Opinion
Israel no apartheid state
Yonatan Silverman
Published: 09.08.11, 00:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
31. #28 Rebecca
(08.09.11)
So your first response is ''Israel is not apartheid'' and if the court rejects that defence your alternative defence is '''well, the blacks were better off under apartheid anyway''. Sometimes its best to get a lawyer rather than conduct your own case.
32. Ynet,
Salma ,   Palestine   (08.09.11)
you confuse me so much.
33. #10 your analysis left out two important facts
Tahl   (08.09.11)
The blacks in South Africa have never sent suicide bombers into white population, nor have they shot rockets at white towns, or went into their settlements to kill children. They also did not teach their children that killing whites will get them into heaven. In short, the blacks have never waged any kind of war, and never advocated violence and murder upon the whites. As for who "drove out" the Palestinians - for the most part it was none other than the Arab leaders, who told the Palis to move out of the way so it would be easier for them to wipe out the Jews. Other Palestinians fled after they were defeated, fearing retribution from the Jews. Do your homework better for next time.
34. and north korea is a democracy !
anton ,   istanbul turkey   (08.09.11)
35. Long overdue and way too mild.
noa ,   israel   (08.09.11)
36. To: No. 23
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.09.11)
No, it is not apartheid. How can Israel "steal" what belongs to it to begin with? The ersatz "Palestinians" are interlopers, who come from the Hejaz in Western Arabia. The ones that live on the West Bank -- non-sovereign territory acquired by Israel in the course of fighting a DEFENSIVE war against Jordan and, therefore, Israel's to occupy, settle and even annex (that's coming) -- have no place in Israel and no right to live in our country and terrorize our civilians. Protecting oneself against suicide bombers and knife-wielding terrorists or stone-throwing terrorists is not apartheid. If you REALLY want to see apartheid, you need look no further than your own selves. Women throughout the Arab and Islamic worlds are not treated with the respect that is given to a stray dog. So please fix your problems before accusing Israel of anything. That should occupy you for the next millennium. The list of Arab and Moslem ills can go on without ending for at least that long. Imbecile.
37. To: No. 32
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.09.11)
It's not YNet's fault, dear. You confuse rather easily. Double-digit IQ, doubtless.
38. Settlers run apartheid state in WB
Daoud Kuttab ,   Jerusalem   (08.09.11)
I think there is a lot of confusion here. No Palestinian I know talks about apartheid in Israel. They talk about apartheid in Palestine ie areas occupied in 1967. Specifically the minority of Jews in the territories who have seperate laws, subsidized housing and water costs and live under civil law while the Palestinian majority live under Israeli military rule is where the aparthid exists. In Israel there might be other problems but the term is used only for the rule by minority of Jews in the West Bank against the majority of Palestinians
39. The opposite is the truth
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (08.09.11)
With the Arabs - whenever they accuse somebody of anything it is because that is exactly what they are doing. Take these moronic apartheid claims. We have no such laws - but EVERY single MUSLIM country practices apartheid. Where else are there laws that impose the death penalty for selling land to one group? Where else is immigration restricted to a single religion? Where else is the leader of the country required to be of a certain religion - oops there is England my bad. The list is endless. Then the claims of occupation - well that at least is true, just the identity of the occupiers is the opposite of the claims. The Arabs have absolutely NO LEGAL claims to any of the land west of the Jordan River - that is black letter international law. Their illegal occupation of our lands must end.
40. To: No. 38
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.09.11)
Did you like the West Bank better before Israel built hospitals, medical clinics, schools, universities, infrastructure and gave you indoor plumbing and electricity? Did you like the West Bank better when you had no paved roads? Did you like the West Bank better when it had one of the highest infant mortality rates in the world? Did you like the West Bank better when you had perennial cholera outbreaks? Did you like the West Bank better before Israel taught you primitive louts modern agricultural techniques? Did you like the West Bank better when you had 40% unemployment? Learn a little gratitude. If it were not for Israel, you'd still be living in the Stone Age. As it is, the ersatz "Palestine" Authority is sending you back there -- or haven't you noticed? Of course, Abbas has his private Gulfstream jet. What can be more important than that?
41. 11 - Jews being forced to live apart from the Christian ...
split ,   US   (08.10.11)
Really ? Who forces you to live in ghettos in US, to mention few of them in NYC, like Crown Hights, Boro Park, Williamsburg, or New Square up State N.Y. ? Who stops you to be a farmer, work in coal mine, build skyscrapers or bridges to be a lumberjack ?,...
42. To Andy
Luiz F Haddad ,   Niteroi, Brazil   (08.10.11)
Dear Andy, I do agree with you. I think all true Israelian's friends, around the world, do it also. I salute you.
43. It Will Be
Gordon ,   New York USA   (08.10.11)
...unless the Israeli government finally stops using the excuse that the Palestinians are not ready to govern themselves and begins to negotiate a settlement that will lead to a two-state solution.
44. Double standards
Ryan ,   Johannesburg   (10.29.14)
So Israelis are entitled to self determination and the promise of secure borders but white South Africans aren't?A hypocritical piece seeing as though our argument was also that Africans could not viably govern themselves and would rape and kill our families given the first chance.Care to look at murder and rape statistics for South Africa?If we were wrong,so is Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article