Opinion
The Protocols are back
Giulio Meotti
Published: 15.08.11, 19:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
31. Spectacular article
Mark Levin   (08.16.11)
It's very rare to' read and find such articles today
32. #28 Brod ...about paganism
marc   (08.16.11)
for Jews there is no difference between Catholics who like their fancy churches and Christians who like very plain unadorned churches. It is the belief that Jesus is the son of God which is regarded as a pagan concept. It is this pagan nature of Christianity which disturbed Mohammed and caused him to invent Islam.
33. Syrian Christian new Defense Minister
MedivalAntisemitism ,   Jerusalem Israel   (08.16.11)
I wouldnt be surprised if the new Christian Defense Minister who repleaced the murdered one is a Syrian Christian chosen most likely because as a member of Assad's inner circle a Christian would never dare attempt a coup Christian leaders in the Middle East are still infected with medival anti semitism and a complete acceptance of their 2nd class Dhimmitude status in the Moslem world not to mention many are involved in all kinds of curruption themselves and may be even blackmailed into making such statements.Interesting the Syrian Orthodox mentioned were slaughtered in their tens of thousands along with the Armenian holocaust by Turkish and Syrian Moslems in the Syrian Desert during World War1 .Modern "liberal "Protestant Christianity does not less in their virelent demonization of theJewish homeland.
34. The best answer which can be substantiated
Jerome ,   NZ   (08.16.11)
Spread this answer anywhere and everywhere you can. “12 million Jews have contributed to the world in terms of economics, technology, medicine and science equally to 7 billion pagans collectively”. Let them choke on jealousy.
35. discovering the lies
Stephen Harsch ,   Geneve   (08.16.11)
...it's Meotti's goal, a noble cultural campaign very rare in modern journalistic arena
36. We are against christianity ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.16.11)
So , those who say this , tell me how it's possible that you can FREELY observe your "religion" here , in this Jewish State ? You are persecuted here ? Tell me then how it's possible that your number is growing here , and this contrary to your numbers in your "friends" countries . Tell me how many Christians were murdered here for their beliefs ? Oh yes , we have imprisoned a "monsignor" ? do you remember why ? he smuggled weapons for a terrorist organisation . In many countries the same clergy is also imprisoned for crimes , pedophily . Are those NON Jewish countries anti christians too ? Those protocols must be read ? as someone said ? It should be banned in all democratic countries . There are to much people who can't think a little bit by themselve , who will take those 'writings" as telling the truth .
37. Christians pe4rsecuted here ? TRY # 2
charles ,   petach tikva   (08.16.11)
So , those who say this , tell me how it's possible that you can FREELY observe your "religion" here , in this Jewish State ? You are persecuted here ? Tell me then how it's possible that your number is growing here , and this contrary to the number in your "friends" countries . Tell me how many Christians were murdered here for their beliefs ? Oh yes , we have imprisoned a "monsignor" ? do you remember why ? he smuggled weapons for a terrorist organisation . In many countries the same clergy is also imprisoned for crimes , pedophily . Are those NON Jewish countries anti christians too ? Those protocols must be read ? as someone said ? It should be banned in all democratic countries . There are to much people who can't think a little bit by themselve , who will take those 'writings" as telling the truth .
38. skesslerfilm@gmail.com
Steveoh ,   Brooklyn   (08.16.11)
To #22 come to Brooklyn. Walk Atlantic Avenue before you get on that bridge you're trying to sell and chat with the Muslim booksellers on the street and in their shops. They have trouble keeping The Protocals and Mein Kampf on their shelves. One vendor I spoke with told me directly "I can't stock enough of these." So are you ready to start that negotiation on the Bridge I grew up walking, biking and driving across for 40 years. Ignorance is bliss. Enjoy your bliss.
39. protocols onceagain
noel ,   usa   (08.16.11)
dumb hateful goyim remain dumb hateful goyim -- no hope --since Christianity & Islam both fraudulant hallucinations designed for weak minded, illogical, & insecure.
40. Targetted Assassinations
Purity of arms   (08.16.11)
The time has arrived for a exponential increase in targeted killings as rosh hashana approaches because this is the real message of eating the head of the fish and not the tail.
41.  It is wrong to call this toxic document a “forgery”
Vincent Ferrigan ,   Stockholm   (08.16.11)
It is wrong to call this toxic document a “forgery”, since a forgery is a copy of something authentic. The Protocols are a mere fabrication, put together by Eastern Orthodox Christian fanatics in the pay of the tsarist secret police.
42. you wish Dino !!! we here in spite of you guys tring to kill
naftules ,   jerusalem   (08.16.11)
us ... why ? cause G-d said it would be so in the prophets ... and you my friend are on the Wrong side of history.
43. i would give my opinion ,
D.. ,   Haifa   (08.16.11)
but i know ynet will not post it , so i wont bother ....
44. #34 - yes, it seems that the admission
seadog1946 ,   Erie Basin, NYC   (08.16.11)
policies and quality of education at the "pagan" universities needs to be brought to a higher standard... at this rate, their graduates could never match the creativity of the scholars produced by "Jewish" institutions of higher learning. Yes, you should spread that message... there are billions of "pagans" ready to choke.
45. #28, 32, 39 - Asherah weeps... she longs to
seadog1946 ,   Erie Basin, NYC   (08.16.11)
return to her rightful place alongside Yahweh... in the long lost temple.
