16.11)
these are not "protesters"; these are enemies who aim to destroy Israeli authority and, in that, way subvert Israel. let the enemy know that Israel has no intention of surrendering to them or of allowing them to subvert the security of the people. let them know that if they want to live in peace, they will be protected but if they lift a hand against Israel, they will be destroyed.
25. Jews are denied the right of self defense
jason white ,   afula, israel   (06.16.11)
If there was no security camera there, then this guy would be spending a long time in prison. The government discourages Jews from fighting back and are ready to have both the police and prosecutors go after those that do. All Jews should be allowed to carry firearms if they do not have criminal and or mental problems. Every city, town and village where Jews live should have firing ranges that are affordable and ammo that is also affordable. Multiple weapons licenses should also be made available and also let people purchase rifles and shot guns. Anyone stealing a weapon or ammo or using it in the commission of a crime should get a 20 years prison sentence with no parole. Having an illegal firearm should also carry a 20 year prison sentence.
26. THIS WAS SELF-DEFENSE !!!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.16.11)
Really nothing more to say about...
27. He should have reported it to the police himself
Ilan ,   Ariel   (06.16.11)
While it is true that the police and prosecutor's office do not act justly with these cases the proper thing is still to report the case at the time it happens.It is a testament to the systematic bias of the court system that the majority of Israelis have zero faith in the authorities.
28. Stop using the term "Settler"
Mike ,   Jerusalem   (06.16.11)
A "settler" from Alon Shvut with an apartment in Jerusalem?? Just an excuse for YNET to use the word settler. STOP using the term "settler" already! He was an Israeli Jewish citizen traveling in Samaria who was attacked by Arabs and defended himself. Period.
29. #28 = RIGHT !!! The mindless use of the
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.16.11)
propaganda term "settler" is directed against the Jewish citizens of Israel...STOP IT...!!!!
30. Israel's Dual Justice System
NormanF ,   USA   (06.16.11)
Eli Assayag deserves to be arrested and imprisoned for interfering with a citizen's basic right of self-defense. The Israeli prosecutor's office is advised not to take the case. The video is open and shut.
Next talkbacks
Back to article