News
Professors back university that cut anthem
Tomer Velmer
Published: 30.06.11, 13:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
1. LEFTISTS = BUNCH OF TRAITORS
(06.30.11)
2. CAN ANYBODY TELL ME?
Proud Israeli ,   Central Israel   (06.30.11)
What is the source in traditional Biblical Jewish law that requires "democracy" as the system of government?
3. Lame Excuse
Ron ,   OC, US   (06.30.11)
Israel is a Jew state. Period! All concerned must be fired.
4. Israel is delegitimizing itself
Rachel ,   US   (06.30.11)
If you don't stand up for yourself, no one else will.
5. Univ. of Hasan
Observer ,   Israel   (06.30.11)
6. as an Israeli when they told me to sing the Canadian anthem
david ,   vancouver, canada   (06.30.11)
in the university of vancouver i never felt like it hurts me in any way. It's just another attempt to undermine the basic principles of Israel. shame on them...
7. The Enemies From Within
Alain Weinstein ,   France   (06.30.11)
As soon as we turn away, the radical leftist professors will continue to try to undermine Israel and the Jewish people. We have had our fair share of kapos in our history and these are no better. When they are not trying to undermine our national unity, they support anti-Israeli NGOs and the BDS scam. They constantly want to turn away our sacred homeland to those who hate us and wish to destroy us. Lucky for us, their influence has waned in the last few years but we cannot relent.
8. unbelievable.
dan ,   israel   (06.30.11)
maybe we should sing the palestinian anthem so that the arab ISRAELIS would feel more comfortable in OUR GODDAMN COUNTRY!! idiots.
9. haifa U shame on you
daniel mostrel ,   paris   (06.30.11)
what a shame! how can i explain to my chiildren to make aliya with guys so unhappy to be israeli or jew
10. I wonder if they would do it in the USA
Jonny ,   Cape Town   (06.30.11)
I am not sure whether any of these professors have taught or had tenure at US univesities, nor am I sure if the American National Anthem is played at their graduation, but I am SURE that if the above 2 conditions are met, that NON of these professors would dare object, even though there may be some Amercian graduates who do not accept the USA government of representing them in any way.
11. "Offended" by Hatikva?
Menachem ,   Israel   (06.30.11)
Then pack your things and get the hell out of the Jewish nation-state and bring the leftist anti-Zionist crack-pot "professors" with you for free. Israel was, is and will ALWAYS remain the national homeland of the Jewish people no matter what our external and internal enemies want. Enough is enough.
12. #2 proud Israeli
Just a Thought   (06.30.11)
Didn't you know that a "democratic" system of Government is quite in order except for arabs. They have their own system, no matter what!
13. If Israel offends them they should get the hell out!!!
Israeli Jew ,   Israel   (06.30.11)
14. Haifa University
David ,   Haifa, Israel   (06.30.11)
LEFT WING ARAB LOVING SCHOOL!!! shut its doors and stop State funds.
15. crazy
jeremy greene ,   manchester england   (06.30.11)
Wow! I cannot believe that these professors did not want to offend arab students. The arab students that were present in the graduation ceremony, chose to study in Israel and they should be grateful for receiving an excellent education. For this reason alone, these Arab students should stand there in respect of hearing Hatikva. At the end of the day, Israel gave these Arab students the oppotunity to study. Furthermore, I am shocked at how politically correct these academics have attempted in becoming. They have bceome politically correct to the point where it is incorrect and the only thing they are doing is hurting and slowly destroying Israel. Last but not least, i would not be surprised if such people participated in the Nakba and Naksa day celebrations.
16. #12
Proud Israeli ,   Central Israel   (06.30.11)
And so do we! The Bible commands theocracy NOT democracy!
17. Liars & traitors.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (06.30.11)
Just the usual BS double-talk because they got caught, it was publicized, so the creeps are worried someone might lose their cushy over-paid parasitic job. Since I believe in free speech (unlike these lefty retards), they have a right to their creepy opinions but at the same time, as a taxpayer, I don't want to pay for it. They should all be fired - if they have the courage of their convictions, they shouldn't accept a salary from the State.
18. #12 Not true
Menachem ,   Israel   (06.30.11)
It is not news that many Israeli Arabs are hostile towards Israel but nobody including anti-Israel citizens of Israel are above Israeli law.
