Opinion
Passionate about Jew-hate
Benjamin Weinthal
Published: 25.06.11, 16:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. Nothing new here ..
Elisha ,   The Promised Land   (06.25.11)
2. This is only the tip of the iceberg!
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (06.25.11)
3. #1,#2, You are 100% correct...!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.25.11)
4. Leftists are Jew-haters
BH ,   Iowa   (06.26.11)
groundbreaking study indeed.
5. Nazis were leftists too
elhrac ,   USA   (06.26.11)
National Socialists to be precise.
6. When will you have an article
(06.26.11)
on self-hating Jewish Israeli anti-Semites?
7. weird they following the legacy of Karl Marks
ghostq   (06.26.11)
but they hate jews, anyone see the irony of the maximus stupiditus that delt here, I do.
8. Dead but not alive
Shoshana ,   Helsinki   (06.26.11)
The Leftists approve Jews when they are dead but not when they are alive. Using shoah as the hobby horse has been the favourite tactics of the Left to show the basic depravity of the Western culture, but at the same time the Leftists are quite eager to compare the actions of Israel to that of the Nazi Germany and overlook much worse atrocities and human rights violations in the Islamic countries.
9. Note these are mainly east germans
Sean Green ,   Pasadena, USA   (06.26.11)
The western ones aren't this damned stupid. I blame the soviet education system.
10. #9, Sorry, but you are wrong, the western
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (06.27.11)
ones are equally bad...
11. Israel and Europe
berlonski ,   berlin   (06.27.11)
If you read the current Ynet headlines in the opinion section you can get the impression that Israel's most dangerous enemies are in the West: European politics: Wilders, Israel and the Jews German politics: Passionate about Jew-hate Pollard protest: Don’t boycott America What's going on there?
12. The result of a pro-Israel declaration
berlonski ,   berlin   (06.27.11)
The minority left party in Germany passes a pro-Israel resolution and a minority in this minority party has problems with it. The result is a headline on the Ynet front page that says: German politics: Passionate about Jew-hate Wow!
13. scary
Nilus ,   Schweiz   (06.30.11)
It's scary to see how such a skewed article can make its way into an Israeli newspaper and mislead the Israeli public to believe that anti-Semitism is widespread in the European left. I agree with Berlonski (post 11&12) that there’s a pattern in this, which makes it highly precarious. This isn’t the first article to try and portray the European left as anti-Semitic by consciously blurring the difference criticism of Israel with the hatred of Jews. Most of the article actually deals with activities by members of “Die Linke” that criticize Israel for its policies. Wolfgang Gehrcke’s participation in rallies condemning Israel’s massive bombardment of Lebanon and Gaza are maliciously called “demonstrations in support of the terrorist groups Hamas and Hezbollah”. And since when is it anti-Semitism when somebody supports the right of the Palestinians to also use violent means to defend themselves, a right that Israeli politicians claim on a daily basis? The only claim in the article that deals with an allegedly anti-Jewish action of Erika Zemaitis by voting “against funds to build a new Synagogue in the city of Herford” completely distorted. Erika Zemaitis voted against an additional pledge of 40’000 Euro to cover for costs (due to a miscalculation by those responsible for the project) for the Synagogue for which the city had already spent 205’000 Euro. She justified her vote by saying that the city shouldn’t have to pay for the mistakes of others in a time of austerity where social spending cuts were imposed on the whole city. The only one rightly accused in the article for an anti-Semitic statement was a member of the governing center-right party CDU and he was rightfully dismissed by Chancellor Angela Merkel. That leaves us with zero evidence in the article that “Die Linke” has anything to do with anti-Semitism. What the article rather shows is that the majority of “Die Linke” bowed to the pressure of a massive smear-campaign directed at them from pro-Israeli groups and individuals by voting for that resolution. Rather than supporting anti-Semitism, the members who actually voted against the resolution protested against this relentless campaign (of which this article is part of) of equating criticism of Israel’s policies with anti-Semitism. And rightly so!
Back to article