News
Conference to offer alternative to 2-state solution
Ynetnews
Published: 16.06.11, 20:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. Solution: Pay Arabs to leave Judea & Samaria.
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.16.11)
Like virtually all of Israel's problems, the solution to "Palestine" is simple. Pay Arabs to leave Judea and Samaria. Most of them want to leave. Arabs are already leaving Judea and Samaria by the tens of thousands annually, without Israeli compensation. With fair compensation, we could solve the problem in a few years. Judea and Samaria Arabs would get a chance at a new life they crave and Jews maintain our biblical, historic and legal rights to Judea and Samaria, our heartland.
2. Autonomous Region
Essie HaKohane ,   Florida, USA   (06.16.11)
I am surprised the organizer's intentions were not to set up an autonomous region in the area. That concept is not beyond some of the organizers.
3. IT'S ABOUT TIME!!!!!!!
FREEDOM FIGHTER ,   ERETZ-ALL OF IT!   (06.16.11)
4. ying yang
cristian ,   buenos aires arg   (06.16.11)
it is not human but spiritual struggle between the opposites of good and evil,light and darkness,truth and lies,altruism and selfish,love and sex,israel and palestine,jews and arabs,ignorance and wisdom,obedients and transgressors,wolves and lambs,lords and servants that i think it will finish when the karma really comes and if you do or say right you will really receive right and if you do or say wrong you will really receive wrong and the fucking justice for all which never comes,if there is rights of course there is reverse
5. Don't give in to BHO
BH ,   Iowa   (06.16.11)
Don't allow him to sell you out to your enemies in exchange for plattitudes and empty promises. 63 years is a heartbeat in Jewish history. Think for the future. What will the population be in 100 years? In 500 years? You will need Judea and Samaria. Shechem and Hevron shouldn't even be up for discussion. They are more Israel than the coastal plain. Don't repeat the mistakes of appeasement. You are far better off with your heartland and its problems than with surrendering it to enemy control.
6. Bibi turned the tide when confronting Nobel Prize winner
Marco ,   Spain   (06.16.11)
This was a turning point that everyone will realize looking back in 10 years or so. The final outcome: There will be no 23rd Arabs State and 99% of Arabs West of the Jordan river will be transferred to East Jordan, in a society identical to their own. Keeping the 2 peoples so close to each other geographically precludes any other humane solution.
7. Jordan is the answer
Rachel ,   US   (06.16.11)
Turn Jordan into a constitutional monarchy. The king can stay, put will have a Palestinian PM.
8. NO apartheid...
Marco ,   Spain   (06.16.11)
Two people, one state, with one man one vote. Palestinian right of return being a MUST.
9. Judea & samaria IS Israel.What's there to discuss?
tom ,   tel aviv   (06.16.11)
10. Step One
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.16.11)
Formal annexation is coming. Rather soon, actually. The ersatz "Palestinians" can choose between being repatriated to Jordan or moving to Gaza. Prime Minister Netanyahu will go down in history as being more pivotal a leader than David Ben-Gurion (z.l.).
11. #1 Chaim, Israel
Marco ,   Spain   (06.16.11)
Since Jews love money so much, a better solution would be to pay Jews to go back to where ever they came from. This offer should not be limited to the West bank, but to all of Palestine.
12. The right honest direction....
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (06.16.11)
towards true equilibrium, security and eventually peace.
13. THIS IS A GREAT START
EZ ,   USA   (06.16.11)
Let the Pals have Gaza: the rest is ours: always was, always will be. Some areas can be incorporated for the pals in JUDEA and SUMARIA. Enough of this BS with the pals already. It would never work out.
14. That is it...!!! A clear vision and a clear
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.16.11)
direction for what Israel is now and for what it will be in the future. Judea and Samaria was Israels heartland in ancient times and it will be so in the future...! Israels land must be one and it can not be split up.
15. To: No. 8
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.16.11)
The ersatz "Palestinians" will exercise their right of return -- to Jordan. Unless, of course, they prefer Gaza.
16. Glick always smelled rightist to me
Krzysztof ,   Warsaw, Poland   (06.16.11)
now it is clear to me. Takeover of West Bank as "sovereignty over Judea and Samaria". What will be the next step, expulsion of Arabs or what? Or is Mrs Glick willing to give the Israeli citizenship to next 2 millions of Arabs...?
