News
High Court orders Migron eviction by 2012
Aviad Glickman
Published: 02.08.11, 15:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. This is amazing.
Dovid ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.02.11)
That it takes this long to remove an illegal outpsot! And these criminals will still probably be there in April. Look at the costs involved in getting rid of these lawbreakers! The settlers are costing us much too much and hurting our nation in every way.
2. Hey Beinish & Barak why don't you destroy ILLEGAL ARAB HOMES
C.C. ,   Yehuda & Shomron   (08.02.11)
and there are tons of them, you racists. Why don't we get rid of these self-appointed judges whose goal is to destroy Israel? Democracy in Israel is nothing but a joke.
3. Why Dovid #1
Abraham Nachmias ,   Petach Tikva IL   (08.02.11)
Dear Dovid, why do you hate so much people who live in Judea and Samaria and defend their land and their ideas? Any special reason for that? Anything in your past? Sounds strange to me how it's possible to hate so much!
4. SHAME ON BIBI AND HIS LEFT WING GOVERNMENT!!!
David ,   Haifa, Israel   (08.02.11)
vote HaIchud Leumi!
5. supreme court is antidemocratic
david ,   new york   (08.02.11)
you know who appoints these judges? -other leftist judges. it is an incredible system where a self appointed unelected elite gets to tell the army what wars they can fight and gives land from jews to their enemies. there is nothing "honorable" about them!
6. 'Living' in tents?... Patriots in Migron
George ,   ashdod   (08.02.11)
Sfard's comment that he is "ashamed of the government's plan to establish a neighborhood of private homes for the residents of Migron while dozens of thousands throughout the country are living in tents"--is completely disingenuous. The people 'living' in tents are people who want to live in a tent. They have an apartment to go to if they want. And many of them are not in the tents anyway. Ashdod has a tent city that usually sits empty except for the couple of hours every night that a few people go there to smoke hookah and sing songs and talk about how bad they have it. The families in Migron heroically built homes there--with the thought of making Israel a safer place to live. They deserve every consideration.
7. @ 2 C.C.
Harmen ,   Leiden, Netherlands   (08.02.11)
You are right! Democracy is only truly democracy if it always leads to the outcome that I prefer. It would be crazy if a democracy or a system of law would lead to outcomes that I personally do not prefer. Come to think of it, it would be best if I can personally appoint and fire the judges, so that I will be certain that they act the way I want. I think that China and North Korea have great experience with such a system of law. C.C., I am with you!
8. Good for Israel!
Ali ,   Sco   (08.02.11)
Its good to see Israel acting responsibly.This brings legitimacy to Israel.No one should be above the law,even the gov'.I feel sorry for the judges that are called traitors for following the law.....Judges should be encouraged not ridiculed.The law is the law.
9. Let's hope that Beinish & her self-appointed radical leftist
(08.02.11)
mobsters, destroyers of Israel, will be loooooong gone by 2012.
10. Who does the land belong to?
VICTOR ,   USA   (08.02.11)
Wouldn't it be cheaper to just pay out to whoever the land belongs to? The state helped build the community, and it looks like there is almost 50 homes there now, plus community center, school, etc. To relocate 50 families to another community is going to be many millions of dollars. Why not just pay the Palestinians who owe the land?
11. OUT! Good riddance
Muayyad ,   Palestine   (08.02.11)
Today Migron, tomorrow Gush Etzion! All settlements are illegal. Read international law.
12. Migron-Migrane headache
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (08.02.11)
13. Muyad Settlements ar not illegal
Yerach ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (08.02.11)
The Hashemites in Jordan/Palestine are illegal!!!!! I suggest you go there but not anwhere west of the Jordan river because it is Jewish!!!!
14. High court of justice?
Yoav ,   Germany   (08.02.11)
Justice for whom? Certainly not for Jews!These judges are playing with fire, they should take care not to be burn to it self. The arabs wouldn´t have merci neither with them nor with their children, they should better not forget it!