46. The Gospels are even more harmful than
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (08.16.11)
this garbage...!!!!!
47. Marc #32
Brod ,   USA   (08.16.11)
Obviously, your knowledge of Jesus is zero. There is no need to comment on a subject you don't know. Jesus' message is antithetical to Muhammad's kill, kill teaching. Both Papism and Islamist-Jihadism were the creation of a Luciferian god. In the End Time GOD will put an end to the dark forces.
48. 21,28&47-I'll be happy to match my knowledge of Christianity
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (08.16.11)
I translated the entire NT from ALL of the earliest extant source mss. up through the 4th century, as well as all of the Judaic sources up through the Even Bokhan -- which I know you have not. I read the same Bible as the historical 1st-century Pharisee Ribi in the original language, which I suspect you cannot. I've read Oxford historian James Parkes' classic on the Christian origins of misojudaism, The Conflict of the Church and the Synagogue, which you CLEARLY have not. I've read Eusebius, which you CLEARLY have not. I translate the Targumim from Aramaic which you clearly cannot. But Ynet won't publish the documented historical facts suppressed to this day by the Church, because Christians think the historical truth is offensive. So it's politically incorrect. While ynet is willing to publish baseless hate-spewing it deems harmless ranting, they censor serious contradictions of Christianity. Ynet has even refused to post that I've published an answer in our Web Café (URL below). So you win because Ynet won't publish serious historical truth that contradicts your spurious claims. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-observant Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Discrete Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, they have refused to post it. Find our reply in our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
49. Paqid #48
Brod ,   USA   (08.16.11)
You seem to have an impressive resume'. However, it is amazing that you still miss the mark. You don't know Jesus. You must have been reading some irrelevant literature. My first degree is in History. I have taken Ancient History, Church History, Biblical Archaeology, etc. I know the History of Papism and its 1260 years reign of terror during the Dark Ages commencing from 538 AD to 1798 when French General Berthier captured the Pope and incarcerated him. During this long dark period, millions of Judeo-Christians-Apostolic Christians, Waldensians, Albigensians, Huguenots, the Lollards, Protestants, etc were persecuted by Papism. Must Read books are as follows: "The Great Controversy" by Ellen G. White, "Romanisn And The Reformation" by H. Grattan Guinness "The Papacy" by J. A. Wylie "Unfolding The Revelation" (revised) by Roy Allan Anderson
50. 29 , paqid the big LIAR . TRY # 2
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.16.11)
If your tb is not published , try AGAIN and again . Don't always tell your christian lies .
51. #46 Chris, sorry, but I have to accuse you of "gibberish''.
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (08.16.11)
But I do think that the misinterpretation of the Gospels, and New Testament can lead to harmful consequences.
52. The Christians have killed their own mind
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (08.16.11)
first and then they tried to kill all the Jews...Christianity is the BIGGEST LIE in the history of mankind...!!!
53. You make remarks as ridiculous as Charles the atheist
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (08.16.11)
You assert what people don't know when you don't have no clue they know. I know, and the the historians--including the ones you cite--know that Jesus is a 4th century make-over of gentile Hellenist Christian redactions beginning in 135 C.E. and becoming fixed in the 4th century C.E. That is indisputably documented in Parkes' book and in many other historians' work since. It is also a historical fact that ALL of Christianity has derived from the 4th century Hellenist Roman Church, Protestants, evangelicals, charismatics, the works. There is no exception. Like it or not, as long as you remain in ANY part of Christianity, you are a branch from the root that you call "Papism."
54. Chris #52
Brod ,   USA   (08.16.11)
You don't know what you are talking about. Papism is NOT Christianity. There is no need to comment on a subject that you don't know. .
55. Paqid #52
Brod ,   USA   (08.16.11)
Apostolic Church from the time of Jesus and His disciples and Apostle Paul existed long before Apostate church-Papism emerged and ravaged the Christian Church with its Pagan practices. Forget about other literature. The sole authority of true Christianity is the Bible and the Bible alone-from Genesis to Revelation.
56. Brod , this paqid is a self proclaimed convert
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.16.11)
to Judaism . NO rabbanut has recognised his conversion . He's the biggest LIAR in the world , who tries to convert innocent people to his faith . He's a baptist minister , not a Jew at all . I am , contrary to him , a HONEST person and a 100 % Jew , but secular
57. 49 again: Cite legit historians, not your 7th Day preachers
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (08.16.11)
58. By the way, Jesus was NOT a Christ but
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (08.16.11)
a Jew...so much about Christianity !
59. The problem with the Gospels is not the
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (08.16.11)
teaching of Jesus, but the HATEFUL story about his death...ALL of this HATE was directed against the Jewish people...This is the wording AND the meaning of the Gospels...!
60. #14 Moshe, Jews who don't want it.
Michael ,   California, USA   (08.16.11)
In the U.S. every second person from Jewish parentage is marrying someone of non-Jewish parentage and two out of three children born to such mixed couples are raised as if they were from non-Jewish parentage. Similar process is taking place in Russia, England, France and elsewhere. This is why since the end of the last World War, in 1945, until today, three generations time, the number of those who call themselves Jews went from 10 to 14 million in the world. Jews vote with their feet, with their own lives and with lives of their children. The reason for it, in my opinion, is the Orthodox Judaism's attachment to irrelevant scripts, their inflexibility to modernize.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article