News
Barak: Israel regrets Egyptian deaths
Ynet reporters
Published: 20.08.11, 17:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
31. to nr. 24.
sjoerd ruurd... ,   everywhere   (08.20.11)
to hell with the unjust and absurd right of veto and the permanent membership of france, the uk, (the peoples republic of) china, russia and of the us of a/of the states, of the dictatorship of the un-security council. the tasks, the job and the duties of the security council can better be done by the un-general assembly, which already represents the governments of almost every country in this world/on this planet, under the nearest sun, in this universe. let us have our common benefit with it/this/ the proposal in/of my talkback we also can say, i thought.
32. Selma
Ezra ,   Florida   (08.20.11)
You,Selma, certainly know a coward when you see one.You do not have to go far. Just look in the mirror. Leave your home for a moment and see them all around you. Yes these "heroes" of yours who don those kaffiah-masks to hide their identity, while wielding guns and shielding themselves by the kids they grab. Your "heroes" also keep sending rockets into civilian schools, homes, restaurants and what have you. They also ambush buses and murderl their passengers. Real HEROES.
33. time to expand the Gaza Strip?
inconito   (08.20.11)
the Egyptian air force is excellent and almost as powerful as the Israeli Air Force. Egyptian Navy has three times as many ships the Navy Israeli. the Army is over-equipped, with U.S. equipment. and demograpgic power is on the Egyptian side : 85 million against 7 millions. I ask just one question, and if the time had come to take over the Negev and expand the Gaza Strip?
34. The future
Paul ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.20.11)
The Egyptians have lost control, or are deviously giving control to have an excuse to jump back into continued hostilities with Israel. TAKE BACK THE SINAI NOW.
35. #28 Doug - This site "an apologist for the IDF"???
(08.20.11)
No, not really Doug ...and you know that. I know you came along read all these inane hot-headed comments...and thought . Damn it! I'm going to give these people a piece of my mind! We thank you sir for your invaluable contribution! PS: Would you prefer that we make this an PAL apologist site? If so GET ON YOUR KNEES DHIMMI!
36. Funny
Egyptian ,   Egypt   (08.20.11)
We didn't kill anybody from your army and you should clarify your actions. You shouldn't wait all of this time to comment on the incident. The incident violate the peace accord between the two countries. The terrorists that attacked you went through your border and they drove an Israeli car which is a failure from your side. A lot of African migrant cross your borders every day and you couldn't stop them either. Egyptian guards have to shoot them to stop them from going to Israel.
37. Good ole Ehud!!
Mark ,   USA   (08.20.11)
Gee Ehud..how about canning the regrets for Egyptian deaths, probably the result of the "arab spring", and do something so you won't have to give regrets to your people who deserve more than that...go give regrets to the families of those Israelis who were innocent yet killed! The Post claims that over 45 rockets have been fired so far..its that true, Ehud? Why don't you just go and get lost?
38. Ahmed the canibal
Ezra ,   Florida   (08.20.11)
What happened in 1956 &1967 and then again in 1973? You see, Jews are not canibals. They are just people who would like to live in peace. You, on the other hand preach for nothing but murder , murder and then again more murder. Now you add canibalism to your culture. I for one will never invite you for dinner. I have better food to put on the table.
39. 20 terrorists infiltrate from Egypt
Miriam ,   Jerusalem Israel   (08.20.11)
and Egypt wants to play like they have no responsibility. Guaranteed the IDF did not do the killing, but you will see the Egyptians escalating tensions with the Jews. It benefits them domestically and Internationally.
40. let me tell you about ''egyptian greatness''
(08.20.11)
35% of your citizens can not read or write. 30% live on 200 usa dollars a month and can not provide for yourselves but for cotton and tourists prymaids. were it not for that you would be eating sand flies. you elected crooked parliment. the schools there suck and no one learns past the 5th grade. all over arabs land is nothing but misery and disgrace. you honor kill your women. that is not much to be prouf of
41. indeed we'll make you regret breaching the Treaty twice
observer ,   Egypt   (08.20.11)
The MFO in Sinai reported that Israel breached the treaty twice; when troops crossed border and when shooting Egypt's soldiers.
42. Are relations worth it?
Michael   (08.20.11)
Turkey supported the flotilla and then recalls it s ambassador. Egypt opens its borders to terrorists and before an investigation is started talks about recalling its ambassador. What is the point of land for "peace"? they can recall their ambassadors anytime but can Israel recall the sinai?! what will happen in Judea and samaria when the PLO decide to have relations. Than they recall their ambassador? Wil Israel be able to recall Judea and Samaria ?! The Land for Peace deal is outdated. The formula just compounds the problems Israel faces. At best it temporarily defers the issue. Now the Sinai is becomming lawless like gaza and southern Lebanon. How long will the israeli government continue with shortsighted and dangerous policies?!Treaties are only as good as the people who sign them.
