Opinion
Don’t invade Gaza Strip
Hanoch Daum
Published: 22.08.11, 11:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. Respect ISRAEL first,fear ISRAEL second,united against Isra
david's SLING ,   ATLANTA GA USA   (08.22.11)
ISRAEL already has the united Arab world against it/us, but not united in attacking...Arabs now have TOO MUCH TO LOSE, TOO SELFISH TO ACT. As long as Israel can reverse ANY arab countries 20th/21st century progress by flattening them in a 24 hour war, and returning them back to starving desert wanderers, Israel is respected and feared... GO ISRAEL GO! nothing like assured destruction to make an enemy hesitate.
32. OPERATION SAMSON: KEEPS THE A**HOLES OUT!
Jewish Doctor ,   NYC, USA   (08.22.11)
walk softly (and unafraid) and carry a VERY BIG stick. and don't fear anyone but yourselves. It doesn't matter if every arab wants you outed, as long as they know it will cost them everything, Israel has nothing to fear except it's own ineptness i.e. Peretz and his ilk.
33. Ummm...the whole Arab world is already against us!
Jayjay ,   Israel   (08.22.11)
WHat happened to the ISrael that wasnt scared to show some strength? Arabs only respect force! I wish our politicians would realize that!
34. #5 Well said Terry...my sentiments exactly!
Jayjay ,   Israel   (08.22.11)
35. CUT GAZA ALL SERVICES
MILLY   (08.22.11)
water, light, supplies, gas, EVERYTHING. If Israel do not exist for them neither the services.!!
36. wishful thinking
Leor ,   Be'er Sheva   (08.22.11)
i'm afraid reality that walking on egg shells only proves our lack of conviction and self-determination to lead a normal life. are we not allowed? sucks to be under attack.
37. hanoch daum is right.
celine woland   (08.22.11)
this article was reassuring and i hope, it will be the way hanoch daum hopes it will be. just the aerial atacks , no ground op. a good common sense approach in a dangerous situation.
38. External factors leave 1 option: BIG ISRAEL
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (08.22.11)
39. Israel & Palestinians must live as two countries in peace
DR JULIAN G. DARWISH ,   LA, CA , USA   (08.22.11)
In order for Israel to live in peace and prosperity in the middle east; it must recognize Palestine as arab country and live together side by side in peace with 67 boarders not 48 according to UN rules before. arab world recognize Israel as one middle eastern country among them; why Israel does not give the Palestinian people the same right live and let other live?????why?
40. Yes,invade the Gaza Strip
Tomy ,   Israel   (08.22.11)
That's the only way if we don't want to live for ever under rockets,if we don't want to create situation were we use to die at our homes,when we use to see our cities and our Kibbutz's destroyed,where we use to go to fortified schools.... YES INVADE AND TAKE THE ENTIRE GAZA STRIP NOW!!
41. Retake Gaza forever.
Chaim ,   Israel   (08.22.11)
The solution is the reversal of what caused the problem in the first place. What caused our last Gaza War and the tens of thousands of rockets from Gaza and all the problems we are having with Gaza? Our retreat from Gaza. Given that our Gaza problems all stem from our retreat from Gaza; the solution is obviously to retake Gaza forever, and to demolish our enemy within Gaza. It's basically the same solution which won WW II for the Allies and brought permanent peace to Europe and Asia.
42. Israel is wasting time
Jose Farias ,   Sao Paulo - Brasil   (08.22.11)
She should be prepared in advance and give an answer promptly after any attack from terrorists. Where are the people responsible for defense of Israel?
43. Weak argument.
alien ,   ok, usa   (08.22.11)
This is a patently ridiculous argument. The arabs are already united against Israel. So is the UN.
44. WHERE IS THE SOCIAL JUSTICE FOR JEWS?
David ,   NJUSA   (08.22.11)
Why doesn't Israel defend itself?
45. Don't Invade Gaza
Sarah ,   Jerusalem Israel   (08.22.11)
Hate to say it, but he's right. If you read the Arabic papers as well as others (and not just western or Israeli press) you'll see that most of the rest of the world has figured out that this is Assad's Ploy: Tehren is worried that it's Damascus puppet may fall, so rather than that happen, they are helping Assad encourage the PRC and Hamas to raise hell with Israel. This will detract world media attention from Assad's slaughter of his own people (since Libya is almost over, and NATO is newly available to hit Damascus) AND will draw Israel into Cast Lead II and give the Palestinian's a HUGE propaganda victory right before September and with any luck at all, weaken Egypt and destroy the peace treaty (although this would just be gravy). There is a concept in American football called "offsides." This is where an opposing player is tricked into making an illegal move, and the opposing team is penalized for that illegal move. Invading Gaza will only advance the interests of Syria and Iran, and Israel witll be penalized for being "offsides." Do NOT fall for this.