17. #8 Return
Shmuel ,   Miami Beach, USA   (06.16.11)
Lets start by calling refugees only those that meet the standard defination of a refugee, ie. only those that actually fled their homes. Those millions of claimants do not qualify.
18. To: No. 16
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.16.11)
The Arabs living in the West Bank are citizens of Jordan. They will be repatriated; or, they can go to Gaza. But one or another way -- they are going.
19. Judea/Samaria Sovereignty Conference
Joe in LA ,   Los Angeles USA   (06.16.11)
I hope this outstanding conference is put up on YouTube so that it can be watched around the world -- and at the White House!
20. Independence now
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (06.17.11)
The Jewish residents of Judea and Samaria need to declare their independence. Later if we ever get a real leader they might think of joining. The first step is to demand their own independence.
21. To: Shmuel at No. 17
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (06.16.11)
Refugees are forced from their homes, which was not the case with the ersatz "Palestinians." They were voluntary quits, which makes them displaced persons. By stark contrast, the nearly one million Jews who were expelled from Arab and Moslem lands following Israel's victory in the War of Independence were true refugees.
22. GREAT
George S. ,   Washington, USA   (06.17.11)
Great is talking about establishing Judea and Samaria. I am endorsing No.1 of Talkbacks, which is about paying Arabs to leave Judea and Samaria. Keep up the good job. Then peace will reign in Eretz Yisrael, encompassing Israel, Judea, Samaria and Aza (Gaza).
23. Only Apartheid land....
Marco ,   Spain   (06.17.11)
is in Arab countries, all of them Eat your heat out, impersonator!
24. #11 Marco you are so right!
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (06.17.11)
Jews should be given every assistance to return to where they originally came from, which you rightfully say includes the whole land of Palestine. For the record, it's called Israel nowadays. It's wonderful to hear your words of encouragement for Jews to return to Israel! I bet you never expected such praise from a Jewish settler. Goes to show you never know what comes out of someones' mouth, even Balam's ass got that dead weight burden on his back to see he was heading in the wrong direction. I'm sure you must enjoy being compared to such a noble ars like Balam?
25. Easy: Jordans crown prince (ie next king) is Palestinian
Jordan I.S. ,   East Palestine   (06.17.11)
All arabs in Judea and samaria and aza become Israeli residents and Jordanian citizens (or rename Jordan "Palestine", which it was before it ever was called Jordan). meantime Pay to emigrate program launches giving Palestinian families money to emigrate. average palestinian household in 2009 figures made 2-3000 a year. 50 or 100k would be like 25-50 years salary, at once! past polls have shown large %'s of palestinians interested in emigrating for financial compensation. JORDAN IS PALESTINE
26. Ynet - why is mentioning Ezekiel 37 off limits
O V A D Y A H ,   Hales   (06.17.11)
I note several times I have posted something on it ...it never made the talkback...including this one. the religious viewpoint is one of many view points that are pertinant to this discussion...and I submit G-ds viewpoint has a place here.
27. to 1 biblical rights??? historical rights??? wth is that?
ygalg ,   israel   (06.17.11)
can you bring god to the witness stand? there is no such thing biblical nor historical right what we do have is legal right. but not on all territories. if the international laws recognize "to the victorious goes the spoils" especially when it was the one who been attacked...that would add to our advantage... please stop with biblical nonsense you do us disservice.
28.  2-state solution?
Yonatan ,   David"s City   (06.17.11)
dose not exist, ??????????? a 22 state solution dose exist,mmmmmm
29. Finally! This idea is getting some press...thanks YNET!
BJL   (06.17.11)
These are the best and brightest thinkers of Israel. They know there is legal and moral justification for this concept. Yasher koach and kol hakavod!
30. Yesha council traitors
Jordan ,   las vegas   (06.17.11)
Do not listen to these traitors. The yesha council gets all of there money from the israeli government. They were money grubbing prostitutes to selll out the jews from gush catif, what makes you think they wont do the same thing to judea and samaria and jeruesalem? Yesha jews and all loyal jews need to resist on a masssive scale to prevent expulsions. Noam federman and daniella weiss are the true yesha leaders.
Next talkbacks
Back to article