News
Glenn Beck compares Norway victims to Hitler Youth
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 26.07.11, 07:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
231 Talkbacks for this article
91. Right words and right analogy from Glenn, but wrong time.
Yoav ,   Germany   (07.26.11)
92. Norway &#9
Syrus ,   NZ   (07.26.11)
How smart and how typical of European double talk. The fact that the camp was not all that benevolent space where Socratic principles of CIVILITY and human respect for differences, but a prescribed place where Israel is being demonised, and shown as a pariah to young brains. Elsie #9, you would want to stop at the border of Israel all the peaceful visitors who came to Israel Universities to advance BDS.?! You won't of course, as a person from different country, you have been impressed I am sure of the diversity of Israel discourses. Don't allow yourself to get segwayed from the actual fact: the camp where the HORRIFIC massacre took place was celebrating an anti-Israel Day!! This does not justify the terrible result, but it should force Norway to think through the political ramifications of the event., and not to try and redirect the immensity of the event to other ways.
93. Glenn Beck
Rabbi Moshe Pesach G ,   Yerushalayim, Israel   (07.26.11)
I lived in the Yishuvin of Tekos and Bat Ayin. It is clear to me that the Land was given to Am Yisrael by the Creator, so I make no apologies or have to 'prove' my 'bona fides.' Haaving said that, Glenn Beck is a demagogue and hater and I want him as ally as much as I want that guy in Norway. I will write all who are taking a leading role in Beck's trip here to disavow any connection with this person.
94. Wrong angling
befriend ,   Norway   (07.26.11)
So many people seems to believe that this youth camp was ALL about protesting against Israel and pro-palestine... You don't know ANYTHING folks... this was NOT the main focus at all... It was a camp about MANY, MANY different political issues -- and it was a camp where youth's came together to socialise and 'goof around' with each other and just have fun (as teens like to do)... I don't support the labour party myself ... and I love Israel and the jewish people... It's THEIR land. But I really felt that many comments are completely off-the-mark.
95. Glenn Beck is crazy and drama queen but also usually right
Yaniv ,   Israel   (07.26.11)
96. This is beyond disgraceful even for this
Dovid ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.26.11)
totally disgraceful POS. Israel should not permit him to have this garbage rally here. We should distance ourselves from him. He keeps reaching new lows. Where will it end? Remember- when he minimizes the Holocaust (as he does all the time), he minimizes its victims.
97. nearly 100 comments to prove that the
whowouldavguessedit   (07.26.11)
massacre of nearly 100 Norwegian kids in Norway is indeed actually just another story all about Israelis. Is there any disaster anywhere from Japan to Haiti to New Zealand which isn't really all about Israel?
98. To: No. 94
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.26.11)
For a camp supposedly about many different political issues, the only banner I saw -- and it was a very large banner -- promoted the boycott of Israel. There was not a single banner decrying the violence in Syria. There was not a single banner protesting the ruthless suppression of Kurds in Turkey. There was not a single banner devoted to the singular absence of civil rights in Iran. This "youth camp" (very reminiscent of the Nazi era) was dedicated exclusively to promoting hatred of Israel. The Norwegian Labor party should not be in the business of indoctrinating schoolchildren; yet it is clear that that is precisely what it is doing. Ultimately, if the Norwegian government is looking where to apply blame for the recent tragedy -- it need look no further than itself.
99. Beck is right...
Yossu ,   Canada   (07.26.11)
These kids were indocrinated just as the Hitler Youth were...stop lashing out at him without knowing the facts..those insult him are plain ignorant...see these pics of the 'democratic' kids at the camp...yes, it was wrong to kill them but Beck was right...that camp was like the Hitler youth's: liamgetreu.com
100. glen beck
c. cohan ,   Rehovot Israel   (07.26.11)
WHY NOT LISTEN YOURSELF TO WHAT HE SAID INSTEAD OF DEPENDING ON A NEWS COMENTATOR?
