Jewish Scene
Who removed IDF prayer from siddur?
Ari Galahar
Published: 30.08.11, 15:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel should send them all out of the country
Daniela   (08.30.11)
and not allowed them to come. goal nefesh !
2. prayer for the state of Israel
dr daniel mostrel ,   paris france   (08.30.11)
send him to teheran
3. Find the culprit
Sagi   (08.30.11)
and when he is found an immediate deportation order should be signed by the Minister of Home Affairs to be implemented within 24 hours and with no question of referral to the courts for an injunction.
4. "Medinat Israel He Reshet Geulatanu!"
Israela ,   Israel   (08.30.11)
The State of Israel is the beginning of our Salvation.
5. TZA'HAL: Yad Yemin shel Elokim!
Israela ,   Israel   (08.30.11)
Israel Defense Forces: The Right Hand of G-d!
6. Kol HaKavod L'Tzahal! (All honor 2 the IDF!)
Israela ,   Israel   (08.30.11)
7. this is nothing new..
Eddie ,   London UK   (08.30.11)
if you manage to find a siddur in any haredi yeshiva or synagogue, which has the prayer printed, they will have defaced it already.
8. His hands should be crushed!
jason white ,   afula, israel   (08.30.11)
These neutrei karta kapos do not deserve to live here in Israel or any other place on Earth. Israel should be hara-dim free, unless they start to serve in the I.D.F.
9. #5 The Multi-versatile Left Hand AND Foot?
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (08.30.11)
10. Neturei Karte is not alone.....
Shalom ,   U.S.A.   (08.30.11)
They are not the only hassidic sect who refuse to daven for the State of Israel. Unfortunately there are quite a few"Do not sing that disgusting song" the HaTikvah. Belive it or not but that's what I heard from a hassidic rabbi!
11. These can't be Jews!
Keren ,   IL-BR   (08.30.11)
Religious Jews should (and normally they do) always pray for their fellows-secular and not,and their fellows(seculars) should wish also the best for religious.
12. deport to gaza
judah ,   Israel   (08.31.11)
13. LOVE THY NEIGHBOR
ELI ,   BROOKLYN NY   (08.30.11)
Jason degrading a group of people to feces is very crude. Teaching tolerance is what you should do.
14. What is a siddur?Bishvil ma hashtut hazot?Get rid of it now!
Michael ,   California, USA   (08.31.11)
15. Put it in the prayer books in the mosques too
Mordechai   (08.30.11)
I assume all the people who want to deport any haredi who does not say the prayer for the state of Israel also agree that any Israeli muslim who does not say the prayer should also be deported. After all we can't be racist Securlar Jews including Meretz members must also agree that Israel is the start of the redemption. One law for all
16. That's simply not true!
Rabbi Yoni ,   Israel/USA   (08.31.11)
Every Sepharadic siddur in every Sepharadi Charedi Yeshiva has the prayer for Tzahal in it, as ordered by HaRav Ovadia Yosef himself! Watch who you attack. - Rabbi Yoni
17. this fifth column should be destroyed
dante ,   uk   (08.31.11)
18. Haridi dangerous to Israeli health
Norman Gellmnan ,   Rehovot   (08.31.11)
Just another manifestation that the Haridi community is in fact dangerous to the health of state of Israel! I do not see any real logic for the government to continue to finance them and their institutions. They are in fact against the existence of the state of Israel. We should stop tolerating them they fallaciously think they are the true Jews.
19. #7 - why the confusion?
Shalom Hartman   (08.31.11)
You appear to be confused - people use hareidi to refer to anyone in a black hat. The majority of "hareidim" are regular, good, non-chassidic people who would never dream of defacing a siddur, or anything else for that matter. They don't kick girls out of schools, neither do they burn trash cans. Enter neturei karta nuts and their friends and give all orthodox jews a bad name
20. #9 those r the secret weapons! nod wink!
(08.30.11)
21. thank u Israela! I agree w/u 100% Kol HaKavod l'tzahal!
avi ,   israel   (08.30.11)
22. #18 you live in Israel - you should know the difference
Rebecca ,   Modiin   (08.31.11)
between ordinary and Neturei Karta. Most Chardim are solid citizens, even if they long for a state based on religion. NK .. there are no words to describe that band of nut cases. Chardim might not openly condemn them, but they certainly do not associate with them.
23. haredim are too lazy too work, so they
David ,   manchester,UK   (08.31.11)
hide in their books
24. Prayer books
TLJ ,   BrooklynNY   (08.31.11)
Its high time to get rid of the people that don't like our great country. You don't like us, move out! If you are here, shut up and get with the program.
Back to article