15. We Have A Serious Housing Shortage and....
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (08.02.11)
the High Court rules to evict Jews from their homes. We need to build...and they destroy. We need land to develop...and they deny it to us. Bottom line: The High Court does not have the best interests of the Jews in mind. It values extreme left-wing liberal values over the legitimate needs of Jews to live comfortably and flourish in our own homeland. For one, I have little respect for them.
16. # 7 Democracy
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (08.02.11)
Harmen ! The soon to be the majority in your country,will appoint and fire judges,you will go down in flames,carrying high the banner of Democracy and liberty,you and the rest of Europe are tired,and the muslims have the zeal and the vigor to take over,but the muslims will not grant you the freedoms you provide the muslims now,well,life is not fair,China will survive and flourish,because survival takes priority to Democracy,good night Europe.
17. Muyyad
Aicha ,   Maroc   (08.02.11)
You, Barak, Beinish and co. will never see that day. The settlements, I mean "The liberated territories" are here to stay and develop further.
18. Anti-Jew, Anti Human Rights Court Strikes Again
Linda Rivera ,   New York, USA   (08.02.11)
The High Court is surely not unaware of the fact that Palestinian Authority Muslims claim ALL of Israel, as belonging to Muslims. All Palestinian Authority maps show the new state of 'Palestine' covering ALL Israel. PA children are inculcated into a murderous hate of Jews and brainwashed with lies that Israel was stolen from Muslims. Of course, Muslims claim Migron belongs to them. A top Muslim leader in Britain just claimed that Britain does NOT belong to Brits.He said it belongs to Allah. Muslim immigrants believe that Britain does not belong to indigenous Brits; they believe Britain belongs to Muslims.
19. The so-called "palistinians" don't own Migron, but the
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (08.02.11)
traitorous "peace now" provoked the arabs into claiming it was their land and the leftist "supreme" court just gave away Jewish land on undocumented lies. There needs to be a Nuremberg type trial for the so-called "supreme" court.
20. for # 10
shamir ,   brooklyn us   (08.02.11)
the palestinians do not sell their lan they want the settlers to leave and go back to israel
21. Judges Beinish, Naor and Joubran
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (08.02.11)
Isn't it time for out Judges Beinish, Naor and Joubran to be equal minded with the illegal Arab construction? How about firing guns at weddings, they do this, can we? What do Judges Beinish, Naor and Joubran say about equality?
22. And what about the illegal arab buildings in WB?
Jayjay ,   Israel   (08.02.11)
Seems the leftist high court judges have one rule for Jews, and another for the Arabs! Meanwhile, thousands of illegally built Arab homes on land they dont own, and without permits, are being built every month! The hypocrisy if the courts is unbelievable!
23. Destroy illegal Arab homes first
Vlad   (08.02.11)
24. AGAIN!
marlene ,   Philadelphia, USA   (08.03.11)
Again I say the court is SUPREMELESS! Can't they be replaced? By any means? They do SO much harm - like the Biblical sadduces and pharisees!
25. leaving in a quiet and orderly manner
John ,   Alaska   (08.03.11)
The article reads: "The settlers must show responsibility in face of the social and economic situation, and decrease the cost of evacuation by voluntarily leaving in a quiet and orderly manner." The imagery in Mr Oppenheimer's statement is the same as that when the Jews were being moved in a quiet and orderly manner from Western Europe to the camps in Poland.
26. Demolish the illegal settlement now
Haim ,   TA   (08.03.11)
Why wait for more settler thugs to move in. Demolishion should start as soon as possible.
27. #19 Bunnie living on an Native American reservation
Avi ,   Israel   (08.03.11)
Will you be vacating California sometime soon , as quite obvioulsy you are in favor of giving land back to its original owners.
28. #15 Reuven you could always go back home to the USA
Haim ,   TA   (08.03.11)
29. To #20 let's be honest
John ,   Alaska   (08.03.11)
The so-called "palestinian" Arabs won't sell to Jews because doing so is a capital crime. They don't sell to Jews because the Muslims that run their town will kill them if they do.
30. To #7 Harmen
John ,   Alaska   (08.03.11)
What does your response to #2 have to do with his post about the illegal Arab building in Samaria and Judea?
Next talkbacks
Back to article