News  Tags  IDF
Palestinians say Gaza under major assault
Elior Levy
Published: 19.08.11, 04:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
121 Talkbacks for this article
31. Hamas’ military wing?
Ed ,   USA   (08.19.11)
Hamas’ military wing? Hamas makes no distinction between a military wing and a political wing. That this is such a distinction is fiction imposed by the EU in order to justify the absurd claim that Hamas (political wing) is willing to negotiate. Y-net should not be advancing this European fiction.
32. #12
Simcha ,   so.Cal.USA   (08.19.11)
Right! Too political.
33. terror
yacov ,   jerusalem   (08.19.11)
REMOVE OUR ENEMIES FROM OUR PROMISED LAND
34. To Lebanon Pride
Standing Tall ,   USA/Canada   (08.19.11)
Once your kind finally get it through your heads that Israel is here to stay and they can do much better with Israel around, there will be peace. As long as the PA and the Hamass organizations say it is ok to kill Jews, this is what you get. It's too bad that the Gazans decided to vote Hamass in, this is the start of a new war. The PA warning Israel to be responsible is the biggest joke of this century.
35. Lebanon Pride #4- loathsome liar
Stephen in New York   (08.19.11)
The Gazans killed in the initial Israeli strike were the leaders of PRC- -the group responsible for the attacks. Hardly "innocent." Those targeted in the current strikes are not butchers, bakers and candlestick makers.
36. #4 - no, they are dogs. vicious and
Arthru ,   SF, CA   (08.19.11)
murderous.
37. #4 LebanonPiss - get one thing straight. This is retribution
Harry Wright ,   UK   (08.19.11)
Address your lecture to Hamas, the killers of innocent people. When innocent Israelis get killed then expect "innocent" Hamasniks to get killed. Reserve your disgust for Hamas terrorists, asshole. If Pals are humans they should behave so.
38. Hamas is irresponsible ...
Alice ,   USA   (08.19.11)
...and evil to teach hatred to their children. This is all about jihad, pure and simple, until "all the world is Allah's." After Israel, they will come fo r the rest of us. It's in the Quran.
39. Why doesn't Israel put a missile or two
DT ,   TA Israel   (08.19.11)
through the PA HQ and shut a few useless mouths
40. Take out the PA at the same time.
Wise Saba ,   Ma'agalim   (08.19.11)
Get rid of all those terrorists in Gaza & Ramalla.
41. We are warning Israel
Niss ,   uk   (08.19.11)
Saeb Erekat "warnes" Israel but not the terror group because he thinks terror against Israel is ok as he thinks palistinains have a licence to carry out terror acts because the world sympathize with the palistinians and now we will see some staged films on tv news how injured babies and children on the palistinains side carried to cars to sympathize them palistinians are good at this
42. Yes Number 12 -
beentheredonethat ,   Israel   (08.19.11)
Apparently, you might be the only one. Do you live in Israel? Well I do. And I say - Yay Bibi and Barack - finish them off!
43. Palestinian Authority warns Israel to act ‘responsibly’
Daniel ,   Israel   (08.19.11)
Wow! What a warning!! Were you asleep when attack on innocent travellers took place? Were you safe keeping "Your Responsibility" under your pillow 'Abu Mahajan'?
44. Shouting or Thinking ?
David ,   Paris   (08.19.11)
In this kind of events, decisions should be made by thinking, not by shouting. Otherwise major mistakes can be very easy and lead to more Israeli deaths (i.e. 2nd Lebanon War). War or fight must not be stupid. I hope the ones who are shouting and screaming in this "talk back" will never be in charge of anything in the military or government ...
45. #4 Stop shooting at buses and all Gazans will be fine.
BK   (08.19.11)
46. I have only one word to say to Gaza
Shlomo ,   USA   (08.19.11)
Napalm!
47. No major assault at all. Just some open spaces
Harry Wright ,   UK   (08.19.11)
being ferociously attacked, some widening / upgrading of tunnels and some empty buildings being used for target practice. No need for concern. Go back to bed.
48. Netanyahu's right-on; Better refrain, border-stormers!
Daniel ,   Los Angeles, USA   (08.19.11)
It's not a good era for terrorists. We'll be putting their heads on pikes.
49. Major assault?
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (08.19.11)
That's a pretty exaggerated description. This is a ''love tap.'' Let me be DM for just a day - I'll show you what ''major'' means.
50. Oh, "act responsibly?"
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.19.11)
Did he really say that? Okay. Okay. Bomb their sorry asses into the Stone Age. That would be Israel, acting responsibly.
51. It's Just Hogwash!
copyleft ,   India   (08.19.11)
As soon as the attacks happened-or maybe even before that- the who-is-who in Hamas Terrorist directory went into hiding.All the IDF had to fire at were empty building and the likeliest casualty would be the idiot janitor that Hamas chose to leave behind to make a 'martyr' out of.Terror against Israel will continue so long as the Israeli leadership looks up to the Europeans and Americans for approval.The only way to put an end to Islamic terror is to strike at the head of the serpent.
