News
Egypt recalls ambassador to Israel
Roee Nahmias
Published: 20.08.11, 10:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
1. A sad attempt to cover Egyptian incompetence in Sinai
Al Levy ,   Toronto   (08.20.11)
Egypt is in sad shape, and it shows when a large band (estimated at up to 20) of heavily armed terrorists brazenly goes under the noses of Egypt's military in the Sinai and launches a murderous attack against Israeli civilians. Egypt is paying a heavy price for their two-faced approach in the Sinai - ignoring terrorists and allowing smuggling of weapons and cash into Gaza. The Egyptian record is dismal. Their troops and security arms have been unable to stop the terrorists, while the best their soldiers seem to be able to do is shoot and kill dozens of unarmed refugees - including women and children - trying to sneak into Israel for a better life. Of course they withdrew their ambassador. It's about the only thing they could do to save face.
2. A gift...
Avi ,   IL   (08.20.11)
This is one of the gifted moments when you can turn around historical mistakes and turn them into an opportunity, they are known to twist turn lie and falsify the truth bluntly and with no shame so give them enough rope to hang themselves – let them bring the Egyptian army into the Sinai peninsula and in full force to deal with what goes on there and in time it will encourage them to make a move against us forcing us to a second six days war but this time we will take care of them and Gaza properly and for a good…
3. Time to conquer Sinai again
Mike ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.20.11)
4. no apology
fad egypt   (08.20.11)
israel was defending itself , hamas and the palestinian terrorists ve killed many security personnel and officers and we did nothing they bombed el arish and we did nothing why we are speaking now !!!! oh my country you ve been seeing dark days because of the stupid palestinian issue since 1948 !!!!!!! many many people ve been killed and our economy has been collapsed because of the wars and all that to throw israel in the sea !!!!!!! and to liberate palestine !!!!!!!! shalom
5. Shamelessness
Ali ,   6 October City Egypt   (08.20.11)
israel to withdraw its ambassador from Cairo now
6. It doesn't really matter.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (08.20.11)
The peace treaty is going down the toilet. Little by little, Egypt will renege on all their treaty obligations. They've made a good start already. Peace treaties & agreements with our Arab neighbors are the result of wishful thinking rather than common sense. Even very smart people deceive themselves by thinking that ''everyone'' wants peace. Not true. This isn't just wishful thinking but close-minded arrogance, the inability to see other cultures for what they are instead of what you want them to be. In America, it's already a bit of a joke as every calamity is called ''unexpected'' by the liberal media. It's only ''unexpected'' because they were blinded by ideology, sane & normal people predicted the consequences. So it is here in Israel. ''Unexpected'' .......
7. Perfect example of Arab logic.
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (08.20.11)
Makes as much sense as the last time they recalled their ambassador. Craven, hypocritical behavior. As anticipated, their highly touted "Arab Spring" signaled no improvement, just further descent into insanity.
8. US Congress, take note!
leo ,   nyc   (08.20.11)
Does this mean Egypt no longer needs congressional support? ie foreign aid???
9. "new Egypt " looking for new strategy against Israel
Anna M Sedda ,   Rome-Italy   (08.20.11)
It is quiet clear that the old Egypt is gone and that this "new-Arab spring" bullshit Egypt has found a good strategy to go against Israel,letting terror cells, maybe with the help of egyptian police border,to attack Israel and than,and only than,have a good reason to "take legal steps against Israel... This Muslim brotherhood Egypt is not longer in peace with Israel and will do everything he can to go against Israel... This is only a new beginning;the beginning of all "Arab spring terrorist" to attack Israel on all sides... Don t be naive,Muslims are Muslims,they do not change even if a black rock would come from Heaven...
10. Worthless Peace Treaty
leo ,   nyc   (08.20.11)
Egypt no longer sees any benefit in the peace treaty and really won;t support efforts to keep the border calm. It is quite possible that some of their forces in Sinai aided the terrorists that came into Israel. So with the gas pipeline shut yet again, it appears that the peace treaty between Israel and Egypt is really hanging by a thread-and that thread is the threat of an aid cut by the USA...we are light years away from real peace...
11. The results of another succeful
David ,   On this planet   (08.20.11)
achievement by the US current administration in the Middle East, The Oslo peace price receiver Barak H Obama his side kick Hillary Clinton and the US Jewish Democrats. What a lovely trio.....
12. egyptian feeling
ahmed ,   cairo   (08.20.11)
since when did we as real egyptians believe the peace treaty !! we know if israel have small chance to attack egypt it will do .. even if under the peace treaty . we don't seek to war , we want an official apology only . but if you want war , you should know that you will face people wish to die
13. Israel has become completely isolated...
Shlomo ,   Sweden   (08.20.11)
In the past, the shah of Iran was Israel's best ally in the region...Turkey and Egypt became close second... Today Israel has no one in the region but herself... Soon, Israel won't even have herself...With internal problems pitting Jew against Jew...I hate to be a Jew living in Israel these days...
14. We should have never given back the Sinai
Adam ,   Ottawa, Canada   (08.20.11)
All Israeli leaders who have given up land for a counterfeit peace are solely responsible for every drop of Israeli blood shed by these Arab murderers. Sharon gave away Gaza and we all saw what happened to him. Betray G-d and the Torah and you get yours
15. why did Israel apologize
Israel did it again ,   Baltimore   (08.20.11)
The terrorists came from Egypt. Egypt should apologize! Now Israel has apologized for doing nothing wrong, and as expected, the Egyptians go on the diplomatic offensive. Stop apologizing! Rather demand Israeli troops get to patrol the Sinai.
