Culture  Art&Culture
Gibson slammed over film on Jewish hero
Reuters
Published: 11.09.11, 10:55
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
31. To Daniel 17
Shai ,   IL   (09.12.11)
Israel was occupied by foreign forces for some time by the time of the Maccabean Revolt. The revolt only occurred when the occupying forces refused to allow the Jews to practice their religion as they saw fit. The Maccabean Revolt was against religious coercion and didn't target civilians as a means of gaining political leverage. That's why it wasn't terrorism, and that's the difference between the terrorists you mentioned and the Hasmonean brothers who led the revolt. Learn a little history, Daniel.
32. You gotta love the irony of it all
Cameron ,   USA   (09.11.11)
33. A universal hero in the struggle for religious liberty?
Orly ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.12.11)
No, Mr. Foxman, Judah Maccabee deserves better, he was a hero in the struggle for religious hegemony - but certainly not liberty.
34. D'Bag
Joe ,   Florida, USA   (09.12.11)
Even a D'Bag like Gibson has the right to make a movie, and pretend he's not the D'Bag we know he is. But he spoke his mind in 2006, so at least we know that he's a putz. We no longer have to wonder IF he's a putz.
35. article fails to explain what is insulting
Herbert   (09.12.11)
poorly written non-article, go back to journalism school or go do something else
36. @ 7
Ignacy ,   Babice, Poland   (09.13.11)
I would.
37. Froike # 18 you write:
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.13.11)
"Isn't that a concept of Tshuvah?” That's fine and dandy; however Tshuvah is only for Jews which the old guy is not. Then you write: "Perhaps old Mel is seeing the error of his ways and making an attempt to apologize for his past by making this film?" To that I say "no" and I bet you the main reason he is trying to make this film is because he knows he is all washed out as an actor and no Jewish producer/director will give him the time of day by offering him any gig. Therefore he is attempting to produce, direct and act in his own movie. This is what’s behind this feeble attempt to make amend...that's all.
38. arabs are the invaders
arad ,   arad,israel   (04.14.12)
Judaism, is the native culture, religion and ethnicity of this land
Previous talkbacks
Back to article