52. after 18 years of peace talks the real erekat speaks
zionist forever   (08.19.11)
" The palestinians will not accept an Israeli attempt to use the terror offensive in the south in order to undertake belligerent acts against the Gaza Strip " Big words how are you going to back them up with actions, go to the UN maybe? In the old days he was very well spoken tried to make himself sound like a nice guy get people sympathetic to his cause. Now Erekat is not so charming and polite he is showing his true colors that he hid for so long by telling Israel don't respond to this act or else. Today the master peace negotiator issues warnings rather than condolences. Bibi needs to give the go ahead to carry out a military operation in Gaza similar to the one Sharon carried out in Jenin. Destroy the arms dumps, kill the Hamas sewer rats and just level the place, that will give Erekat something to make speeches about and make Israeli's safer.
53. right. the only responsible action is to eradicate this hama
ralph   (08.19.11)
hamas cancer. but that would aid the pa with nothing in return. make hamas pay we know their fingers are every where destroy the mansions they built for themselves and all administrative and military structures.
54. Erekat, don't worry we haven't forgotten about you. you are
ralph   (08.19.11)
next.
55. Concerned
Mark ben Josuf ,   USA   (08.19.11)
Apparently the Israeli government is positive of the source, though I have yet to read a claim of responsibility. The retaliation in Gaza seems to be less discriminate with civilians among the dead and missing. And the JPost reports Egypt being bombed with three Egyptian casualties. JPost also reports Turkey with planes in the air, unknown destination. Egyptian authorities have denied the Israeli government story about smuggling out into Sinai and then into Israel. Since JPost has reported Israeli bombing and killing of Egyptians, who knows what their military is doing? The US? Maybe. Other reports say Jordan told Israelis this might happen, but the warnings were ignored. Have to wonder if there is anybody really in control of anything at present. For Shlomo @ 46 - Napalm is supposed to be a jungle defoliant unless your intent is mass civilian casualties. Hopefully, somebody in the IDF is more rational than you are at this point. For Sarah @ 50 - Do you remember in the 1960s when American cities burned and students were shot in Ohio over the sometimes irresponsible use of force in Vietnam? Do you really believe that there is nobody in Israel with a conscience?
56. #4
Paul ,   Israel   (08.19.11)
Well, now. Besides the difference that the initial attacks by the Palestinian butchers targeted civilians intentionally ( they always target the defenceless), while the civilian casualties in Gaza are collateral damage, let's have a deeper look. Oh! There it is: The terrorists and their leaders are once again hiding behind the skirts of their civilians, using them as human shields, in the hope that this will stop Israel from targeting them. This is contrary to the Geneva Convention, in case you didn't know. Perhaps they don't even care if their own civilians are killed, as long as it makes good headlines and gives the world an excuse to criticize Israel. As Golda Meir said: There will be peace when the Palestinians learn to love their own children more than they hate us.
57. # 19
Madeleine ,   Rehovot Israel   (08.19.11)
Well we certainlydon't want the likes of you here. Your comment is meaningless. people move here because they want to be part ofthe Jewish homeland. You don't even say who you are or where you lve, so let me say this: If you in Eurabia or the U.S., deal with your own Arab/Moslem populations now before you are completely swamped by them. And if you are "one of them", well, there's no place for you here, is there? Just crawl back into your hole for now.
58. Now is time to take Shalit out of Gaza
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-ItLy   (08.19.11)
..and to take out of Gaza for good some of Hamas terrorist...do not be too soft on terror makers..
59. Remove Egypt from the picture - cut off Rafah for good!
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (08.19.11)
The ONLY answer to Iranian arms smuggling through Sinai and the unreliability of "peace partner" Egypt is straightforward: Israel must cut off the porous Rafah smuggling border from the rest of Gaza by conquering a 3-4 mile wide strip between Rafah and Khan Yousis, from the abandoned Dahaniyah PA airport to the sea. Export the few people in this desert dune strip to north or south, and turn it into a buffer that is de facto annexed to israel for good. Smuggling becomes impossible (too wide to tunnel under from either side), and line of forts down the middle (1 1/2-3 miles from Arabs, too far to tunnel to and hit. Heavy shelling of Gaza if they attack the buffer. Now totally dependent on Israel for everything, cut off from Sinai contact, nothing goes in or out except on condition of good behavior. Or no power and water from israel and no more of Hillary's pasta, no more luxury goods. Let the world whine, their Syria hypocrisy and impotence has discredited them. The French Navy can come and evacuate the terrorists from Gaza to Tunis just like they did the PLO from Lebanon. No more Iranian weapons, force Gaza to trade arms they still have for food and rebuilding supplies. No mkore truck convoys until damage to Israel is 100% compensated. And confiscate the PLO's tax monies to pay for the damage to Israel their Hamas unity partners did.
60. throw stones
wyatt ,   USA   (08.19.11)
What if a group of people starting lobing mortars into canada (and the US refused to protect you)? Would you be so worried about protecting the people who are living there or protecting your family. You live in 100% safety every day and have no idea what it's like to live in Israel. Should occupy this strip and weed out the militants, which i bet would be most, and end this.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article