News
Israeli man to give birth
Sarit Rosenblum
Published: 12.09.11, 23:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
70 Talkbacks for this article
31. sorry, don't believe this piece
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (09.13.11)
doctors have yet been able to give a man the ability to produce an egg. Just like they can not give a woman the ability to produce sperm. Look deeper and this will turn out to be a farce.
32. Hope she can still breastfeed
Lemmings Hotline ,   sd usa   (09.13.11)
That would have been a selfish act to remove breastfeeding capability for asthetic purposes.
33. no mother
Daniel ,   Germany   (09.13.11)
That's funny, the baby will not be Jewish, because it won't have a Jewish mother. At least, no mother at all.
34. Jakob and others similar
Daniel ,   TA/DC   (09.13.11)
Jakob I am so sorry you are unwell. You should seek treatment. Perhaps an anti-emetic and lessons in tolerance and humanity. Transgenders are people born into the wrong gender for their psyche. They are therefore always truly the gender to which they ascribe and if possible become. To feel badly for them when they are in the wrong body is like feeling badly for a person with diabetes. It is something with which they can live but they are not comfortable. This man is bringing life into the world would all you religious people suggest he have an abortion? This is a mitzvah! A baby is being born to loving parents who happen to both be men. Mazel Tov!
35. Sarah B.
Lowe Nakhon ,   Chicago   (09.13.11)
Sorry Sarah B. I can understand your confusion but... An hermaphrodite is a person BORN with both male AND female genitalia. This man removed his breasts but still has a functioning uterus. He is therefore transgender and for once YNET did not screw up the English.
36. Birds & Bees
Cindy Matthews   (09.13.11)
Eh, hello? Men don't have babies, women do. Even if you dress the woman up to look like a man, that doesn't make her a man - pregnanacy is proof. So stop playing "What's My Line?" and get serious young lady.
37. Well, uh....
Cameron ,   USA   (09.13.11)
38. "The man who was born as a woman..."
Jake ,   USA   (09.13.11)
...is still a woman
39. Poor kids!
JewishHeart ,   Israel   (09.13.11)
I feel sorry for the confused kids who is taught by a very confused woman.
40. 'Bearded Lady' is the correct term
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (09.13.11)
Nothing unusual about bearded ladies. There may be something unusual about her partner though? Still whatever turns you on, although whatever turns you off might be more appropriate here? I agree with talkbackers that show concern for the child. Hopefully, by then her maternal instincts will come to the fore and the mohel can perform two brits in one day!
41. Poor kid gonna grow up sooo confused.
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.13.11)
I guess everything's possible. LOL. now questions arise 1. is that guy both mommy and daddy ? 2. who will suckle the bibi ? Well, I just think it goes against nature, and I don't like that. he is a he and she is a she.
42. DNA is useless
ZT ,   USA   (09.13.11)
A DNA test won't be helpful, because even when people undergo a full normal sex change their DNA stays the same. Furthermore, there are cases of people being born with atypical sex chromosomes (something other then XX or XY) and of people who are born with one set of chromosomes but exibit more traits of the other sex. Sex and gender are not as simple as we are often led to believe.
43. To #19 and #20
Dr. David H Stern ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.13.11)
#19 "She was born a women, she's giving birth as a woman, end of story." #20 "She becomes a he so "he" can marry a guy?!" It's not the end of the story but the beginning, in several senses: (1) This person wants to be known as a man, but she isn't really. So I will refer to her as "she" and "her," but primarily to avoid confusing anyone, not an expression of my own ideology. (2) We don't know her name, so I am calling her "K." (3) K is a woman who functions sexually as a man. I suppose this means her sexual partner is a woman, a woman who obviously could not have impregnated her. So how did K become pregnant? It could have been by artificial insemination. I don't see how it could have been by sexual intercourse with a man, since her (K's) parts don't allow for that -- unless whatever operation was performed on her did somehow allow for it. To me it's a mystery. Can anyone explain it? (4) If K keeps her baby and raises it, it will certainly have identity problems, and if K loves her baby, which she ought to, I hope she will try to help the baby deal with them.
44. i think its called a "starpadicktome" ?
Haim ,   TA   (09.13.11)
Anyway good luck with the pregancy :-)
45. 'Gender Bender'
Natalie ,   Karmiel   (09.13.11)
So the Age of Ambivalence has now hit Israel!
46. There is a place for people like him
American Sabrah ,   Israel   (09.13.11)
Its called the circus of freaks.
47. Israeli man to give birth
Shoshie Borchardt ,   Migdal Israel   (09.13.11)
I don't know what all the excitements about - "he" was a woman hence the reproductive organs.... I personally thinks it's disgusting.
48. She's a woman
John ,   Tel Aviv   (09.13.11)
He/she kept female reproductive organs - she's a woman, not a man.
49. What is done is done
Devorah   (09.13.11)
Our hearts and thoughts should be with this baby who will be facing an uphill battle.
50. Seriously you are so closed minded
lol ,   Israel   (09.13.11)
Grow up people, you are all so closed minded and self centered. The person wishes to be a MAN, HE!! is a MAN. Stop pushing your IDEALS onto others, and stop acting like you are better then everyone. SHAME ON YOU! Learn to accept people for WHO THEY ARE. SHAME, SHAME ON ALL OF THE JEWISH NATION.
51. lol
(09.13.11)
Do you KNOW anyone of a lesbian/gay couple? no, you probably don't. But I do, and guess what? They are all NORMAL PEOPLE WITH NO MORE ISSUES THEN YOU
52. YNET Shame!!!
jj ,   NZ   (09.13.11)
..Israel's on the brink of war..and you come up with this rubbish for news!!! A woman having a baby is news!!! Get some real news that will benefit the nation of Israel not confuse it further!!!
53. Maybe
Mike Van Harris ,   Antwerp Belgium   (09.13.11)
Maybe Natenyahoo is the father, WOW. weard country and weard people.
54. Puhauhauhauahuahauhauha XD
Can ,   Istanbul   (09.13.11)
55. I must say this is a very sad situation
miri ,   israel   (09.13.11)
and I bless my normal children.
56. Nobody's perfect
LolaFalona ,   Los Angeles   (09.13.11)
Some people here are just so judgemental, it's disGUSTing!
57. tolerance
Tammy ,   USA   (09.13.11)
You want to talk about intolerance and racism but your comment is the same. You are judging all Israelis by the comments of the few ignoramuses who chose to respond to this article. Democracy with freedom of speech unfortunately also allows the bigots to have their say. Have you ever read what idiotic Americans write as their comments to such articles? And no one claims we are not a democracy or that one American's bigotry speaks for us all. Take a deep look inside yourself before you accuse an entire country of intolerance and racism based on the comments of a few.
58. Disgusting!
Chana varon ,   Atlanta usa   (09.13.11)
Israel is suffering because of sins like this!
59. If you think this is strange?
Koose E Mack ,   NY NY   (09.13.11)
This sounds like an Enquirer article! A similar child was born in England about 2 years ago. The proud mother and father watched through the glass window as the nurse held up the baby. The "father" said to the "mother"..."That one is certainly ours! Look how quiet and well behaved he is!" The nurse replied, "Oh no...if you think he's quiet, wait till I pull the pacifier out of his ass!:"
60. Scoundrel!
Jack Mehoff Hagan ,   NY NY   (09.13.11)
Where did you get a photo of my wife? husband? Wife?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article