46. Hanock Daum is a sissy
Richard ,   Boca Raton USA   (08.22.11)
Ok so we don't invade Gaza. Now what? Let the Arabs start up again with Rockets at a latter date and possibly kill Jews. Hanock you are a sissy!! How about thurning the Gaza into a parking-lot buffer zone where no rockets could harm Jews. Oh, you are worried what the rest of the world thinks. That is such a weak position, and the world will think of Jews again as weak and trembling. You disgust me.
47. Don't need big invasion, just cut Rafah from rest of Gaza
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (08.22.11)
No huge land operation is required, the objective should be to cut off rocket smuggling by isolating Rafah from the rest of Gaza, with IDF punching through the 5 miles to the sea across the sand dunes between the Rafah border and Khan Younis. Create a fortified No-Mans-Land 3 miles wide, too wide to tunnel under and ban all surface travel from the Rafah border. That stops rocket smuggling for good, because Israel should never withdraw from this barrier strip. THEN is makes sense to target rocket supplies with air strikes, because they can't be replaced. Arab world united against Israel,.They do that when Israel is only defending itself - look at Arab League resolution of yesterday, which doesn't even mention the cross-border raid ot Grad attacks, only Israeli air strikes - they are the enemy?? It is obvious the writer of the article doesn't live in Ashdod, Sderot or Beersheva, but is corresponding from a nice safe leftist coffeehouse in Tel Aviv. The emotions and sensibilities of countries and peoples who reject Israel's right to exist and defend itself should NEVER be taken into account when devising responses to attackson Israel!to
48. Appeasment
Michael ,   Madison,nj USA   (08.22.11)
So what's the solution? Israelis should just learn to live under rocket bombardment? How depressing. What happened to Jewish pride and skills?
49. oy ,what an idiot!
(08.22.11)
the arab world IS united against us, no matter what we do!
50. oooh, Arab world, christian world against us. Coward.
USA   (08.22.11)
51. attack
colin   (08.22.11)
Again the cowardly groveling defence minister barak with feeble excuses. Now the arab nations will unite against Israel!!!! What is the United Nations ??? Another name for arab union !!The world is against Israel !!!We saw the cowardice before the holocast with all these excuses. And now hamas says the ceasefire is TEMPARY !!! Get rid of this scared swine and let someone who will defend Israel take the defence minisry.
52. Hanoch - you fool!
Lila ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.22.11)
That's EXACTLY why the terrorists struck now - so we'd be AFRAID of retaliating. Proving once again that to the fools who run this government, and those who think like them - Jewish blood is cheap, and we can get by with a million people in bomb shelters so the world won't support a PLO terror state. Except that they're going to vote for it anyway, fool!! So let's go into Gaza and get the job done of wiping out the rockets and those who fire them!!
53. aren't the arabs already united to destroy Israel ?
omberg ,   NYC   (08.22.11)
the author of this crappy article should move to Eshkol, sderot or beer sheva....
54. Typical "Ghetto Jew "mentality.
Howard ,   Seattle WA   (08.22.11)
55. Don't attack Gaza
ronnie ,   Philadelphia USA   (08.22.11)
Altho I am not Israeli.I cannot understand his logic that it would unite the Arab world against us. THEY ARE!!
56. Do you want one more Hetzbollah?
Shalom ,   U.S.A.   (08.23.11)
The only way to prevent it is a large scale operation, eliminating the leadership and its infrastructure. The only question is the timing, before of after September? Or waiting for another round of violence , a few more israeli lives lost? Time is working in their favor!
57. Gaza invasion
Faroom ,   Tehran, Iran   (08.23.11)
There's nothing wrong with aza that a couple of thermobaric weapons can't solve. even if they are exploded where all they do is minor damage, start at 5 km or whatever away and move closer with each rocket...
58. What Israelis want is a closed Border.
JO   (08.23.11)
Let Gaza be it's own country with closed secure borders with Israel. Until it changes it ideology there can never be any unity for Palestinians and no peace or realization of any "Palestine". with a safe and secure Israel beside it.
59. hanoch daum-"" do not invade..."
sjoerd ruurd van der ,   mankindland etc.   (08.23.11)
more or less i can agree with this opinion. an invasion in this case can be considered as an act of unnecesarely, war-like/war-mongering agression, by the rest of the people of humanity/mankind.
60. don't invade faza...LET THEM KILL US
les ,   canada   (08.28.11)
hanoch, maybe you are just too young to think clearly, or it may be it is worst than that. if oil did not "unite" the arabs, gaza sure won't! if they cared at all, would they allow them to live like rats there, or in lebanon, or in syria, jordan at al.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article