43. Regrets is not apology .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.20.11)
Those Egyptian border guards were probably also fighting the terrorists . A common enemy . But the Egyptians can NOT control the whole lenght of our common border . We can't do it neither .
44. egyptians looking for conflict......
Robert ,   farmington,wv   (08.20.11)
the egyptians are looking for a conflict , if this happened anywhere else nothing would have been said. after last months blood in egyptian streets and the record the egyptian army has against the israel defense force you would think they would tone it down , yes the egyptian army has got stronger over the years , but so has the israeli army and they still have God on there side... my advice to egypt is you can think it , you can say it , but dont do it.
45. #27,38 are parading their ignorance about regional culture
observer ,   Egypt   (08.20.11)
saying we are going to eat you alive is not like we eat hot dogs. dogs aren't dogs and hot is not usually hot. Remotely President Johnson said that they would make Nasser drink both Seas!
46. when there is legitimate reasons to apologize
Galut ia ,   selah   (08.20.11)
Israel does ... !
47. then lets END the peace treaty because its meaningless
ghada ,   Egypt   (08.20.11)
1) The peacekeeping force said that Israeli forces entered Sinai by land before clashing with the police unit at border point 79 and causing the deaths. 2) The peacekeeping force examined the boundary line where the clashes took place, recording several violations by Israeli troops, 3) and then Israel's Defense Minister says Israel deeply regrets the deaths of Egyptian troops killed during a shootout between Israeli soldiers and Palestinian militants. 4) And Barak approved the Egyptian request for a military investigation and a joint inquiry with the Egyptian army to clarify the circumstances of Friday's incident, when militants from Gaza crossed into southern Israel through the Egyptian desert and launched a deadly attack that killed eight Israeli. SO Israeli troops KILLED OUR SOLDIERS.. IN OUR LAND.. WHILE THEY WERE GUARDING OUR BORDERS as per the peace treaty we have … And you Don’t want to Regret or apologize.. ? We THE PEOPLE OF Egypt WILL NEVER ACCEPT THAT AND If You don’t like it , then lets END the peace treaty because its meaningless.
48. MR .BARAK PLEASE RESIGN
LAWRENCE ,   Zefat (Safed)   (08.20.11)
49. #17 you are so so correct
Rozie   (08.20.11)
Mr. Barak sould resign and SHUT UP. He will do his mouth and the people of Israel a favor. What a Moran. The only thing he know to say is to apologize.
50. Its all over the news here in the US that Israel apologizes
rachel ,   usa   (08.21.11)
for causing the death of egyptians.
51. #15 not the sephardic jews in france . My father and uncle w
(08.21.11)
were fighting and killing the germans
52. if we had not done it then the arabs kill themselves anyways
(08.21.11)
so what. look at how they live in syria, and all over the arab lands like barbarians that they are. price tag is all.
53. Fire thios effin idiot now..Israel is about to enter a long
Al   (08.21.11)
war. Netanyahu...either do your job or get out.. The poeple will throw you out like a rag should you not pony up and do the right thing. Fire Barak...Fire the IDF Commader Ganz they are both useless. When you stood up to Obama you showed you have balls...now get the dogs of war to crush the enemy. Dont give a damn if your financial friends in NY are worriied...the Jews of Israel in Israel need leadership. You are their PM. They demand that you do what has to be done to save them. Do your job or leave.
54. #8 Anton as you know very well th esaying in Turkish
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (08.21.11)
He who laughs last laughs the best (son gulen iyi guler). I haven't started to lough yet but you seem to be going berserk laughing to Israel under attack. The time will come when I will be laughing too. and since I will be the last to laugh you know how I wil laugh as the Turkish saying goes.... COK COK IYI.
55. #19 Egypt was great only when jews lived there . Since you p
rachel ,   usa   (08.21.11)
people kicked them all out ,its just a piss hole !
56. #22 sure.....don't mess with the zohar
(08.21.11)
57. #28 get off your high horse especially when you have no idea
rachel ,   usa   (08.21.11)
what is going on ..........
58. to 3 Salma
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (08.21.11)
So you have learned to squawk hahaha -not bad for an Arab squatter parrot.Print your address if you are not a coward.
59. excuse me?
max ,   Egypt   (08.21.11)
theif is a coward because he steals then he wait all time scared if someone catch him,build walls around him,has no friends ..everyone hates him..excuse me?i guess i am talking about israel..not arabs..israel who build a so great wall to protect it..israel has tunnels underground while pals get killed everday and never built tunnels to hide..israel soldeirs who escape from stones while they got guns...who is the coward?
60. i wonder why
max ,   Egypt   (08.21.11)
killing 5 egyptians by your hands dont need even an apology.. you burn all gaza because 8 of your men were killed .you say egypt should aplogize first for terrorists killing israeli soldiers..but the terrorists who killed them not US,lol let the terrorists apologize ..and Egypt is responsbale for its own land..the terror operation done on israeli land..you cant blame us for openning borders..you blame youselr because you did not protect borders from your side..we are no body guards.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article