16. Quick question, if egypt tears up Camp David
Danny   (08.20.11)
Does Israel get the Sinai back? Does it get all the money back for the gas it paid for? Does Egypt give back all the aid it got from America?
17. Egypt asking for apologie
eridan ,   tel-aviv   (08.20.11)
may be , it is up to Egypt to apologize , as , the bus driver first attacked said that the terrorists were Egyptians soldiers... I do not understand why nobody is speaking about it .
18. Egypt (peace partner) reaction
Issy Hass ,   Ra'anana-Israel   (08.20.11)
What a quick success for Hamas after the reaction of the Egyption government who refused to point the finger at Hamasfor using itsborder to kill innocent civilians in Eilat-instaed Egypt itspeople to burn the eMBASSY AND CALL THE iSRAELI AMBASSODOR what a good peace partner
19. Netenyahu's Israel
sergen ,   ankara   (08.20.11)
a five years old baby and then five innocent egyptian soldiers.After that deaths, how will Netenyahu eat meat at his dinner and feel in sleep with peace of mind.
20. EGYPTIAN
muhammad ,   cairo   (08.20.11)
People do u really want war caze war is shit and every body will pain we want peace but strong peace with enough respect and at last i hope that Israel tell us the truth about what happened and it will over . I read some comments for people who want war i think any buddy talk about it dont know what it is really about at last if there in Israel ppl want peace there in Egypt too and there who want war and the same in Egypt ...........respect Peace is the solution. bye shalom el salam 3lekm
21. Israel only needs G-d
Adam ,   Ottawa, Canada   (08.20.11)
but thanks for your input Shlomo from Sweden. Btw, it must be great living in Sweden as a Jew. Try wearing a yamulke around
22. Who's Running Egypt, Anyways?
Ron ,   Boston, USA   (08.20.11)
Does anyone even know who's running Egypt? Feels like the Twilight Zone to me.
23. oh my
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (08.20.11)
it seems that when mubarak was in charge before we didn't see the full extent of the egyptian government's stupidity. this should get really embarrassing really fast for them.
24. egypt should wake up
Gadi ,   Israel   (08.20.11)
and see what is going on in her back yard called sinai. The egyption gonverment can't blame Israel for responsibility for the terror attack took place two days ago. On the contrary: Egypt should do some homework about the acts she has done for the last months, and stop terrorists in sinai before they reach the israeli border.
25. It's getting boring&predictable: they're doing a Turkey on
tom ,   tel aviv   (08.20.11)
us and expect Israel to come crawling with an apology for what's mainly their fault: enabling (most certainly adding as well) terrorist to come from their territory and kill us. It's same old same old.... and we never learn.
26. Isrealian stupid leaders
Raouf ,   Cairo, Egypt   (08.20.11)
a stupid way to get raid of internal protests in Israel. As usual Israel regime could kill his people to sustain.
27. Israel - Egypt Peace 1979- 2011 RIP
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (08.20.11)
Egyptians can allow terrorists, aided and abetted by Egyptian soldiers, to kill Israels but when Israel retaliates and kills the terrorists and those who aided them, then "Israel is politically and legally responsible for this incident". Of course, holier than thou Egypt is not responsible for letting terrorists to use its territory to kill Israelis. Egypt opened the Gaza border and is allowing terrorists from Gaza to use its territory to train there to kill Israelis! Egypt knows very well that the Sinai Peninsula was returned to Egypt as a result of the Peace Agreement and should this agreement be nullified, Israel and Egypt would once again be at war and the Sinai would be retaken! Is this what Egypt, weakened by internal strife, bankrupt and totally unstable, really wants? Think again Field Marshall Tantawi!
28. We are STUPID!
(08.20.11)
We should have returned OUR ambassador from Egypt and file a complaint over Egypt allowing armed terrorists to cross the International Border into Israel and kill civilians! They've briken already so many sections of the so-called "peace treaty" that one might think that we are still at war. And sadly, I believe that we'll soon be, as Sinai quickly becomes what Gaza used to be during the Fedayen times. So Egypt better do something about Sinai or Israel will, and then they can kiss their Sinai goodbye and I don't think that next time we shall talk about peace, they will get everything back as they did in '78. Egypt is quickly becoming Turkey #2 and we should learn how to deal with it based on the lessons we learned from the Turkish treason.
29. Egypt kills Sudan refugees but not Muslim terrorists!
(08.20.11)
If they want, they can prevent border crossing.
30. The murderer is blaming the victim again!
(08.20.11)
The Egyptians have the impertinence of blaming Israel for "not protecting its borders". Well, that's just like the murderer is blaming the victim for not locking the door more securely. Egypt, YOU are responsible for not allowing murderers from crossing the border FROM Egypt INTO Israel. We can't do anything until they actually cross the border. So Egypt - YOU are RESPONSIBLE and ACCOUNTABLE for this terror attack and your dead , corrupt and incompetent border soldiers. Your blame of Israel will NOT work, and it proves what we actually always knew - there is no real peace with Muslims, only if you are much stronger. We'll make sure you get a taste of our strength soon!
Next talkbacks
Back to article