19. amazed
Maurice ,   Tel Aviv   (06.30.11)
Neville Chamberlain would be proud.
20. #2 - It's in Milkud 22
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Israel   (06.30.11)
same page as electricity, shaving (oops, I mean clipping close), dressing in medieval garb, all-white tzitzit and inability to distinguish between an umbrella and a tent on Shabat.
21. Haifa Univeristy and Hatikva
Les Freud ,   Toronto, Canada   (06.30.11)
They don't want to insult the Arab students by singing the national anthem of the country in which these students hold citizenship? The anthem of the country that infers the same rights upon them as on all other citizens? The anthem of a country that affords them more rights than any Arab country would afford them? Are you KIDDING?
22. ISRAEL'S ENEMIES ARE LAUGHING AT THIS EDUCATED STUPIDITY
stude ham   (06.30.11)
the academics who decided on this absolute nonsense deserve all of the abuse, and possibly more, to which they claim they are being subjected. if you cannot play HATIKVA in your own country then where can the anthem be performed?
23. irrational
Jewish Whale ,   Haifa, Israel   (06.30.11)
How does this offend anyone? "As long as the heart within A Jewish soul still yearns And beyond, toward the east An eye scouts Zion Our hope is not yet missing, The hope of two thousand years, To be a free nation in our land, The land of Zion and Jerusalem." If anything, a Democratic state would play the anthem in a show of pride, representing the people of Israel. This act clearly shows the inferiority of the legal counsel and graduates of Haifa University. If they lack the spine to salute their own flag, how will they defend their clients? Pathetic.
24. They don't have to sing along
Michael ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.30.11)
I am a Jew that grew up in Italy as a kid. I attended public school there, and every morning I would respectfully stand alongside my classmates as they chanted the "Hail Mary." As a Jew, I did not pray along, but I stood up out of respect because I knew that I was living in a culturally Catholic country. On that note, Israel is culturally Jewish. The Arab and Muslim minority here know exactly where they live, and what culture they are living in. The problem here is those "scholars" in the ivory towers of Haifa University who have lost touch of the everyday world that so many of us live thorugh here in Israel... a Jewish world. Regardless if you are Jewish or not.
25. Israelis offended by their anthem?
Antonio ,   Spharad   (06.30.11)
This is familiar for me, sadly familiar. Here in Spain there are two communities that always, for years, are offended when Spanish anthem (or King's photo, or Spanish flag, etc) is performed: Catalonia & Vascongadas (name it as Basque Country is a hard joke). By our experience, DON'T LET IT PROGRESS, CUT THESE ACTS FROM THE FIRST. Anyone who denies his own country has two options: accept the rules and be quiet, or leave the country. The third case is seed of confrontations.
26. ANYTHING JEWISH PEOPLE DO IS OFFENSIVE TO ARABS.. who cares?
SABU TAGE ,   Atlanta USA   (06.30.11)
arabs don't give a hoot for Jewish people....so what, who cares if arabs are offended...? too bad, go take an aspirin.
27. What's next, the flag? language? calendar?
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (06.30.11)
Actually, this *is* the same crowd that is offended that the national flag includes the Jewish star, that schools teach Bible, that the country follows the Jewish calendar. When I lived in Canada, I stood at attention when they played the national anthem even though I was an American. No one says the Arabs have to sing the anthem if it "offends" them (What doesn't* offend them?). But it should be played and they should respect it. "If I am not for myself, who will be for me?" (Hillel)
28. Traitors should be FIRED.
Eli ,   USA   (06.30.11)
Every time I read an article like this I ask if it's even worth making Aliyah. Whats the point in living in Israel if you can't be a proud JEW. Wake up Israel, stop these liberal anarchists from destroying the Jewish soul of Israel.
29. I want names, adresses, social sec. no. fire the lot now!!!!
tom ,   tel aviv   (06.30.11)
30. Not one shekel for Haifa University.
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.30.11)
Haifa University should not receive a single shekel of funding, public or private, till it publicly apologizes for it's disgusting ban on Hatikvah and guarantees nothing similar will ever happen again. Moreover, whoever instated the ban must be immediately fired.
Next talkbacks
Back to article