101. GLENN BECK IS DEFAMING NORWAY & iSRAEL
Shira Lev ,   Israel   (07.26.11)
by this poor analogy. I don't agree with the campers myself but he could show some compassion to them. no?
102. to # 60
Rina50 ,   Haifa, Israel   (07.26.11)
It's not a socialism, it's more marsism-islamism.
103. to nr. 5.
cosmopolitan ,   global-municipality   (07.26.11)
i agree with you. glenn beck, the essence of ignorance and conceit, with the us-republican party, the us- tea-party-movement and us-foxnews.com hopely they will not win in the us in 2012. barrack obama and the us-democratic party are the least bad candidates for the next us-elections, i thought.
104. to nr. 9.
cosmopolitan ,   global-municipality   (07.26.11)
i understand and respect your opinion. at my idea the jewish people and the rest of mankind really indeed deserve better.
105. Beck Is Evil And The Israelis Who ......
World Citizen ,   the world   (07.26.11)
Espouse His Ideas Are Evil Too It is sad to see people listening to and believing anything this fool has to say. To see that Bibi & Co. welcomed this dangerous religious kook into your country tells me a lot about how far Israel has fallen.
106. If Norwegians sympathize with hatred and anti-Semitism..
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (07.26.11)
..hatred is what the Norwegians will receive. Now when the Norwegians have experienced an act of terrorism, they maybe will understand who is civilized in the Arab-Israeli conflict and who is not, who is democratic and who is not, who stands for freedom and who does not stand for freedom, who wants peace and who doesn't want peace, and why the wall must stand to separate Israel from the Arabs - precisely to avoid what the Norwegians recently experienced. Sympathy for Norwegians? Did they show Israel any sympathy? These people openly support PA and Hamas - the Trojan Horse of the Arab empire hellbent on Israel's destruction through demographic warfare, boycotts, terrorism, weapons of mass destruction, genocide, conventional warfare, rewriting of history, conquest, colonialism and imperialism.
107. The minds of 13 year old kids
Johan ,   Brusseld   (07.26.11)
The minds of 13 year old kids should not be tampered with by any political ideologues. It's unfortunate given the circumstances but the Hitler Youth analogy also crossed my mind after hearing about the massacre. Even before seeing the display of the anti Israel banner.
108. DON'T GET CARRIED AWAY
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (07.26.11)
I have watched his show, personally I never understood his popularity. He seemed wild and animated with his presentation. He was a conservative and wasn't afraid to take on all kinds of issues. But I agree with the article and the ADL that he seemed to use Hitler and the Holocaust in way that trivialized it. So I wondered how this wild eyed, animated guy could become so popular? But we have a free market system and in the end that's what did him in. So when I hear or read others write how they would have laughed him off the air. He is off the air on TV, and I suspect his radio show will follow. But to be fair I don't believe Beck was advocating or making any excuses for the shooting of kids. His comments were about politics. I even commented about the camp, how my kids go to camp for fun, hiking, canoeing, archery, repelling, games etc., by that remark I don't endorse the shooter, that idea is ridiculous. The shooters Father was a diplomat in the Labor party, same as the camp sponsors. I wonder whether that had any influence on his targeting selection. I didn't know it was a 60 year old event (as stated in the article), so I beginning to wonder more about the shooter and why he picked this target. What shocks me more than Beck. is in Norway you can only get 21 years in jail, no matter what kind of crime you commit? Now that is outrageous.
109. Wrong Norway! #04
Ezra ,   Nice, Fr.   (07.26.11)
The camp was meant to 'goof around' so much that it requires a FM of Norway to add to the "goofiness" by being met with a big sign "Boycott Israel" and a musical of Palestinian flags. Don't get us wrong, Norway is not going to do things to please Israel, or to be just little bit fair, but it cannot hide behind high fullutin "principles" of democracy and good entente between nations, as its deeds show different intent. Don't start a fire and ask a fireman to go with you to search for the pyromaniac. By the way, we also love and admire Norway.
