Jewish Scene
Dutch approve ban on animal slaughter
Reuters
Published: 29.06.11, 07:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
16 Talkbacks for this article
1. No need for Sharia law ....
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome   (06.29.11)
This is a good point,some human made laws Are just pointless,a good training when Islam will try to' impose to' Europe sharia....we will have to' fight against it...
2. Pack your bags
Moshe ,   Jerusalem   (06.29.11)
Jews of Holland time to pack your bags and come home.
3. These "merciful" goyim are more merciful than G-d
C.C.   (06.29.11)
May G-d deal with them in kind. The next thing these "merciful" ones will do, is ban circumcisions.
4. So how long till the Muslims riot?
Israeli ,   Israel   (06.29.11)
5. PvdA
Harald ,   Netherlands   (06.29.11)
This law is even supported by the pro-islam-parties PvdA. and GroenLinks.
6. Good for Aliyah!
David ,   Israel   (06.29.11)
Jeremia 16:16
7. Dutch approve ban on ritual slaughter
Malka ,   Boston, USA   (06.29.11)
I know its the principle, but with functional MRI it probably could be demonstrated the amount of pain an animal experiences. Perhaps that would make Kosher and Hallal slaughter universal. Stunning cannot be a pain free process. Shame, shame.
8. BAN the slaughter of ALL animals
Isrel   (06.29.11)
Cottage cheese is back down in price - no need to eat animals.
9. vos excigeances
Louis Capet ,   Paris, France   (06.29.11)
it would be simpler to stay at home, as opposed to living abroad, so u could kill and eat the way u like it. If it's a problem of "lebensraum" I am sure u can arrange it with the palestiniens!
10. The Point of Kosher Slaughter...
Aharon Cohen ,   U.S.A.   (06.29.11)
... is not the tradition in and of itself. That would be pointless. Judaism was the first civilization to have this as a point of being kind to the animals as well as a health law (whatever you put in you, you become). I for one, am not nervous in the slightest about having a debate over this. If Geert Wilders truly is not anti-semtic, then he and the animal rights activists should gladly welcome a debate. If Kosher slaughtering is truly more humane than stunning, (Which I fully believe it is) then the other side should have no problem in conceding when proven wrong. This is all about 'animals' rights/minimal suffering, right?
11. How humane is "stunning"?
Babishka ,   USA/Mea Shearim   (06.29.11)
Stunning an animal means zapping them with a huge taser. Sometimes it takes more than one electric shock and several minutes of many painful electric shocks before the animal loses consciousness. Can someone please explain how this is more "humane" than instantaneous severing of the carotid artery? Of course it is just less messy and more efficient for the meat industry and has nothing whatever to do with humane animal slaughter. There is nothing humane about administering multiple massive electric shocks, which is the reason the electric chair is no longer used for executions in the United States.
12. New Expression of Anti-Semitism
B. Klein ,   USA   (06.29.11)
The banning of Jewish ritual slaughter is not about banning cruelty to animals. It simply the latest expression of anti-semitism in the west. If you do not let Jews eat kosher meat maybe they will leave the countries they are in? The Europeans hide their anti-semitism behind many masks, anti-zionism, Anti-Israel, anti-kosher ritual slaughter. I guess 60 years ago they forgot to hide their hate for Jews and simply slaughtered them.
13. #9 Monsieur Capet
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (06.29.11)
The guillotine is a much more humane method of execution than the electric chair, as you well know!
14. Conspiracy to Unite Muslims and Jews
Frankie Littlehammer ,   New Herstal, TX, USA   (06.29.11)
It's a conspiracy to bring Jewish people and Muslims together, to show that they have common ground. Maybe that's not a conspiracy but a little help from friends in the start of something beautiful.
15. In Reality
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim   (06.30.11)
B"H In reality kosher slaughtering is the most humane of all - on kosher animals. The anatomy of kosher mammals, and only of kosher mammals, is such that kosher slaughtering cuts off all blood supply immediately to the brain, eliminating all and any suffering within fractions of a second. See: http://thetorahrevolution.blogspot.com/2011/06/only-to-kosher-animals-kosher.html
16. Eat beans instead. They're cheaper & full of protein
Michael ,   London UK   (11.08.11)
Back to article