110. You got it exactly backwards, pal #97
Tahl   (07.26.11)
If the whole world wouldn't have been so obsessed with demonizing Israel all the time (as this camp was), we wouldn't have made an issue out of stories like this.
111. WRONG, WRONG AND WRONG
Thomas Korn ,   Valdez, USA   (07.26.11)
How does his outright slander make him "right" Just because they teach about politics does not automaticlly make them "nazis'... grow up
112. To: No. 101
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.26.11)
Compassion? Compassion? These were baby Nazis in the making. Ten, fifteen years from now, they're the ones goose-stepping down Main Street and painting skulls and crossbones and "Achtung Juden" signs on Jewish-owned businesses. No, thank you; I think I will preserve the full measure of my compassion for those who deserve it; these junior Nazis most assuredly do not.
113. To: No. 97
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.26.11)
Did you miss that great big banner calling for the boycott of Israel? We didn't turn this into a story about Israel -- those miserable little neo-Nazi kids did. Some of us are thinking down the road ten or fifteen years and wondering what all that anti-Semitic and anti-Israeli indoctrination would produce in the "campers" and -- well, you know what? Maybe their loss isn't so tragic after all.
114. Rep to Rina... 102
cj ,   Paris france   (07.26.11)
Sadly the line between Socialism and Islamism does not exist . Somehow the Labour party of Europe seem to have been bought by Arab oil money to support Hamas, Al Qaeda and so on. The Lefties in Europe, I canĀ“t speak for Israel or America, are enjoying the tragedy of Norway..It has given them ammunition to speak ill of Jews and Christians... Under the veneer of sadness they are gloating. They see re election coming their way.
115. Norway
michael Pielet ,   boca raton, Israel   (07.26.11)
the Norwegian government, media and churches propagate hatred of israel and the Jews. Beck is not the issue. Hatred of the jewish people in Norway is the issue.
116. Taken out of context
Yaron ,   USA   (07.26.11)
There is no bigger supporter of Israel in the US media than Glenn Beck. He is a hero and a true friend of Israel. It is more than I can say about the 70% of American Jews who voted for this disaster that is currently occupying the White House. While it was likely a bit insensitive to say.....he is one of the brightest minds of our time.
117. LIora 63
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (07.26.11)
It doesn't disrespect the children because it is about the people who are using them and brainwashing them. It in no way cheapens the Holocaust. He makes a point. Don't you think the German kids were probably nice kide until they were brainwashed? What's the difference between German children or the children of any other country when the same tactics are used to influence them? Beck is just pointing this out and you really should be able to see it if you just stop and think about it.
118. Elizibeth 72
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (07.26.11)
Those were not Devorah's words. She was quoting what Mormons believe. Like you she does not believe it. Read it again.
119. redefinition of terms
Nabuquduriuzhur ,   Oregon, USA   (07.26.11)
I find the redefinition of term "right wing" in the media starting around 2000 to mean "national socialist" disturbing. Prior to that, all branches of socialism, from Communism, National Socialism, Parliamentary Socialism, Maoism, International Socialism and so on, were all defined as "left wing." To call Mr. Beck "right wing" and thus national socialist, does not fit as he's not a socialist.
120. #97 Israelis relate stories to Israel--So what?!
David N. ,   Haifa, Israel   (07.26.11)
This is an Israeli newspaper, so relating a story to Israel, especially since Beck connects himself to Israel. Why do you think it odd putting on Israeli-focus? Your concern is concocted and of no moment. Regarding Beck, he is not a well-educated man, and is an entertainer, not a leader or even a serious commentator. Stories about Beck belong with Lohan and Beyonce and Pitt Jolie stories. Most of us in Israel don't know who he is, or care one way or another. I am not sure why he is even coming. Makes me sick.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article